From: "Patrick Bennett" Date: Wed, 06 Jul 2005 06:17:10 +0000 Subject: Fw: footer isn't appended to multipart messages (part II: reality check!) Message-Id: <002601c581f2$57f28ef0$6564a8c0@stnick> List-Id: References: <200507052130.02825.lists@seattleserver.com> In-Reply-To: <200507052130.02825.lists@seattleserver.com> MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit To: mlmmj@mlmmj.org oops, forgot to cc the list. apologies. -Patrick ----- Original Message ----- From: "Patrick Bennett" To: "Casey Allen Shobe" Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2005 11:14 PM Subject: Re: footer isn't appended to multipart messages (part II: reality check!) > Alright, first, not intending to have started a flame war whatsoever, > but.... well, anyway, hoping I'm being read in a tone that takes it down a > notch and injects a bit of humor.... > > I think we (ie. "free/open source" software developers {you, I presume}, > administrators {me} and users {lots of oft strident and fanatic folk out > there}), often miss the boat by insisting our preferences must be foisted > as "the one true way" on all the other innocent users out there (and by > "users" I mean not just end-users, but purchasing decision makers, pointy > haired bosses, systems administrators, etc.). This, imho, is one large > factor that hinders open source software adoption by "the stupid users", > the business world, pointy haired bosses, ad infinitum. Don't we come off > as a bit kooky with such unbending sloganeering? We do propose to create > in the bazaar, rather than the cathedral, no? I thought the point was to > create high quality, highly flexible software and share it with the world > for everyone's mutual benefit..... or maybe I got that wrong and it is > instead to create a "free as in beer" fourth reich. > > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "Casey Allen Shobe" > To: > Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2005 7:38 PM > Subject: Re: footer isn't appended to multipart messages (part II: reality > check!) > > >> On Tuesday 05 July 2005 23:32, you wrote: >>> This is absolutely true- you (that is to say, *we*, that is to >>> say techie/programmer types) find this stuff very annoying. >>> However, mailing lists are used by knitting clubs too, and I, for >>> one, DO NOT want the nightmare of administrating a knitting club >>> mailing list that has absolutely no dependable notification of >>> "how to do it yourself". >> >> Reality check indeed: knitting club members aren't going to have a >> clue wtf the reminder mail or appended text means. They don't >> understand what "unsubscribing from a mailing list" is, they just >> use a particular address to talk to other club members. If they >> want off the list, no matter how much you spam them with >> instructions, they will ask the head of the knitting club to do it. >> I'm on some lists which append unsubscription messages to every >> mail, and guess what I see posted there all the time? empty >> messages with "unsubscribe" subjects (often with unsubscribe >> misspelled, not that it matters since that's not how the lists >> work). >> > > You're right, my hypothetical "knitting club" was probably too far on the > other end of the spectrum and thus a poor example, mea maxima culpa. My > target users are actually in between- comfortable with technology, but not > professionals nor geeks. They desire obviousness and convenience and more > or less easily understand and are eager to follow a terse "unsubscribe > footer" or regular reminder; but are frustrated by enforced ignorance. > The damn shame of wasting a few hundred bits of bandwidth a day on a > helpful (to them, but obviously not to you) footer, or a few hundred bits > of bandwidth a month on a helpful (to them, but obviously not to you) > how-to-be-a-good-mailing-listizen email is utterly lost on them. Some of > them, only a few mind you, might even actually have a background jpg > embedded into their email. {Gasp!} > >> Also, even though Outhouse Express is not yet one of them, many mail >> clients have built-in support for List-Unsubscribe header which >> enables a button for unsubscribing from the list. >> > > I wasn't aware of this feature. Cool. I'll see if I can get it to work. > Any further info on how to implement this? > >>> not sure which "example" you mean >> >> The example you asked about: appending footers with >> subscribe/unsubscribe information. >> >>> For other lists, on the contrary, it should be *encouraged* (see >>> above)! >> >> I could not disagree with this statement more. You really think >> that when I (the idiot user in this example) feel like >> unsubscribing that I'm going to wait around for the next monthly >> mail or go digging around for an old one? No, I'm going to whine >> to the list owner or whomever I think is in charge if I can't >> figure things out, and probably just the whole list to make sure >> somebody hears me. >> >>> 1) I haven't found the documentation on how to enforce text-only >>> mailing lists >> >> You could filter incoming messages with something like maildrop or >> your own script. Not sure how you'd go about mingling this with >> mlmmj, perhaps somebody else can answer that. >> > I had inferred (apparently incorrectly; a thousand apologies) from > something another respondent had said that there was a mlmmj built-in > method for enforcing text-only posting. Thus, my comment about not being > able to find any documentation on it. > >>> 2) not sure what happens on a text-only mlmmj list when a >>> multi-part msg is sent, but [it] has to handle the >>> default settings of widespread [...] email clients [...]. >> >> Short answer, if you want HTML mail to reach the list, then don't >> block it. If you care about people seeing signatures on every >> single mail (even the HTML ones), then don't allow HTML. You can't >> (easily) have your cake and eat it too. >> >> Long answer, you *can* have your cake and eat it too, but it will >> require substantial work on your part to reduce the messages (which >> I don't think you're actually willing to do or you might have just >> implemented multipart footer appending yourself): >> > If I understand correctly, and I may well be mistaken, other mailing list > softwares out there in the open source world (gnu mailman comes to mind as > an example), are able to handle appending footer messages to a wide > variety of incoming email formats. No suggestion that, coding wise, this > is accomplished *easily*, but just that it would be cool (and, in > particular, useful to *me*) if mlmmj could do it as well. Besides, I > doubt a corrupted final email (that is to say, a multi-part mime mail with > a plain-text footer appended to it inappropriately) is the goal of the > mlmmj crafters. If I were both 1) an experienced programmer, and 2) an > expert in email protocol, formats, etc., you're right, I could implement > this my own damned self, couldn't I?!? As it is, I've just wasted every > one's time with my unworthyness and rubish opinions. > > >> Another answer, if you just want a monthly/weekly/whatever reminder, >> just mail the list from a cron job. >> > > Now *there* is a useful suggestion that I might well steal. Even though, > again, I couldn't find any documentation of it, I had just hoped and > half-way suspected (since it seems like a common feature, even if you > personally are offended by it, in many mailing list managers) that mlmmj > had something built-in to handle this already. > > >> Cheers, >> -- >> Casey Allen Shobe | http://casey.shobe.info >> cshobe@seattleserver.com | cell 425-443-4653 >> AIM & Yahoo: SomeLinuxGuy | ICQ: 1494523 >> SeattleServer.com, Inc. | http://www.seattleserver.com >> >> > > Eeek! Is that a foote... nay, inline-spam!!!?!??!?? > > -Patrick