From: "Patrick Bennett" Date: Fri, 30 Sep 2005 15:56:21 +0000 Subject: Re: silently discarded post Message-Id: <012d01c5c5d7$8222b3c0$6664a8c0@stnick> List-Id: References: <003f01c5c4e1$dbd80420$6664a8c0@stnick> In-Reply-To: <003f01c5c4e1$dbd80420$6664a8c0@stnick> MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit To: mlmmj@mlmmj.org ----- Original Message ----- From: "Mads Martin Joergensen" To: Sent: Friday, September 30, 2005 7:34 AM Subject: Re: silently discarded post >* Patrick Bennett [Sep 29. 2005 23:50]: >> I pointed this out to the user and he says that listing is kept in a >> global directory at work (he is a government employee... take a look >> at the address, you can probably guess where) and he has no power to >> change the way the listing is set up. Additionally, he won't be able >> to get anywhere having the IT Department change the listing for him, >> since this is about a email issue for personal use. >> >> Thus, if this is the source of the error, the only way for him to be >> able to use the mailing list is for mlmmj to be able to work around >> it. > > It is the source of the error, and very hard to work around. Reason > mlmmj discards it, is that it's not a valid from with two email adresses > in it, and then it's thrown away. > I wonder if this could be (from a logical standpoint) handled in one of the following two ways, and whether it would make sense to program this logic into mlmmj: 1) Even though it is not a "valid from" if it contains (what appear to be) two email addresses and one of the two is on the authorized-to-post-list, the mail is accepted; or 2) here's a quick survey of "From" fields in the message sources in my inbox: From: "Patterson, Daniel@EDD" (the offending example) From: "renatofea@yahoo.com.br" From: Mads Martin Joergensen From: root@norcalsolutions.com From: Arno van Amersfoort If there is a matching pair of <>, everything inside the "" (if they exist), or everything prior to < should be discarded. Or perhaps it would be better to simply scan the "From" field and first discard everything inside quotes, before searching it for an @? As I see it, the problem isn't so much a bloated mailer (even though it probably is bloated), it's that the @ symbol is considered a valid character for the "name" field of many mailers' email account settings (and now I see Neale's reply that this is within the RFC's). I've just tested outlook express and mozilla thunderbird and both accepted @'s. I believe my user is using outlook. Theoretically, lots of mlmmj users and administrators - and not just ones using microsoft mailers - could run into this two-@'s-in-the-from-field snafu. TIA, Patrick