From: Evgeniy Polyakov Subject: Re: [Netchannel] Full TCP receiving support. Date: Wed, 24 May 2006 13:38:49 +0400 Message-ID: <20060524093849.GA7482@2ka.mipt.ru> References: <20060516173416.GA22552@2ka.mipt.ru> <20060518103443.GB26183@2ka.mipt.ru> <20060520155202.GA31923@2ka.mipt.ru> <20060521.230617.64626468.davem@davemloft.net> <20060522163414.GA5426@2ka.mipt.ru> Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="envbJBWh7q8WU6mo" Cc: netdev@vger.kernel.org, kelly@au1.ibm.com, rusty@rustcorp.com.au Return-path: Received: from relay.2ka.mipt.ru ([194.85.82.65]:6099 "EHLO 2ka.mipt.ru") by vger.kernel.org with ESMTP id S932605AbWEXJi7 (ORCPT ); Wed, 24 May 2006 05:38:59 -0400 To: "David S. Miller" Content-Disposition: inline In-Reply-To: <20060522163414.GA5426@2ka.mipt.ru> Sender: netdev-owner@vger.kernel.org List-Id: netdev.vger.kernel.org --envbJBWh7q8WU6mo Content-Type: text/plain; charset=koi8-r Content-Disposition: inline Hello, developers. Initial TCP benchmark. After tweaking some stuff I run netchannel vs socket TCP benchmark. Unfortunately currently I'm unable to run 1Gbit test, since my test machine is slightly broken... So only 100Mbit for now. Performance graph attached. Speed is the same, CPU usage is the same (socket CPU usage is 1% (or 20% :) more than netchannel one, but let's throw this away as some experimental error). Netchannel was setup in copy_to_user mode, so it was not expected to be faster or eat less CPU, but main purpose of this test was to show that netchannels with _all_ protocol processing moved to process' context can be at least that fast as when it is splitted into pieces. I've found some links in the web and blogs where some developers completely disagree with VJ idea of moving stuff into process context... Well, this should break theirs mostly theoretical arguments. It is clear that using memcpy setup CPU usage numbers (at least) for netchannel are noticebly better than for sockets (see previous posted benchmarks). I will start changing core networking code to accept different copying "actor" methods which will allow to use netchannels preallocated mapped area instead of copy_to_user(). Full patch and userspace application are available from netchannel homepage [1]. Thank you. 1. Netchannel homepage. http://tservice.net.ru/~s0mbre/old/?section=projects&item=netchannel Signed-off-by: Evgeniy Polyakov -- Evgeniy Polyakov --envbJBWh7q8WU6mo Content-Type: image/png Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="netchannel_speed.png" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAABAAAAAMACAMAAACNZOU/AAAAA3NCSVQICAjb4U/gAAABKVBM VEX///8AAACgoKD/AAAAwAAAgP/AAP8A7u7AQADu7gAgIMD/wCAAgECggP+AQAD/gP8AwGAA wMAAYIDAYIAAgABA/4AwYICAYABAQEBAgAAAAICAYBCAYGCAYIAAAMAAAP8AYADjsMBAwIBg oMBgwABgwKCAAACAAIBgIIBgYGAgICAgQEAgQIBggCBggGBggICAgEAggCCAgICgoKCg0ODA ICAAgIDAYACAwODAYMDAgADAgGD/QAD/QECAwP//gGD/gIDAoADAwMDA/8D/AAD/AP//gKDA wKD/YGAA/wD/gAD/oACA4OCg4OCg/yDAAADAAMCgICCgIP+AIACAICCAQCCAQICAYMCAYP+A gADAwAD/gED/oED/oGD/oHD/wMD//wD//4D//8BUJrxzAAAAAXRSTlMAQObYZgAAAER0RVh0 U29mdHdhcmUAZ251cGxvdCB2ZXJzaW9uIDQuMCBwYXRjaGxldmVsIDAgb24gTGludXggMi42 LjE2LTEuMjExMV9GQzUb5X7HAAAZ/ElEQVR4nO3dC1viytaoUfLs1fz/n7y7VSQ3cqFIaqbm GOd8W1uoGF3OlwARbzcAAAAAAAAAAACgZd3gDZBJ1/XfALk4AoDEpgHogAv6VADeTMlJ7F6J 2LsXe+/a3D0B+Cy7VyD23jW5ez8HDv3jhxa/zPPYvQKx9y7L7iX5Mg9i9wrE3rssu5fkyzyI 3SsQe++y7F7wLxOYIwAcauWJpuGjSN3388l7P8Vb19yy6o0nyXqPji0v/ui+vD9+AsCR1gah F4Du9hib7eeZdQvXm/nw3qHb/2P9O/ndpwOw8du4lwBwpN9ZHjxx9PtmcATQDSfncc1usm6w 9Z+zWbrH6q7rXTb4tN1gY6PLbjMfHE/pzNcwCtzzS+jGDfjovgw/+/sn9AgAB3v8nP/Ow+DN 4Ink7vYcieGN+3Bdb0n/ml1v8H7zMVzX9Tc2ONTousGb0ee/TTc2u0u/H/jel4Xlpftye3nZ /1YN//vcPkMAeKU3Lo9b667r//g+rjUzVYPby26y3efb36HrLx/fQs5E5TbYl9kFw0833JfR 1/B7NDKq2xH78ioO+wgARxrexPVvssczMgxAN9jE/LQ93+meAZh8om56zde35NMFwy/lNtmX 4c386Mt4MbMl+/KMQb8y473YTgA41Nyd3BePAfze4A1Wz6ybfI7bMwCD293eLevzA6N773O3 urOf7/Hu6LLRHg0/w+f35fdX8YffwbfnTwA4wWk/Hn4OdxIATiAAUQkAJCYAsNf6U21Lz7yF IgAV/NdXe2cqOvM04f/GxjPavXj/1TwfeZrwcNdf/HvrZfs+S+3ttOvVzI9/MCvtXgVrg9AL wIvThHszORnwpXmf+7Qzz/it7/4u208Tnt2+AFzR/sF+9RN85F7W8TvLW04TXhvwS58mPHvG 8+Mqwx18Lnh+BqcCR3PE2K5NwOqEVLDjFnrN12F5s6cJz30p3WCXpl/di33Z+ZMgAJ9Uc9jW lE5goRd71ft5T3ya8OgG/fGx/rrNAdhJAD5h5ae8nr2PVhfat3PDm9v+TfZ4RobT0Q02MT9t z3e68RHA9Oa2f83Xt+TTBcMv5TbZl82nCfe+lNkjgOcOOhU4lHCDXzaRZ3Oa8NKX0g0WPJcP P9Ft9jNtJwDvCDP41xr4eaf96OT6Gd1IAPaoPvgtDPyYANQkAFtUG/wWB55IBGDJ6YNv4DmX AMzbNfj7Hw7/zMPoCTyf6ruNH+l/Xmf71nauOvJ034/uy/vjJwBTu0f/1cdf++j+Nmz2ibjR 5a9+9lZSsekndveP9fbTfT+6L73L/owuGv979AEBGNhxu2+QTzB8Yn0SgMfRQff7hFjc033P elVgAXiX2Y/nMczzdwEGz4/fop/u+9F9ub287M+que9wsYsHYOvwO4A/Vzd5000uHAZgcLXx LWQ3s7GzTvf9+L68CsDoW+gIYMXWo36jX0HvB/02mbbnO934CKCbW/57zde35NMFw325TfYl 3KsCC8AOm2bf43YVDR9Pv/Tpvp/ZF6cCf8rq8HvE/oKu93NYWc4ALA6/wb+wa/0cBpAwAK+G 3+CTT7IAzN70G3zSShSAmeE3+VfW7mnCszuxtOT98csSgNHwu9G/vtknzUaXv/q5XEnFpp/m 3T/y208Tnt3+xgDcBxfcJx8Z/TNDAAY3/Sa/FcMn5CcBeBwddL9PlsU9Tfg2+Oyzrwg0ON13 9BkGl03GffSBbAF4Dr/Rb8tjmFs4Tfj5pr+8v0vTr+7FvtxXzX0Xi4UMwPdNv0f329RN3nST C4cBGFxtfOvZzWzsrNOERzfoj4/1120PwPC7lPMI4Od1PAx+y0bjchvd3D7e6cZHANOb2/41 X9+STxcM9+U22Zcqrwqc9zGA3ovQG/wMGjpNeHy6b/8q4x0cfqLb7Gfa7vIBGE29weeVADdS 8Vw2AOOxN/isEIAZVwvA16j3Bv+kTwttukoAfm/mQ/w9DmjERQLwfUtv+OGzLhGAf0f6hh8+ 7woB+J/hh2OED4Dhh+OEDsD3o/1HbBn4J3AAvm75jT8cKGwAvg/8zT8cKWoAvu/3m384VNAA fN/8m384VsgAOPyHc0QMgMN/OEnAADj8h7OEC4DDfzhPtAA4/IcTBQuA+YczhQrAf+7+w6ki BcDNP5wsUADMP5wtTAD+M/9wuigB+Bl/8w9nChIAN/9QQ4gAOPyHOiIEwOE/VBIgAG7+oZbq AXD4D/XUDsDjFX8FACp4b3AHf6K4YDvmH6p6a3B//jZ5f/lb23m+4r8AQA0FRwDdowTvbqf3 Bz8EAGooCkDXOwL4smsj5h8qemNmf5d+ry+7CyAAUFvZXYCSAPT/4p8AQBVvPgjY9d68uR0H AFBdvfMABACqqxYA9wCgvggBMP9QiQBAYrUC4B4ABBAgAOYfahEASKx+AMw/VFMpAA4AIAIB gMSqB8D8Qz11AuAAAEIQAEisdgDMP1RUJQAOACAGAYDEKgfA/ENNNQLgAACCEABIrG4AzD9U VSEADgAgCgGAxKoGwPxDXQIAiZ0fAPcAIIyaATD/UJkAQGKnB8A9AIijYgDMP9QmAJDY2QFw DwACqRcA8w/VCQAkdnIA3AOASKoFwPxDfQIAiZ0bAPcAIJRaATD/EIAAQGKVAmD+IYJTA+AA AGIRAEisTgDMP4RwZgAcAEAwAgCJVQmA+YcYTgyAAwCIRgAgsRoBMP8QxHkBcAAA4QgAJFYh AOYfojgtAA4AIB4BgMTOD4D5hzDOCoADAAhIACCx0wNg/iEOAYDETgqAewAQ0dkBMP8QiABA YucEwD0ACOnkAJh/iEQAILFTAuAeAMR0bgDMP4QiAJDYGQFwDwCCOjUA5h9iEQBI7IQAmH+I SgAgsZIAdN1ztQDABRUEoOsv3xAA8w/RHB8ABwAQVuFdgK7/fje7MQGAiF7P7I5tTN6ZcA8A wioLwIYHAR0AQFxldwE2bEcAIK7DzwNwDwDiOjoADgAgMAGAxM4KgPmHgA4OgAMAiOysAAAB CQAkdmwAzD+EJgCQmABAYgIAiR0aAPMPsQkAJCYAkNiRATD/EJwAQGICAIkdGADzD9EJACR2 xh8HBYISAEhMACAxAYDEBAASEwBITAAgMQGAxAQAEhMASEwAIDEBgMQEABITAEhMACAxAYDE BAASEwBITAAgMQGAxAQAEhMASEwAIDEBgMQEABITAEhMACAxAYDEBAASEwBITAAgMQGAxAQA EhMASEwAIDEBgMQEABITAEhMACAxAYDEBAASEwBITAAgMQGAxAQAEhMASEwAIDEBgMQEABIT AEhMACAxAYDEBAASEwBIrGRwu+65WgDgggoGt+svFwC4IAGAxD52F+BL+f4A5yidWUcAcHUC AIl5FgAScx4AJCYAkJgAQGICAIkJACQmAJCYAEBiAgCJCQAkJgCQmABAYgIAiQkAJCYAkJgA QGICAIkJACQmAJCYAEBiAgCJCQAkJgCQmABAYgIAiS0O7tff/tk22gIAF7Q8uJ0AQMtWBnfz XAsAXNDS4P678d862AIAF7QWgK2TLQBwQZ4FgMQEABITAEhMACAxAYDEBAASEwBITAAgMQGA xAQAEhMASGxtcDu/DgztWg/AttkWALggdwEgMQGAxAQAElt7STCvCAQNW3tR0I2PAQoAXJEA QGICAImtPgbgRUGhXZ4FgMQEABJbeQzgS/l2gJBW/zTYxr8OJABwQat/HHTj8wACABckAJDY hqcBPQYArfIsACQmAJDY+l0ApwJDs/wuACQmAJCYAEBiq4PrtwGhXZ4FgMQEABJbPRXYXQBo lwcBITEBgMQEABJbfUEQAYB2eRYAEhMASGzDi4JuulAA4IIKTwUWALiy9cFduka36VpAUEUB 6F20/S8IABFsmNnlK3Qv3gcuomBwu5f/AK5BACAx5wFAYgIAiQkAJCYAkJgAQGICAIkJACS2 eKb/jtN7BQAuqOyXgfZeCwhFACAxAYDEPAYAiXkWABITAEhscXB3vMSPAMAFrbzi3+a5FgC4 IAGAxAQAElt/GtB5ANAszwJAYgIAiS0/Dbh2hY3bAWJa/8NfHgOAZgkAJCYAkNjKqcB+GxBa 5lkASEwAIDEBgMQEABITAEhMACAxAYDEBAASEwBITAAgMQGAxNZeFtzvAkDD1gPgtwGhWRsG d9NsCwBckMcAIDEBgMRWBrfzoqDQsOXB3f6ywAIAFyQAkJgAQGJrjwE4EQga5lkASEwAILHV uwCf2Q4Q0dqDgFtPBBAAuCABgMQEABLzNCAk5lkASEwAILHVU4HdBYB2eRAQEhMASEwAILHV VwQSAGiXZwEgMQGAxJb/MMiHtgPEtP6SYJ/YDhDS+oOAH9kOENHa4HpBEGjY6uA6FRja5VkA SEwAILHlpwG7za8KKgBwQUuD2zkVGNomAJDYYgC+FW8HCGrlCGD5Gr04CABcUMngdi/e5/ru P/9XZ/nq+qO3n0fB4HYv/8H13csGpHD56vqjt59GwWMAg8t2PFzABdz/qbb8e/2a0u0XrG/C +syu/6pg1/8HDSkckNL5Wlt/9PbTWJnxtccIBaBRf+ej7AigaPnX4pXHAA7dfh4lLwjSeRag XdUfAyi/xnGrG+I8AOYEeBbgE9c5Ym1b/DIQcwQgCQFgjgAkIQDMuPf+9/zlG1cevf0UBIAZ ApCFADB1H7x5d3nx+k9d71PrWiQATBVOsABchwAwJQBpCAAT95n3zlu+Y9XR209AAJgQgDwE gLH77LvvLC9e/8nrlqxplwAwVjjBAnAlq38azO8CpCMAiawHYNtsC0Az7gv/On75zhVHb795 7gIwIgCZCABD98V/7l1evL729VsnAAwVTrAAXIsXBGFIAFJZe9WvrZMtAI2YDsiukSlcHvAx g8bteOHfgu1wGQKQiwDQNzMgpc/LR3pe3/yP7Xjh35LtcBGFEywAV+NZAPoEIBkBoGd2QEp/ Oy/Ob/eZ/4nVuwCf2Q7XUDjBAnA5aw8Cbn0eUABa8GJASl+hJ8or/Jj/KQHgqXCCBeB6BIAn AUjH04D8ejkg2ybn9bVK139mpfmf4VkAfhVOsABckADwsDAgW2Zn6Tql6z+x1vzP8TQgD4UT LABX5EFAHgQgIQHgx+KArE/P8jVK15evNv+zBIAfhRMsAJfkaUC+rQzI2vwcffmao7ffKs8C 8K1wggTgmgSAbwKQkrsAfKl8H798Po/efqO8JBhfCidYAC5KAPin8vP8n5jPo7ffJi8Lzj8C kNTKEcDmPw0iANdWOMECcFWeBeBW/bf9PjOfR2+/SQLArXiCBeCyFge32/7rgAJwZZVf8edT 83n09lu0+MdBH/+/cDtEJwBpCQDFEywA1yUAbB+Q+Stun6/S9bW336DlxwA2z78AXFnhBAvA hXkWgB0DMnfVPfNVur729tsjAAhAYgJA4QQLwJUJQHq7BmR65X3zVbq+9vabIwDpCUBmApDd zgEZX33vfJWur7391ghAdgKQmgBkVzjBAnBtApDc7gG5L/zrjPW1t98YAUhOAHITgNzeGJD7 i/fPWl97+20RgNwEIDkByK1wggXg6gQgtbcG5D7z3pnra2+/KQKQmgBkJwCZvTkg99Hbs9fX 3n5LBCAzAUhPADIrnGABuD4BSOztAbmXLS9eX3v7DRGAxAQAAcirYEDuZcuL19fefjsEIC8B QAASEwBKBnfwl8MF4HKKBuReOF+l62tvvxklAfjQduoovI1YWz66/E/h+iMuv5d8+fei5cXr a2+/HYVHAJ/YTiWFtxFry4eXTwKwc/0Bl5cNSOHy4vW1t9+MwsF93gUY3CG4gPu96Gfk3oJq 373i9bW334RPzOyFHwMo/AlZWx7+CMBjANyKHwO4bgAK7yX+W7v9PvifP+MCBHgMwLMAlA1u 8scAdvgzcwgAAaQ9D+ADN4Gb/bnN3QmA+gTg/eWbCQBRCcD7yzcTAKLKGoDC3xfbPf8KQEgC ULB8IwEgrKQBuA/evLt8mz+jtxBH7gC8WwABoBECULJ8EwEgrpwBuM+899byDf7MvAdBCEDR 8g0EgMBSBuA+++47y9f9efE+RJA9AO8UQABohgCULV8lAESWMQD3hX/tXr7iz8K/oDoBEAAS SxiA++I/9y5fNp54BSAWAdhbAAGgIQIgACSWLwDTAd410kXzrwAEIwACQGLpAjAzwHtmunD+ FYBYBODFx3Ysf0kAiE4AXnxsx/KXBIDosgVgdoC3T3Xx/CsAoQjA64+WXPEfASC8ZAF4McBb 5/oD868ARCIAix9/72rfBID4BGDx4+9d7ZsAEF+uALwc4G2T/ZH5VwACEYC1S/Ze6UEAuIBU AVgY4C2z/aH5VwDiEIANl22/ypMAcAUCsOGy7Vd5EgCuIFMAFgd4fbo/Nv8KQBgCsO3SLVfo EwAuIVEAVgZ4bb4/OP8KQBQCsPVyAaBBArD1cgGgQXkCUHgf/6PzrwAEIQAbryEAtChNAAqf 5//w/CsAMQjAtqsIAE0SgG3XEQCalCUAhb/t9/H5VwBCEIBN1xIA2pQkAIWv+HPA/CsAEQjA lqsJAI0SgC3XEwAalSMAha/7f8j8KwABCMCGawoArUoRgMK//XfQ/CsA9QnA+lUFgGYJwPp1 BYBmZQjArgGeXvmw+VcAqhOA1SsLAO1KEIBdAzy9+oHzrwDUJgBrVxcAGiYAa9cXABrWfgD2 zv9owaHzrwBUJgArCwSAljUfgN3zP1xy8PwrAHUJwPISAaBpArC8RgBoWusBeGf+e4sOn38F oCoBWFwkALSt8QC8Nf/PZSfMvwJQkwAsLRMAGicAS+sEgMa1HYB35/9n4SnzrwBUJAALCwWA 1jUdgLfn/3vpSfOvANQjAK+XCgDNE4DXSwWA5pUNbjfzXhwF8/9v8WnzrwBUUzS43fYATH7E 125iR5evrJ9O0N/L7kuXr+3evb98fX1hAHbvX6zLg+9e+MsrKglAt+MIYG5Cl29ih5evrJ/5 Dt93DfDy8sP/C9f+CRSAqpdXVBCAbnAX4Murq/75Z/ih+xn+vG3/8ve/kbf3d5OrKPjxOMry zG5c//uPlSuv3cROFR8BrFy+tnsrn35t/T61b4IcAVS9vKKzHgScu5N99GMAi5ev7d7Kp19b v1Ptn0ABqHp5Rac9CzA7YpsF/g7ChZ12HsB4hPc9RycAcAQBgMQEABKrFYCdZ+kJABzhvN8F GM6wAwAIoFIAHABABAIAiQkAJFYnAHt/UVcA4BAnviBIb4odAEAIVQLgAABiEABITAAgsRoB 2P1afQIAxzjzVYEfc+wAAIKoEAAHABCFAEBiAgCJnR+A/X+uQwDgIKf+abCvSXYAAGGcHgAH ABCHAEBiAgCJnR2AN/5irwDAUU4NwN9ZdgAAgZwcAAcAEIkAQGICAImdG4A35l8A4DgnB2D/ NJt/OM6pAbi/Mc4CAMcRAEhMACCxMwNwf2ecBQCOc3IAds+z+YcDnRiAr+cABQACEQBITAAg sfMC8H0WoABAIGcHYOdEm3840mkBePwagABAHAIAiQkAJHZWAH5/EVgAII7TA7Brps0/HOqk APReCUQAIAwBgMQEABI7JwD91wIUAAjj/ADsmGrzD8c6JQDDFwMWAIhCACAxAYDEzgjA6M+B CABEUSEAm+fa/MPBTgjA5O+BCQAEIQCQmABAYscHYPoXgQUAgqgRgI2Tbf7haIcHYGb+BQCC EABITAAgsaMDMDf/AgBBVAnAptk2/3C4gwMwP/8CADEIACQmAJDYsQF4Mf8CADHUCcCG6Tb/ cLxDA/By/gUAQhAASEwAILGSAHTdc/Xcdl7PvwBACAUB6PrLJ9v5O/33ggKYfzhB4V2A1wH4 O/4L8y8AEEFRAPp3Ab70LrvfFwsgAFDXZGbf2cbknV/3pccABAAiOPIxgJJHAQUATnDkswCL lifc/MMZzvnz4DMEAOoTAEhMACAxAYDEqgVgccbNP5xCACAxAYDEBAASEwBIrF4AFqbc/MM5 BAASEwBITAAgMQGAxCoG4OWcm384iQBAYgIAiQkAJCYAkFjNALyYdPMPZxEASEwAIDEBgMQE ABKrGoDZWTf/cBoBgMQEABITAEhMACCxugGYmXbzD+cRAEhMACAxAYDEBAASqxyAybybfziR AEBiAgCJCQAkJgCQWO0AjCbe/MOZBAASEwBITAAgMQGAxKoHYDDz5h9OJQCQmABAYgIAiQkA JFY/AL2pN/9wLgGAxAQAEhMASEwAILEAAfide/MPJxMASEwAIDEBgMQEABKLEICfyTf/cDYB gMQEABITAEhMACCxEAH4mn3zD6cTAEhMACAxAYDEBAASixGAv9Nv/uF8AgCJJQnAp77Mg9i9 ArH3LsvuCUAJu1cg9t61vHtd91wtACXsXoHYe9fw7nX95aVf5sEPAbT7X+EMsXcv9t41vnsC 8BF2r0DsvWt59wZ3AYALqtOOCc8CwrUIACRWeAABAAAAAFxM7EcEYz9i+b1nYffwa7eifgd/ 9irmzj32K+o374PfvcGJwfEE3rV/3/6v/70F3c3n7gX0812L+s3r7V5EH/zudY8flJiiFvjb Y8KC7uPvEUDtHXmhi/zN+9m3sHv3qe9e9/X/Qou7ez8BiPod/NhvfBzh5xg76jfvOfkhd+/2 se9eF/hA50fc3fu5iY26i5ED8LNLUb953ey7oXSf+e5FvRP2I/buxX4MIPTudc83AffuCrv3 qUdQAt/L+Sfy7l3igeygu/d4fD3m3kXfvdj/bQEAAAAAAAAAANjs99fVnQ8GGZl8SOzxmkQ/ //v6BPHhue3OIYcW9H5r7fHb4bO/Ijb87baov+QG7DIXgN8b+8EV+69xZ/ihCS+OAL7+OR7z bnwgAFzb4zGA/gtEPe7g90e8G9759xgANM6IAwC07/83KmaxJgujowAAAABJRU5ErkJggg== --envbJBWh7q8WU6mo--