From: Matthias Dahl Subject: snd-hda-intel, AD 1988b: SPDIF output not working correctly, volume low for analog output Date: Tue, 17 Jul 2007 08:32:00 +0200 Message-ID: <200707170832.01976.ml_alsa@mortal-soul.de> Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: Multipart/Mixed; boundary="Boundary-00=_hJGnGeGxYAQF5Ky" Return-path: Received: from dd15922.kasserver.com (dd15922.kasserver.com [85.13.137.18]) by alsa0.perex.cz (Postfix) with ESMTP id DC8B8103815 for ; Tue, 17 Jul 2007 08:31:58 +0200 (CEST) Received: from marvin (unknown [88.134.217.56]) by dd15922.kasserver.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id AD87B1804A300 for ; Tue, 17 Jul 2007 08:31:58 +0200 (CEST) List-Unsubscribe: , List-Archive: List-Post: List-Help: List-Subscribe: , Sender: alsa-devel-bounces@alsa-project.org Errors-To: alsa-devel-bounces@alsa-project.org To: alsa-devel@alsa-project.org List-Id: alsa-devel@alsa-project.org --Boundary-00=_hJGnGeGxYAQF5Ky Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Content-Disposition: inline Hello everyone. I very recently upgraded my system to a Asus Crosshair (AM2, nforce 590 sli) board because it seemed just good quality. Unfortunately the AD1988b chip on it is causing me some trouble. 1] SPDIF output When I use it for dts/dolby passthrough, it works just fine even though from time to time spdif just hangs- not during playback but when I start the playback. (analog output is unaffected) Meaning that either the player is hanging or playback starts but I hear no sound. After that only a reboot solves the problem... restarting alsa has not effect. Also when the passthrough stops or during playback of anything else besides a dts/dolby stream, I hear a low pitch beating (usually in combination with a very high pitch sound) in the background. I double checked everything to be sure that my other equipment was fine and not the cause of this. 2] analog output I am unable to get it as loud as with the win drivers without overdriving it. The volume is okay... but not on par with the win drivers. That's especially true for the SPDIF output. Increasing the SPDIF volume usually results in worse audio quality over spdif and increased "noise" (see above). Like said earlier, I checked with the win drivers, and everything (audio wise) works just fine there. So it's not a hardware fault. (relief -g-) My guess would be that the AD 1988b is quite a bit different to program from its 1988 predecessors as it contains dts live and stuff. Just a guess... I have attached some hopefully useful informations. If you need anything else, please let me know. I really need that spdif working, so I am more than willing to test just about anything. :-) Last but not leat, I have tried the latest official alsa drivers as well as a mercurial snapshot from yesterday. (which I am currently using) Both show the same problems. Thanks for any help in advance, matthew. --Boundary-00=_hJGnGeGxYAQF5Ky Content-Type: application/x-gzip; name="lspci_output.gz" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="lspci_output.gz" H4sICM5fnEYAA2xzcGNpX291dHB1dADtXGtv4jgX/tz+Cq/eLx1lPBvnRkDtSi3QLVooLLQzK436 ISSmjSYkTBI67f7699gJJCQBUgq9LZWKQ3Dsc+xznnOxHVGsieIXEYmqKNYQES1aE6WRgo58eo8M 6dPhwWA6DB6DkI5TPx8e1D039D2nhlq/dzHq0LGAzqZBx4CKvoAGE2rWH02H8p++tS6/YvT1z9OB 63kTjHqG3/R9jAYhnUxs9xaumv0+Rufw9Jl0hqHP0AinQQ3VjYmANK1z8a+Arhvn8yrCvI1G8+ug 2T4ZwX30x9Xp0PNDjI7nF5344o+oh+MeKw4P2kZIXfOxhkTgxJgYQ9uxQ5tCj98V5QZdPE6of+Ub bjCBp2to4Bj3FHk+6vn22PAfUcsFNkeGSQ8PYCTGY8O1aujMCOi1a4etxomI2EXdDU+IitigXHgB UNGgo4bNiL5uAxEHbdv9geKBRDD69XOnKaD64ArDZROobf84N2wHQ3d2KKBmt47R1T8w3Mf1fh24 h25agWc2XYzaA/bZfAjrV22MNGWYbn9k37LmO+1vrROiDe0QNX6dmy14AG51U7e6UyAyW4s3n60G N7MMkGcwIHAGhFUMkF0w0Kf3dmB7Lmo1QLq/iPKs03Of/pwyEWEDBz/8efHv7CegGyQBbh/3fI/J WPd+BCwec+6A+qsxzrcyFzLeoCSKXKTluFTiUo1LLS71uIwIYKUEJYZSiUuNl1+pa7FOzymojU9T vdX4AJ/XYYAbV4Orbg+mp1+/6oCsMFL5SJ9idN1q9BsFZJNi5snGzJPdMR+RdgGq6ACm1FCPC2OX f/aYNHbZBxDKij77gJFgBYMG/hXwpQ9l75LXvoyr87J/GT9wOXuCXUCvPZ+OaGjeGUOHojEde4AO Q3pnuxYa+rZ1S9H1BMAEkEbEIqDNAaAkupyOh9G9HPxQMQ8/nUELQIRD5eGhyAGbZADbWA3YRgFg 4wSw8UaALRQDNi4CbLwRYAszwI65ljJc09Vc011wvcRMbZFrnOFaznCtr+Zaf22un2mcY66VDNfV 1VxXX9Al2QXXaZckHgE1MwKj1SMw+uBO2f9EEX0X4e9mNkDa4gBVVg9QZc0AvVUQzCpGJcP1ahCs fAgQVFiEoolKIu3DmGvyCR1NfO8W2yPEBOTS88eGgyxqeha9+bSa+V3oBN4m8ymd+Ax9mHcUgW9F 0cD+l9aQLKHhY0iDQ+ZU1NAkCk5ORKgbAP+uxb8R+DaFxi3bhcai79TETtTyCSgbjMyiz8I8E1Ec idxnYVcMXDoFzk0NwU+8Co6qsYprXaKo+bjh+dOpe6yVwYwDFMRjHA/vpiN7vDiyZ5yUegiSAQ2B bzqb3EuvNTgVmBSATMxmpU8DGqYnPgtQ4LbllE8s8O8U/Qb1vF/UB4/ONW7pmLohuqc+j0Ik5sM7 xi1U7HWadecHMDdowQeBfwmj0+lDfer78MiJOD5ldY4aovC5QeBfgn/5zgtZYXqOJYDsz8WzIbLK uOmyOWGNUgdir8bANByQCP5bjlIVWOrQIAAiQd5uXcNxqBVFvv50EkIVUKIfPIJgwd3fUzqFtn4n KOpFgO5PLcuHFlLzTakIfr+JUMMIjRpSiFLNdaytcYGz9XWo33yYsJ5Q3/NCGF8/REcDBwbjE2r1 /2YG5aABoZ4JojeYTliT1GL0P/SMR8czLEQkPdKlz6h3Z7jh+dQ1mc5BQHpl3OLU87FGorYYoGOV SC480iboWJkGqVo8GGG44MF0mSEfEJAsF58D3w4zGry4doMZOULq6b7zYHV9S5h1n9DEZaD3y2di ykEq/VgxP3C3Tw2rT38iIHeGGDxGS40GQ0L4lL6ofw5/h6e+2VZ4hx6I9hmdDnodzm4boIOPrTh/ fvVoRHX48w07YINgoX79DEQmIgOx3AkXc2B08OiadzihbAk9TKphZqHZ0D0LIbSH0aiHPgShnX4b s7stiAfZXV5eeGHPmTLknvoTO6B4/nwUhLFJ5vrYtsc2cPYlEtR5rUiYrXRv504YdwZIFzQYLtTH Vn3Cbl/0Wv5PnKKRk4O6o9HnmCTUdeMeeQLCY9VSUoITKcEoLgrVk4AjhL7afjgFc1cH+XCpExlL PZPOk7Xq3FjmXQRzqO/TeWvSefrLpvNKZMNeLJ2H8wwInAGeGxEYA8Im+chZOk/P0a/nyNfz1Ov7 VN7TU3kRrVtP5eGYeRwzj2Pmccw8jpnHMfP4P5TK40Er83rioLUaBTIkwWZxWfimyDVdkuRFbBaW Y7PwPvIaVZa7NEU1GYGl+azlI7CrAHYn1mnuMkOIZrvoFPnelHlcocedU0lVDwG9bhl2KZxFxMxU gIwQEZPJTwDR3omm3MyrqblqykK1Ahu43ZgDQ8wB/xJ+ZswRS4SU8VeWZrMLJeJ9ZjgNhgSmKCdc mwUpDQLz2r2ot26eiw5vVDcSdEBHFVV0AzS2wT+Wokvj4dN69ZHnasGcogi2QSdGVJRYcgEdyRIG b+EzcsGxnqQw/lOsMspfW1MZAVRG2G2YHgsPyQiPNVeZRHgkEJ5maeF5z25/WeE5ywqPuFx4aCnh kVStWHoadDi95RBdmLB4i8IlRMJlMmQiaR+FFiCTbqDvkaCgATV7LJbqZQRtVM6CfwhBS6To+30U lN+k5InnFMhotTxZcYrkJhYtPTH4ZEWzMms2hBAXyaWaJUmz0ipqKxtTK6+itrIxtVnnaKTMnSOy RAl36vXgWMvwRhBuZbUstXyV0jI1rWVdpmXdvS9QzhdYEBaxOhIL9Wqx1nBeS1lQk0xblYK25Fxb lYK2skLMrUxKiBMPf9EaWS/tyryAHmQpHW624iDFSVpctOIw+5utOBQuyphmiU03FvO59gq7Xf9L WqGwtJTC0lIKq5VSWK2EwppmOYU19wr76gor7RX2mQpbzyosWaqwpi6WUFgzcdpWKKwpFrWVVdih WdRWVmGHejmFHe4V9pUVlmZ2+fBYIaewIkHfQTlD3zBD+54u2eqzHeVcsrtri8opFC5irtrPI2X2 80iL+3lk6Zkbeqx4Sw5clN/QU7ANaN0Gntx4jallT8evtoVnqOe38MSL45n0TTlZBm9RSWXoKmRV UpuMpI+UjVPFuXEhW0rHiaXgmWivgc8vvOdKyOKz+HR8PmAN8cXV5Pceda2FW/mtWSVEn/DjZJqe rOdU5G2tcb4D0ZcSvwq0oHTqQhUry2XfKO+aLHG7hkqRQyVlO6o+IeedOGWLbeglFfVNLroI5fS0 wvQUev9ntkEMx47TlTEc8EGGDr5SM/R8xLd11dDZaf9EQt5oBFboJFGwg97ZafSjnP9xO+ggP21H ZpXk0WFEt4YOZI8OT0eHxbBrUd8qzweHwmgrBw7aFsBBfc/gUNKIv0tweBuug5SLALWiCHB/zqMg LpQzcaG8P+exP+fxZs55qORNnPMA6/Shznmk+HnWOQ+96JiH+mrHPPT9KY81pzyIljOV6iam8iXc 6TdnKpWMqVTKmkpjZsOMlRlUGhk7uNibyr2pfLKpfBtHIvemcskRxCJTSbZsKoXyJyL3pnKdqazk TGVlbypLmko1YyrVsqayOrNh1VWmUhdjUzl8wmLjDDppXM5NZWRu34ipFPamcuemUttHlfu3BzzB Vu7fHrDWWOqRseTrM5JUI4TD0Esdt9uJGSzQ+CxCsAP97I0Aid1IvxPgt99+g0EPAnvoPCLbNb3x xKFhvPWIg0ry2oBvhj/uBwBpjaHTjI4zp8/VLz1Vv+K1AItH5xdO/qdO/Cc35/cKjsVLs1kmmVkm L3+ocquzHLMlZdgq2lbzDtmSM2y95BHYl9DJET8rP2IveCP8rLxUE3mGS+ErxUQmtQpR4sUgMfse E72qgL8kFYnwjt8BiFevFK/f0rbMYwfv/EhO7dGtquVXi5mZK1wttqLk0voFWLDFbBKU+N3QJFqu r6o1mTDCCich2sdWHf1HgqY1c7BsNw9LCfIp0JQ1a+DS0rV4aEMv14b21/J90UbqIAPvC7xgsIes ar/biTuKlndzp/JAPgr22alPX6IXVi/RP3sfNFkSnZgbRScb7LMr2Bswizba9NYA5xechIlnw0iV fFOZKCmbBBuaMvOuyUKsMXNNM67v6mikyM9MRSM4H43gEtEILo5GdpC4WxmJTF2HefPU4sM1/7ar 7F2RZ35q3RuuCfWjN+H0KWMs2iWhxpgsJy/MYHv7it+GCbiaPcuiaGBawZp8HJje3B4ascaW2JDU Wdg+lbQxy0ElYLxkU1Rn2a4oPdvAMiJkqbNwfGUBzatZNE9OYOdxfTiixbgOjxbgurbZ+wpe4XyL pr8WrusJrj8V0Fe+elJYhudLk0cvBOgfNr00p26z/FKZREuukjTP655NrVsaFiUqNdbStfvD9X65 6IiA+334fz9zFmG9ZQAA --Boundary-00=_hJGnGeGxYAQF5Ky Content-Type: application/x-gzip; name="proc_output1.gz" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="proc_output1.gz" H4sICMNgnEYAA3Byb2Nfb3V0cHV0MQDdWltvm0gUfvevGOUxatW5gAFLeSC2k7AbXxS72V1FecAw pKg2WDZu3f31ewbMAI4hvmUdt6rIAMPhO9+cOfOdMc3Q5U4DmYE9Dl9Qi//wHT5HZosYun5dM113 xufzBsK1Rx644QxZLpwsCXEV6DGqDRaj+a95xCfpDawwnXi09gCW5n4YyOuYYVzrhqgDL5ygm0Xg ROL27SxcTJEXLgK31uKevRhHqN/sNGoI/s3sCMA84aXmec8NpGOMESGYqojURZtSrGLEqGgrChHH uI+uwyVkxH2IVlfEH0P0iq2O/Cg2ysEkqSMKdpT4hhfOJnZyj8A9gCEhmZPpZytAjj0FMkJvfoWX GH9CAbg+TU/itv8vX51OFhG/IgULvUVUMEG1nAlxkjehrkwI1lwOHGKKnsyF64cI7EwX0TP6KYzB HYYZIQ00iPiMh6jlv/iRPQaXNhDJMXh2XK7UhCtkNhncaoZBwOOxhSfirmL4XekEK3NCwap0YUUW PH4AbdnDP+wxPCywUg2Jw7MgJ/zJZyI2M4KV02LDAhsuwaaeHhshJdjqp8dWypuWYrOCAjQCk8b4 2JPGkU7oZU5gSIDSiSIBJVZxZtU4otVsgtsnDQYiMBBeEgyjFNuAj8GHcJbPobBCbYqHvL9M+qtf JgzCwZPmnUrzBLv7+M/qm/0nG/3XxWTQ48lQGCicIme6OBgCPrPFYSQOjmBN3KGKOKjimhtPK+mc +zs7x39n57wjznOeWiUYPV1zPkW3POCQKkEb/uW7LzxnX4OEiEFcdsLgLd6wlxdTXpG3USVvGChL MRH01PcDgD6Zjvkyn3ow0bcdwy2F3WYsKAEEXPoBGI1TBdOY10BWF/W+DtFdH1R2BMQmfVCqD4W+ o0SBJNRAT3/Yzvdn0VWYtyPUXkboZhYGUTwOYmTQFSJf9E/QHgPzV6CjOQ8Sk5+dSODBSwdMJa8s G05KJXX0rKkjGKgjGXX3fsDz5D1we7YTd0rCXSlxhiSOVRC3ZfSTfPQTb5es8YoxIoEXKVIJ0Qjx BEXdL+YzGky5/Z3PBEFW8JqgpCDMOLoeA687ciQ1AVFOHFy53LrPvLSJgSmXwdXxne0mJdhZ54wq 4o2llI0kZepHpUyTlJVORh3ENSXFyQjV8zZz8Xq84OuU4UrKpJ4Fqf1BU9gWlGEC/+l++WufuWlL 1rRy1oyPHmjxxMSbJmYlYbvPy7qkSy+nCxfFVOaMjOAifsNgjBAqRv3GX3L3GTVbaT42h2bfKiRk caF6zDFuSJhQ28Vq7pUoU4Xow8myVCX5qPQdC8VJiTRtVzGQs/ym/yrxCktSL/p22IK0ek8KdFQO lOUU/arUO0ZNujnC85tOby/UoGRUL2EliepBv2XdVCWD3jTyHXuccRMTuVtCwJkSdMppo3i0kTYr WDm+tkdKtB2EDTybcLZV8CjESWlK9EzMUvkqsxVJawEkS94OTM9cSUhFALGdmNgpQUom8qvK2gqz ca5iIg6ZiODlDpCcA+8DPE3sFcWtBM7qxRwDJetjOF5MOPozCEevkpjYeNPTVLN6huIqZ0dbObtf vJY5u0/bEEQY9SrSdEma2H5iTG4NiLKfKenOQLwpQOQ6T8mRtjgOKFbKtjiypUaipWcTuVohcimU g6ufyiBXgYpzXwWvJ1zI1skCE3JsCblMqvK4woxLqLgoiGVurNpeb/voMiaK20Or/aAizoqS7H+R fWVieRupXMeE7CeVezM7eFkvMN7Sypok7dRF2SGkURAWe++P/NqRMl1SVj+biUyLE0Q7JfCdFn21 CFw/F8axXQRunA3jShG4fTbAizKLjs4lVNja6uWcDXBSBF5RUpSKAqkJ5I8vlG+jMrJqPH3MO0Sc 1Ddpk3VZkr6K4TfkZn6rZPNPrOwynWpYbr+wt1Rsmdnc3I3NSl3M6MEW1QSotMgOdZ3Zl6moo5lZ 5WCzziaz6l6hxOqHj282Gtn4au9jVj9S8VNMGqyQNMSmUMWXCSW5OZvdMkkw4wzQZgFknwFaVaKt /gTkY6DN4vZYX5S8J9os5x/rE5H3REtr3Uff9e3aY+/+a6eNLuKf8C4Qrl2bgwG6EK3hQ/v6vp20 B/90h3dJU3yvlVzrt80/2w/Jyb3Vha6ioBJnHauJLjq+I9rNFrpotkTL6lh/J73N+2Fs5o7b7vRb mDz00G7etx+TDtatCbXcRdOeRotZfLeXXEnfRbImzZosabasW2to3kMfq900VD13jRZ6rPr373rd dmo9PhFVZHz2aLXavaT5YLasVbPT61rD3sr1/wDe/8ZiPSwAAA== --Boundary-00=_hJGnGeGxYAQF5Ky Content-Type: application/x-gzip; name="proc_output2.gz" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="proc_output2.gz" H4sICMhgnEYAA3Byb2Nfb3V0cHV0MgB9ktuOgjAQhu95irnUC0gLHlbuiGz2EN2YmHhjjOlC1UZs tS1G334H8BhwJyEpw/fP/EwHCMx/ZiIVDK6xCOEzjtwvaXkGbnGGinCgMe4AMAvktOLEJxgg9AF8 gioSwhzIAtkQEiWtVhlmaXitEILhh5zLhGsHaK+kXRSEkIq1sCwDlqdCwT5j51+WbBHqXyD6D+R3 XlZK2N7mmiPTfVnoxgTBg1MrdoVLAkamy03KlqKYk0OIS/CHopgO3k4QXwo1JK72gBbDqFoALfXk hkeSZWoN9fdGdeB8oNScjeW7yh9+pHgDHj65gVZxLm/EimRr2s4Em7komQzH94plDoXTUTR7rxBa Idc+ZeqZCOpE8Ex060T3kaANRuizEVo3Qh+MROmR4eqkMBIyP8FU5TKFSCcbYXlS8rEWRxzKjGsj lATqEY92PGeodnuRoRBz33mGm4frSvqwUhq2XEtcf9/reb7vUTdZGfdIB9Cajidtz/kD2qB/BDcD AAA= --Boundary-00=_hJGnGeGxYAQF5Ky Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Content-Disposition: inline _______________________________________________ Alsa-devel mailing list Alsa-devel@alsa-project.org http://mailman.alsa-project.org/mailman/listinfo/alsa-devel --Boundary-00=_hJGnGeGxYAQF5Ky--