From: julia.lawall@lip6.fr (Julia Lawall) Date: Thu, 1 Sep 2016 09:00:48 +0100 (IST) Subject: [Cocci] Querying Git commits with Prequel In-Reply-To: <2ab7c81b-852a-b090-6ea6-54906d7bab30@users.sourceforge.net> References: <2ab7c81b-852a-b090-6ea6-54906d7bab30@users.sourceforge.net> Message-ID: To: cocci@systeme.lip6.fr List-Id: cocci@systeme.lip6.fr On Thu, 1 Sep 2016, SF Markus Elfring wrote: > > Prequel is like Coccinelle, but for searching in Git commit histories. > > I am curious on how this software approach will evolve further. > > > > http://prequel-pql.gforge.inria.fr/ > > > > Feedback is welcome. > > I pick your offer up now. > > Thus I have read your research report 8918 (Prequel: A Patch-Like Query Language > for Commit History Search) to some degree. > > 1. I imagine that the activities behind the description for a chapter like > "5 Compilation of PQL into SmPL" triggered some development challenges. > > Does an interface exists to view the generated SmPL source code? It goes into the directory specified with the --tmp argument. > > 2. Did this new query language influence further improvements for the semantic > patch language? > > * Did the error reporting become a bit safer by this command usage? No. The code bases are separate, > * How much will the data format flexibility evolve together with the handling > of a key word like "flexible" for metavariables? No idea what this means (data format flexibility). > 3. I get concerns from the section "5.2 Idealized syntax". > How would you categorise it according to the Chomsky-Sch?tzenberger hierarchy? No idea. It seems like a straightforward BNF. > 4. How many means do you offer to restrict commit ranges according to the section > "6.1 Commit selection"? The commit range is just X..Y. X ad Y could be commit ids or tags (v4.0, for example). > 5. Can the combination of words like "token" and "regular expression" > be occasionally confusing? Does the word regular expression occur in the paper? > 6. How interesting will discussions become around the used hardware > that is mentioned in the chapter "7 Evaluation" and the corresponding > software performance? Not sure what there is to discuss. > 7. How is the status for function and class libraries for this application domain? No idea what this means. julia