Skip to contentSkip to conversation

openbkweb-0.0

DISCUSSION Nicolas Mailhot 2 participants 3 messages Feb 15, 2003 – Feb 16, 2003

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw
Quoted 2 lines

if you guys can't come to some sort of consensus, then patents are the route we'll choose, even German law respects patents.

Software is not patentable in Europe right now, much as it pisses of the patent office of the US of A (because it lowers the value of what they offer) and the EU patent offices (for much the same reasons).

Note that won't stop EU patent offices granting (and being paid for) software patents *now* for people that hope they'll be worth something later.

Please do not go the software patent route. If you think the current bk « debate » stinks, just wait till you put your finger in another hot issue (which software patents *are* in Europe, 'cos lots of people don't want the EU to follows the same braindamaged path as the USA).

You'll just shoot yourself in the foot. The shortcomings of CVS didn't spurn any serious free alternative for years, this won't change any time soon unless you start waving a red flag in front of everyone. Just provide any sort of CVS gateway, and most people will go back hacking elsewhere.

You did know creating bk would be an incentive for others to write similar free tools didn't you ? All patents/NDAs/legal threats won't change this fact. They'll only wipe out all the genuine goodwill you earned in the community by helping Linus. Just look at the latest messages, by invoquing all the stupid american legalese you've only managed to startle people in other parts of the world.

Right now inertia is your friend. Be smart and stop making a fuss.

Regards,

Signature · 1 line
Nicolas Mailhot
#1 lore raw

The amazing thing to me is that I don't see Larry making any threats. It's more like pleading "Please let us continue to do this great thing, and don't torpedo my company out of some misguided idea that BK should be free just because you don't want to have to pay for it."

#2 lore raw
Quoted 4 lines · Le sam 15/02/2003 à 21:42, [email protected] a écrit :

The amazing thing to me is that I don't see Larry making any threats. It's more like pleading "Please let us continue to do this great thing, and don't torpedo my company out of some misguided idea that BK should be free just because you don't want to have to pay for it."

Larry is asking for assurances he obviously can't get, else he'll regrettably have to do [lots of things generally frown upon in the community]

Which is why I advised him to cool down (despite me being in position to profit from a free bk clone creation like lots of other people). It's painful to see him feed the flamewars after all the good work he's done. And i'm sure that being the smart guy he is, he knows it. He just can't help himself:(.

Regards,

Signature · 1 line
Nicolas Mailhot