IBM T23; quirks force enable interrupts in APM set power state, causes crash on suspend
Quoted 3 lines
Summary:
dmi_scan.cforces interrupt enable on during PCI BIOS call for all IBM machines, which breaks T23, which needs it off it seems.
[...]
Quoted 3 lines
BIOS Vendor: IBM
BIOS Version: 1AET38WW (1.01b)
BIOS Release: 07/27/2001
I would suggest that you try upgrading your firmware before concluding that your patch is necessary. The latest firmware listed on IBM's website is version 1.03 = 1AET43WW, released 19 October 2001. There have been a LOT of changes since version 1.01 of the firmware. Here is IBM's changelog:
Quoted 31 lines
I. Summary of changes
version 1.01 - 1AET38WW(New) Support for ThinkPad T23.
version 1.02 - 1AET40WW
(New) Support F11 key handling on logo screen for new
recovery program.
NOTE: xKx and xLx models are not supported.
(Fix) IBM Token-Ring PC card does not work after Hibernation
wakeup under Microsoft Windows 98.
(Fix) FDD read/write access fail on Microsoft Windows XP. (Fix) POST 175 error appear.
(Fix) USB device which is connected to USB port in docking
station does not work on Microsoft Windows 95.
(Fix) System can not boot from USB Portable Device Bay. (Fix) Japanese message of eFlash is corrupted. (Fix) Two different docking configuration is made. (Fix) Ctrl+Alt+Del cause system hang on DOS/V. (Fix) Blue screen appear after standby/resume on Microsoft
Windows 2000 or Windows XP.
(Fix) Noise appear when TV out is used.version 1.03 - 1AET43WW
(Fix) Resume hang occur on Windows 2000 when USB CCD
camera is attached.
(Fix) RIPL from PCMCIA TokeRing adapter card in docking station
does not work.
(Fix) UltraDMA mode 5 (ATA/100) does not enabled on Windows 2000.
Thomas,
Quoted 8 lines · --On Saturday, 03 November, 2001 7:20 PM -0500 Thomas Hood <[email protected]>…
Quoted 3 lines
Summary:
dmi_scan.cforces interrupt enable on during PCI BIOS call for all IBM machines, which breaks T23, which needs it off it seems.[...]
Quoted 3 lines
BIOS Vendor: IBM
BIOS Version: 1AET38WW (1.01b)
BIOS Release: 07/27/2001
Quoted 5 lines
I would suggest that you try upgrading your firmware before concluding that your patch is necessary. The latest firmware listed on IBM's website is version 1.03 = 1AET43WW, released 19 October 2001. There have been a LOT of changes since version 1.01 of the firmware. Here is IBM's changelog:
Here's the results
With my patch on 2.4.12-ac5, it was working.
First I took Arjan's pci-bridge patch alone (no BIOS upgrade etc.). It crashes the machine on suspend.
Then I tried upgrading the BIOS firmware (to 1.03) and the embedded controller firmware (to 1.02) - i.e. without Arjan's patch, still running 2.4.12-ac5. It doesn't resume properly and hung APM but didn't crash.
I believe this may be because I fixed the .config to run the sound driver at the same time, and it oops'd, and generally annoyed the suspend process - tsk tsk changing too many variables at once.
Then I upgraded to 2.4.13-ac7 (which has Arjan's patch in). All is now well. Any luck & I'll have sound working too :-)
My conclusion is that the BIOS upgrade fixed the necessity to call APM BIOS with interrupts off, so the dmi_scan.c stuff which forces interrupts on is now harmless.
So if you want to put a patch in, I guess it could at least not break things on early T-23 BIOS's (as that's what the dmi_scan does - as the config option no longer has any effect), or at the /very/ least, document the fact that a BIOS & embedded controller upgrade is extremely advisable.
[ I am recording T23 experiences at
http://www.alex.org.uk/T23
for anyone interested - especially in contributing]
--
Alex Bligh
Re: [PATCH] IBM T23; quirks force enable interrupts in APM set
Quoted 3 lines
So if you want to put a patch in, I guess it could at least not break things on early T-23 BIOS's (as that's what the
dmi_scandoes - as the config
Send me the dmi strings (dmidecode output) for the old and new BIOS, the URL for the firmware and not only can I make the kernel ensure they are called IRQ off, I can make it tell you where ot get new firmware
Re: [PATCH] IBM T23; quirks force enable interrupts in APM set
Alan,
Quoted 3 lines
Send me the dmi strings (dmidecode output) for the old and new BIOS, the URL for the firmware and not only can I make the kernel ensure they are called IRQ off, I can make it tell you where ot get new firmware
Short of dmidecode, assuming you're going to do what I think you're going to do, I think the following should be sufficient (change dmi_printk to use printk). If you really need dmidecode, give me a pointer to it, not that I'm sure how to revert the BIOS image...
This is assuming it's the BIOS which causes the problem, as opposed to the embedded controller which I upgraded from 1.00 to 1.02 contemperaneously.
And the answer to 'where is the new firmware' is, for BIOS & embedded controller:
http://www.pc.ibm.com/qtechinfo/MIGR-39366.html
http://www.pc.ibm.com/qtechinfo/MIGR-40022.html
Sadly they aren't indexed properly from the main IBM site (i.e. find 'T23 BIOS' finds 1.02).
Old (BIOS 1.01b)
All processors have done init_idle
DMI 0.0 present.
48 structures occupying 1720 bytes.
DMI table at 0x27F7C000.
BIOS Vendor: IBM
BIOS Version: 1AET38WW (1.01b)
BIOS Release: 07/27/2001
System Vendor: IBM.
Product Name: 26479LU.
Version Not Available.
Serial Number 787PR4K.
Board Vendor: IBM.
Board Name: 26479LU.
Board Version: Not Available.
Asset Tag: No Asset Information.
IBM machine detected. Enabling interrupts during APM calls.
New Bios (1.03b)
DMI 0.0 present.
48 structures occupying 1720 bytes.
DMI table at 0x27F7C000.
BIOS Vendor: IBM
BIOS Version: 1AET43WW (1.03b)
BIOS Release: 09/25/2001
System Vendor: IBM.
Product Name: 26479LU.
Version Not Available.
Serial Number 787PR4K.
Board Vendor: IBM.
Board Name: 26479LU.
Board Version: Not Available.
Asset Tag: No Asset Information.
IBM machine detected. Enabling interrupts during APM calls.
--
Alex Bligh