Coding style - a non-issue
I have been following this thread with a mixture of amusement and exasperation - amusement that intelligent people like Linus, who ought to know better, are spouting this evolution stuff, and exasperation that some people think that because someone's an expert in one thing, they are an expert in all things.
The idea of genetic evolution itself is complete nonsense - biological systems don't evolve genetically, they evolve environmentally. Biological systems change as a result of random mutation, and what doesn't work doesn't survive. What people try to pass off as evolution is simply the less fit not surviving to pass on their bad genes. Sort of like the hundred monkeys idea.
But that is all completely irrelevent to coding, since it is extremely inefficient for systems to "evolve" based on trial and error. The way modern systems evolve is based on (hopefully) *intelligent* selection - I write a patch, submit it to Linus. He doesn't accept it, throw it in the kernel, and that's it - he looks at it, what it does, and decides if it fits in the Grand Scheme of things - kernel efficiency, speed, flexibility, extensability, and maintainability - and *then* decides if it makes it in. They key difference is that in nature, mutation is random because it can afford to be - in coding, it isn't because we don't have thousands or millions of years to find out whether or not something works or not.
That being said, I am well aware that "genetic programming" has made some progress in that direction, mainly because it doesn't take millenia to figure out what works and what doesn't. But that's a long way from "evolving" an entire operating system. I don't believe for a moment that homo sapiens "evolved" from pond scum although I might believe that some fellow homo sapiens *are* pond scum!) - it only makes sense that we are a created species, and that Homo Erectus ans all the rest were early genetic experiments. Who created homo sapiens is beyond the scope of this discussion ;)
Original Message:
-----------------
From: Larry McVoy [email protected]
Date: Sun, 02 Dec 2001 12:25:26 -0800
To: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]
Subject: Re: Coding style - a non-issue
Quoted 7 lines · Horst von Brand
Quoted 2 lines · Victor Yodaiken
Linux is what it is because of design, not accident. And you know that better than anyone.
I'd say it is better because the mutations themselves (individual patches) go through a _very_ harsh evaluation before being applied in the "official" sources.
Which is exactly Victor's point. That evaluation is the design. If the mutation argument held water then Linus would apply *ALL* patches and then remove the bad ones. But he doesn't. Which just goes to show that on this mutation nonsense, he's just spouting off.
Signature · 11 lines
--- Larry McVoy lm at bitmover.com http://www.bitmover.com/lm - To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to [email protected] More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/ -------------------------------------------------------------------- mail2web - Check your email from the web at http://mail2web.com/ .
Quoted 1 line · On Sun, 2 Dec 2001 15:53:46 -0500 "[email protected]" <[email protected]> wrote:
I have been following this thread with a mixture of amusement and exasperation - amusement that intelligent people like Linus, who ought to know better, are spouting this evolution stuff, and exasperation that some people think that because someone's an expert in one thing, they are an expert in all things.
No offense toward anyone but I find that many non-religious people can be found in the CompSci area of expertise. I'm not sure why this is but besides myself and another friend all the other people I know in that general field are atheists. It would only make sense that we would hear atheist type remarks within these discussions just as we would hear Christian remarks in another field of expertise that seems to attract Christians.
Quoted 2 lines
The idea of genetic evolution itself is complete nonsense - biological systems don't evolve genetically, they evolve environmentally. Biological systems change as a result of random mutation, and what doesn't work doesn't survive. What people try to pass off as evolution is simply the less fit not surviving to pass on their bad genes. Sort of like the hundred monkeys idea.
True. Many mutations in human DNA cause the resulting human to be unable to reproduce once they reach the age where a normal human could do so.
Quoted 2 lines
But that is all completely irrelevent to coding, since it is extremely inefficient for systems to "evolve" based on trial and error. The way modern systems evolve is based on (hopefully) *intelligent* selection - I write a patch, submit it to Linus. He doesn't accept it, throw it in the kernel, and that's it - he looks at it, what it does, and decides if it fits in the Grand Scheme of things - kernel efficiency, speed, flexibility, extensability, and maintainability - and *then* decides if it makes it in. They key difference is that in nature, mutation is random because it can afford to be - in coding, it isn't because we don't have thousands or millions of years to find out whether or not something works or not.
We have a way of being able to direct the evolution of our code as we can control the bad parts and teh good parts and what gets added and what doesn't. We have no control over our DNA (human genetics may have proven me wrong already but if not, it shouldn't take more than a few months more) so mutations in the human race are more random.
Quoted 2 lines
That being said, I am well aware that "genetic programming" has made some progress in that direction, mainly because it doesn't take millenia to figure out what works and what doesn't. But that's a long way from "evolving" an entire operating system. I don't believe for a moment that homo sapiens "evolved" from pond scum although I might believe that some fellow homo sapiens *are* pond scum!) -
*finally* someone who doesn't believe in evolution of the human race. As a side note, i've heard some people say that a bolt of lightning triggered some proteins to start growing into single celled organisms and then into what we now call today human beings. I take offense that I came from a single celled organism. I believe the more complex an object or system is the less randomness can be added in order to arrive at the current/final version. I think we all agree the human body is the most complex object in the universe so how can we say that our existence was an accident?
An operating system is a complex system as well. We all know code doesn't evolve on its own to generate an operating system right? :) It has to be created and as time goes on code forks are sometimes introduced. In humans that could be somewhat akin to whites, blacks, asians, etc. But they were all created from the code that God started with. He just released his source code(dna) a little later in the development tree than some people may have wanted so there was no point in letting us evolve into something more as we were already different enough. :)
Quoted 1 line
it only makes sense that we are a created species, and that Homo Erectus ans all the rest were early genetic > experiments. Who created homo sapiens is beyond the scope of this discussion ;)
It is beyond the scope. If we attempted that topic we would be branded as close-minded even though the others (read: non-religious) can do it and they defend themselves by saying its free speech.
my time is out for this post.
brandon
brandon wrote:
| | *finally* someone who doesn't believe in evolution of the human race. | As a side note, i've heard some people say that a bolt of lightning | triggered some proteins to start growing into single celled organisms | and then into what we now call today human beings. I take offense | that I came from a single celled organism. I believe the more complex | an object or system is the less randomness can be added in order to | arrive at the current/final version. I think we all agree the human | body is the most complex object in the universe so how can we say that | our existence was an accident?
Again, a complete misunderstanding of evolution. Evolution is itself a design process.. it is simply a design process that admits to an literally unthinkable amount of complexity. No individual or team of individuals, no matter how intelligent, could sit down and create from scratch the Linux kernel as it exists today. There are tons and tons of design elements in the code that emerged from trial and error, and from interactions between the hardware to be supported, the user level code to run on it, and the temporal exigencies of the kernel code itself. The fact that humans applied thought to all (well, at least to some) of the changes made doesn't mean that the overarching dynamic isn't an evolutionary one.
Taking offense at evolution having produced us from simpler organisms is like taking offense at the rain, or the sun setting at night. We can now look at life and actually read the code, and see how much is held in common and how much varies between different organisms, just as surely as we can with all of the linux kernels over the last ten years. Both systems have lots of characteristics in common, and for perfect reasons.
Linus is right.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Jonathan Abbey [email protected]
Applied Research Laboratories The University of Texas at Austin
Ganymede, a GPL'ed metadirectory for UNIX http://www.arlut.utexas.edu/gash2
On Sun, 2 Dec 2001, Brandon McCombs wrote:
[snip badly-formatted creationism advocacy]
Please, learn to
* use line breaks
* be intellectually honest
* be at least remotely on-topic
*plonk*
Quoted 3 lines
*finally* someone who doesn't believe in evolution of the human race. As a side note, i've heard some people say that a bolt of lightning triggered some proteins to start growing into single celled organisms and then into what we now call today human beings. I take offense that I came from a single celled organism. I believe the more complex an object or system is the less randomness can be added in order to arrive at the current/final version. I think we all agree the human body is the most complex object in the universe so how can we say that our existence was an accident?
I personally will stay out of the religious side of this argument, having been flamed for standing up for any religious stand point on this list.
However, I just finished my two bio classes for my CS degree. It is interesting that you mention this lightening theory. My bio book (sorry no references and no quotes, maybe later) stated that many people (60's-80's) have tried very hard to duplicate and find conditions whereby simple molecules could even form basic RNA or other such biological/organic compounds. They had some very minimal success. In the end it was concluded that the methods they were trying probably would never have created RNA and other such things that may have assembled a cell. Some of these tests were based on this lightening theory.
Maybe such spontaneous life could have happened another way... I don't really know.
As for software evolution. I would have to weigh in with my opinion being somewhere between Linus and many others. Software does evolve. Just about any human project does. This is one reason why there are "versions", "editions", etc. You can only design so much. Then you go back and evolve it. Is Linus right that there was nearly no design?? I think he would know best about the earliest roots of Linux. However, I think he is wrong that now there is no design (though there may be no master plan, which would mean it is controlled evolution more than engineered/designed).
Anyway, I will sink back into silence for now.
Trever Adams
Quoted 5 lines · On December 2, 2001 09:53 pm, [email protected] wrote:
I have been following this thread with a mixture of amusement and exasperation - amusement that intelligent people like Linus, who ought to know better, are spouting this evolution stuff, and exasperation that some people think that because someone's an expert in one thing, they are an expert in all things.
That's because you're not quite clear on the concept.
Quoted 1 line
...in nature, mutation is random
It isn't random, if it were most mutated individuals would be stillborn.
Quoted 1 line
because it can afford to be...
No it can't.
--
Daniel