Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Changing KB, MB, and GB to KiB, MiB, and GiB in Configure.help.

DISCUSSION Christian Groessler 7 participants 9 messages Dec 21, 2001 – Dec 26, 2001

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw
Quoted 7 lines · GMT Mike Jagdis
Quoted 3 lines · Mike Eldridge

i was going to comment about simply using lowercase equivalents, but then milli already has 'm', although the concept of a millibyte (or even millibit) is absurd.

Quoted 5 lines

Why? For instance a millibyte/s might be a hearbeat across a LAN every hour or so or it might be a control traffic requirement for a deep space probe. You might not have an immediate use for the term but it has a specific meaning - and certainly isn't "absurd" (see definition on
http://www.dict.org).

So, is it 1/1024 or 1/1000 bytes ? :-)

regards,
chris

#1 lore raw
Quoted 8 lines · Christian Groessler
Quoted 7 lines · GMT Mike Jagdis
Quoted 3 lines · Mike Eldridge

i was going to comment about simply using lowercase equivalents, but then milli already has 'm', although the concept of a millibyte (or even millibit) is absurd.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 5 lines

Why? For instance a millibyte/s might be a hearbeat across a LAN every hour or so or it might be a control traffic requirement for a deep space probe. You might not have an immediate use for the term but it has a specific meaning - and certainly isn't "absurd" (see definition on
http://www.dict.org).

So, is it 1/1024 or 1/1000 bytes ? :-)

1/1024. Because we are talking about byte.

Rene

#2 lore raw
Quoted 9 lines · Rene Engelhard
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 5 lines

Why? For instance a millibyte/s might be a hearbeat across a LAN every hour or so or it might be a control traffic requirement for a deep space probe. You might not have an immediate use for the term but it has a specific meaning - and certainly isn't "absurd" (see definition on
http://www.dict.org).

So, is it 1/1024 or 1/1000 bytes ? :-)

1/1024. Because we are talking about byte.

What does bytes have to do with anything? Is it
1/(2^3 * 10^7) or 1/(2^3 * 2^7)? We're talking about expressing a number of "bytes"; terms of the base number system don't have any bearing -- and that's the problem. RAM and addressing are restricted to expressions in terms of binary numbers, as in 2^10, 2^20, etc. Hard drive manufacturers feel it's neccessary to express storage in terms of base 10 numbers of bytes, even though a sector is 2^9 bytes. In networking, absolute numbers of bits on the wire are whats important. Though for some reason telecom engineers have pinned megabit as 1,024,000 bits. Experienced CS people can glean the proper definition from context, but the terms should really lend themselves to accurate definition all the time. If I just say off the cuff that I'm going to send you a megabyte of data, do I mean 1,000,000 bytes, 1,048,576 bytes, or 1,024,000 bytes? With the new measures those would be a megabyte, a mebibyte, and 1,024 kilobytes respectively.

Personally I feel that "kibibyte(KiB)" and "mebibyte(MiB)" are silly, but they are technically unambiguous.

Regards,
Reid
--
"Public sentiment is everything. With public sentiment, nothing can fail; without it nothing can succeed." -- Abraham Lincoln

Quoted 2 lines

Rene

#3 lore raw
Quoted 7 lines · Reid Hekman
Quoted 6 lines · Rene Engelhard
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 5 lines

Why? For instance a millibyte/s might be a hearbeat across a LAN every hour or so or it might be a control traffic requirement for a deep space probe. You might not have an immediate use for the term but it has a specific meaning - and certainly isn't "absurd" (see definition on
http://www.dict.org).

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 1 line

So, is it 1/1024 or 1/1000 bytes ? :-)

1/1024. Because we are talking about byte.

What does bytes have to do with anything? Is it
1/(2^3 * 10^7) or 1/(2^3 * 2^7)? We're talking about expressing a number of "bytes"; terms of the base number system don't have any bearing -- and that's the problem. RAM and addressing are restricted to expressions

Right.

8 Bit = 1 Byte
1024 Byte = 1 KB
1024 KB = 1 MB
1024 MB ...

So we are talking about that, beacuse the X-Byte is defined as 1024 and not as 1000 of the previous step.

Quoted 9 lines

in terms of binary numbers, as in 2^10, 2^20, etc. Hard drive manufacturers feel it's neccessary to express storage in terms of base 10 numbers of bytes, even though a sector is 2^9 bytes. In networking, absolute numbers of bits on the wire are whats important. Though for some reason telecom engineers have pinned megabit as 1,024,000 bits. Experienced CS people can glean the proper definition from context, but the terms should really lend themselves to accurate definition all the time. If I just say off the cuff that I'm going to send you a megabyte of data, do I mean 1,000,000 bytes, 1,048,576 bytes, or 1,024,000 bytes?

What _you_ mean can not be determied from me.
But *I* would mean 1.048.574, otherwise I would say the 9xxx number or say nearly 1 MB.

Quoted 2 lines

With the new measures those would be a megabyte, a mebibyte, and 1,024 kilobytes respectively.

That's the sense of them.

Rene

#4 lore raw

Hi Rene.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines

If I just say off the cuff that I'm going to send you a megabyte of data, do I mean 1,000,000 bytes, 1,048,576 bytes, or 1,024,000 bytes?

What _you_ mean can not be determied from me. But *I* would mean 1.048.574, otherwise I would say the 9xxx number or say nearly 1 MB.

You obviously give short change as a matter of course then...

(Assuming that you use . as a thousands separator rather than as a decimal point the way most of the Enlish speaking world does)

Best wishes from Riley.

#5 lore raw
In reply to Rene Engelhard
Quoted 5 lines · Rene Engelhard
Quoted 2 lines · Christian Groessler

So, is it 1/1024 or 1/1000 bytes ? :-)

1/1024. Because we are talking about byte.

Bollocks. How can I put this politely? Don't anyone ever send me a CV unless you know the technical basics!

Go look up "SI binary prefix" and "SI prefix" on Google. You might not _like_ the binary prefixes (I don't either) but they're what's been standardized and they're unambiguous. It does no good to claim that it's enough that *you* know what you mean. This isn't Alice in Wonderland (you can look that reference up in your spare time :-) ).

Mike

P.S. After you've understood the SI system you should be able to tell us what the binary prefix equivalent for m is and why K as a prefix is a mark of stupidity...

#6 lore raw
Quoted 10 lines · Mike Jagdis
Quoted 5 lines · Rene Engelhard
Quoted 2 lines · Christian Groessler

So, is it 1/1024 or 1/1000 bytes ? :-)

1/1024. Because we are talking about byte.

Bollocks. How can I put this politely? Don't anyone ever send me a CV unless you know the technical basics!

OK, I answered to fast, not reading the mails correct and without concentration
Surely, millibytes does not make any sense...

Quoted 5 lines

Go look up "SI binary prefix" and "SI prefix" on Google. You might not _like_ the binary prefixes (I don't either) but they're what's been standardized and they're unambiguous. It does no good to claim that it's enough that *you* know what you mean. This isn't Alice in Wonderland (you can look that reference up in your spare time :-) ).

A long time ago the MB was under computer scientiests defined as 1024 KB ans we had used it it one or two decades. Then the hardware manufactures started to call 1 MB = 1000 MB and that's shit.

I know this problem, I also know the problem, that is gonna be confusing. I do not insist to change it but I think it is better to make clear what is defined as 1000 or 1024 insted using MB for both.

Quoted 3 lines

P.S. After you've understood the SI system you should be able to tell us what the binary prefix equivalent for m is and why K as a prefix is a mark of stupidity...

Have I said that?

Then I apopolgize. Otherwise I read the mail I replied not as careful as I should and I talked at this moment whitch someone so I was not as concentraded as I had to...

Rene

#7 lore raw
In reply to Rene Engelhard
Quoted 10 lines · Mike Jagdis
Quoted 5 lines · Rene Engelhard
Quoted 2 lines · Christian Groessler

So, is it 1/1024 or 1/1000 bytes ? :-)

1/1024. Because we are talking about byte.

Bollocks. How can I put this politely? Don't anyone ever send me a CV unless you know the technical basics!

The IEC has adopted these units, not SI. And you could argue that the IEC has gotten it completely wrong.

Basic unit of length:      1 m
Basic unit of weight:      1 g

...
Basic unit of information: 1 *bit*

Not a byte. A byte is 8 basic units of information.

To be consistent (as with SI), all prefixes should be applied to the basic unit of measurement - in this case, a bit. And one kilobit == 1000 bits; one megabit == 1 million bits.

Saying "kilobyte" is like saying "micromicrofarad" or "megakilometer".

However, you *could* also argue that the IEC has it correct. IIRC, physicists researching electrostatics/magnetostatics at least used to use (and maybe still do) the centimeter/gram/second units - e.g. an abcoulomb, which ends up being 10 coulombs. For whatever reason, convention among this group of people means using cgs units. For whatever reason, convention among computer people is to use units of 8 bits - 1 byte - as a measurement standard.

Quoted 5 lines

Go look up "SI binary prefix" and "SI prefix" on Google. You might not _like_ the binary prefixes (I don't either) but they're what's been standardized and they're unambiguous. It does no good to claim that it's enough that *you* know what you mean. This isn't Alice in Wonderland (you can look that reference up in your spare time :-) ).

SI standards have been around for years. Yet many mechanical engineers in the US still use English units. Convention and economics dictate that they do so; any change in this field is quite slow.

Somehow I expect that the same convention and economics factors will also dominate the argument over prefixes for bits of information in this field for years to come as well.

-Bob