2.4.20-18 size-4096 memory leaks
Hi Yuval, hi list,
Quoted 3 lines
I'm seeing a constant leak in size-4096 on a machine running 2.4.20-18 SMP BIGMEM, which might / might not be related to the machine finally going out of memory and going into a hang.
I just wanted to let you know that I have been experiencing similar leaks. So far, I wasn't enable to find where the leak was, but your theory matches my observations:
1* On two systems running 2.4.20-2.4.22 kernels, I observed that the free memory as reported by top was going down regularly, by blocks of 4 or 8kB at an average rate of 90kB/min. Sometimes the value would stabilize, but I couldn't understand why. What was lost as "free" memory
increased "buffers" from the same amount. Still that value doesn't exceed a few dozen MB and sometimes goes does by large blocks, so I was wondering if there was a real leak or if it was just some kind of regular prebuffering.
2* On two other, seemingly similar systems, the memory leak wouldn't occur. It happens that these two systems do *not* use ext3, while the fisrt two *do* use ext3.
3* The leak isn't distribution specific. I experienced it on both a Mandrake-shipped kernel and a self-compiled one on a Slackware system.
Your theory that it comes from the ext3 driver makes full sense. I'll confirm that later today, by using ext2 only on one of the leaking systems (without changing kernels of course).
The other leaking system is used as a development server. It used to become very slow after several days. We are now restarting it every monday and have no significant slowdown anymore. Having other things to do, I stopped my experiments there, but could do some more now if it can help.
Signature · 5 lines
Jean Delvare http://www.ensicaen.ismra.fr/~delvare/ ---------------------------------------------------------------- This message was sent using IMP, the Internet Messaging Program.
Hi,
Quoted 10 lines · Jean Delvare
I just wanted to let you know that I have been experiencing similar leaks. So far, I wasn't enable to find where the leak was, but your theory matches my observations:
1* On two systems running 2.4.20-2.4.22 kernels, I observed that the free memory as reported by top was going down regularly, by blocks of 4 or 8kB at an average rate of 90kB/min. Sometimes the value would stabilize, but I couldn't understand why. What was lost as "free" memory
increased "buffers" from the same amount.
That's not a leak, it simply sounds like cache effects. atime updates result in journal commits under ext3, and those use at least a couple of buffers at a time (one for the metadata descriptor block in the journal, one for the journal commit.) Those aren't leaks --- they are temporary use of cache, and once the IO has complete the memory can be immediately reclaimed by the kernel if it is needed for anything else.
Cheers,
Stephen