Skip to contentSkip to conversation

lsm: add bsdjail module

PATCH Colin Walters 1 participant 1 message Nov 22, 2004

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

[ Sorry for the lack of References, I'm not on this list and had to grab the message from the web archives ]

Quoted 11 lines · Andrew Morton
Quoted 2 lines

I don't recall anyone requesting this feature. Tell me why we should add it to Linux?

Subject to the code cleanups and stuff you've noted I'd actually like to see BSD jail stuff in our security modules because it has the virtue of simplicity. If it can be extended to do all of vserver even better. J Random Admin has a good chance at configuring BSD jails etups. J Random Admin needs some serious tools that don't exist to set up SELinux the same way.

Quoted 2 lines

In the security world simplicity is often a virtue, both in code and concepts.

BSD jails are a kind of halfway point on the
"access control <-> virtualization" sliding scale. Certainly, using SELinux for virtualization is not trivial, and I think that's fine; it is not its intended purpose. But let's be honest - using BSD jails for strong access control ("security") has its own downsides. For example, now J Random Admin has N rpm/dpkg databases to manage on the same system instead of one. Or they have hand-rolled chroots which need their own special treatment, scripts, etc.

In other words, BSD jails and SELinux are certainly not the same thing. This becomes more obvious when you realize that hey - SELinux is still useful inside a BSD jail. Why should the cracked sendmail daemon be able to destroy your configuration and the rest of the chroot? You might even want BSD jails to enforce different SELinux policies.