cdrecord dev=ATA cannont scanbus as non-root
Hi all...
I'm trying to get out of the mess that cd burning looks like nowadays in linux...
As I use a 2.6.x kernel, I folowed this hints:
- no suid cdrecord, it uses capabilities
- make the burner owned by console user (pam)
cdrecord burns ok using dev=/dev/burner, but I can't get GUI tools to burn using the /dev interface. All of them try to load ide-scsi, and do a scan based on ATAPI:.
Some tools try to scan with dev=ATA:x:y:z, but that does not work as normal user.
How can I make 'cdrecord dev=ATA -scanbus' work as non-root ?
TIA
--
J.A. Magallon <jamagallon()able!es> \ Software is like sex:
werewolf!able!es \ It's better when it's free
Mandrakelinux release 10.2 (Cooker) for i586
Linux 2.6.10-rc2-jam3 (gcc 3.4.1 (Mandrakelinux 10.1 3.4.1-4mdk)) #1
Quoted 9 lines
Hi all...
I'm trying to get out of the mess that cd burning looks like nowadays in linux...
As I use a 2.6.x kernel, I folowed this hints:
- no suid cdrecord, it uses capabilities
- make the burner owned by console user (pam)
Quoted 5 lines
cdrecord burns ok using dev=/dev/burner, but I can't get GUI tools to burn using the /dev interface. All of them try to load ide-scsi, and do a scan based on ATAPI:.
Some tools try to scan with dev=ATA:x:y:z, but that does not work as normal user.
Maybe because it should have been dev=ATAPI: ?
Quoted 1 line
How can I make 'cdrecord dev=ATA -scanbus' work as non-root ?
Weird, works for me:
22:49 io:~ > cdrecord -dev=ATAPI: -scanbus
Cdrecord-Clone 2.01 (i686-suse-linux) Copyright (C) 1995-2004 J�rg Schilling
Note: This version is an unofficial (modified) version
Note: and therefore may have bugs that are not present in the original.
Note: Please send bug reports or support requests to
http://www.suse.de/feedbackNote: The author of cdrecord should not be bothered with problems in this version.
scsidev: 'ATAPI:'
devname: 'ATAPI'
scsibus: -1 target: -1 lun: -1
Warning: Using ATA Packet interface.
Warning: The related Linux kernel interface code seems to be unmaintained.
Warning: There is absolutely NO DMA, operations thus are slow.
cdrecord: No such file or directory. Cannot open SCSI driver.
cdrecord: For possible targets try 'cdrecord -scanbus'. Make sure you are root.
cdrecord: For possible transport specifiers try 'cdrecord dev=help'. 22:50 io:/dev # chmod 666 /dev/hdd
22:50 io:~ > cdrecord -dev=ATAPI: -scanbus
Cdrecord-Clone 2.01 (i686-suse-linux) Copyright (C) 1995-2004 J�rg Schilling [...]
Warning: The related Linux kernel interface code seems to be unmaintained.
Warning: There is absolutely NO DMA, operations thus are slow. Using libscg version 'schily-0.8'.
scsibus0:
0,0,0 0) *
0,1,0 1) 'AOPEN ' 'CD-RW CRW1232PRO' '1.00' Removable CD-ROM
0,2,0 2) *
0,3,0 3) *
0,4,0 4) *
0,5,0 5) *
0,6,0 6) *
0,7,0 7) *And further (in addition to above):
22:50 io:/dev # chmod 666 /dev/hdb
22:50 io:~ > cdrecord -dev=ATAPI: -scanbus
scsibus0:
0,0,0 0) *
cdrecord: Warning: controller returns wrong size for CD capabilities page.
0,1,0 1) ' ' 'ATAPI CDROM ' '100H' Removable CD-ROM
0,2,0 2) *
0,3,0 3) *
0,4,0 4) *
0,5,0 5) *
0,6,0 6) *
0,7,0 7) *
scsibus1:
1,0,0 100) *
1,1,0 101) 'AOPEN ' 'CD-RW CRW1232PRO' '1.00' Removable CD-ROM
1,2,0 102) *
1,3,0 103) *
1,4,0 104) *
1,5,0 105) *
1,6,0 106) *
1,7,0 107) *Apart from the fact that scsibus shifts up by one, Works For Me(TM)
Jan Engelhardt
Signature · 2 lines
Gesellschaft für Wissenschaftliche Datenverarbeitung Am Fassberg, 37077 Göttingen, www.gwdg.de
Quoted 15 lines · Jan Engelhardt
Quoted 9 lines
Hi all...
I'm trying to get out of the mess that cd burning looks like nowadays in linux...
As I use a 2.6.x kernel, I folowed this hints:
- no suid cdrecord, it uses capabilities
- make the burner owned by console user (pam)Quoted 5 lines
cdrecord burns ok using dev=/dev/burner, but I can't get GUI tools to burn using the /dev interface. All of them try to load ide-scsi, and do a scan based on ATAPI:.
Some tools try to scan with dev=ATA:x:y:z, but that does not work as normal user.
Quoted 7 lines
Maybe because it should have been dev=ATAPI: ?
Quoted 1 line
How can I make 'cdrecord dev=ATA -scanbus' work as non-root ?
Weird, works for me:
22:49 io:~ > cdrecord -dev=ATAPI: -scanbus
dev=ATAPI uses ide-scsi interface, through /dev/sgX. And:
Quoted 4 lines
scsibus: -1 target: -1 lun: -1
Warning: Using ATA Packet interface.
Warning: The related Linux kernel interface code seems to be unmaintained.
Warning: There is absolutely NO DMA, operations thus are slow.
dev=ATA uses direct IDE burning. Try that as root. In my box, as root:
werewolf:~# cdrecord dev=ATAPI -scanbus
scsibus0:
0,0,0 0) *
0,1,0 1) 'TOSHIBA ' 'DVD-ROM SD-M1712' '1004' Removable CD-ROM
0,2,0 2) *
0,3,0 3) *
0,4,0 4) *
0,5,0 5) *
0,6,0 6) *
0,7,0 7) *
scsibus1:
1,0,0 100) 'HL-DT-ST' 'DVDRAM GSA-4120B' 'A102' Removable CD-ROM
1,1,0 101) *
1,2,0 102) *
1,3,0 103) *
1,4,0 104) *
1,5,0 105) *
1,6,0 106) *
1,7,0 107) *werewolf:~# cdrecord dev=ATA -scanbus scsidev: 'ATA' devname: 'ATA' scsibus: -2 target: -2 lun: -2 ######################################################################################### # # Warning: Using ATAPI via /dev/hd* interface. Use dev=ATA:X,Y,Z or dev=/dev/hdX # #########################################################################################
scsibus0:
0,0,0 0) *
0,1,0 1) 'TOSHIBA ' 'DVD-ROM SD-M1712' '1004' Removable CD-ROM
0,2,0 2) *
0,3,0 3) *
0,4,0 4) *
0,5,0 5) *
0,6,0 6) *
0,7,0 7) *
scsibus1:
1,0,0 100) 'HL-DT-ST' 'DVDRAM GSA-4120B' 'A102' Removable CD-ROM
1,1,0 101) *
1,2,0 102) *
1,3,0 103) *
1,4,0 104) *
1,5,0 105) *
1,6,0 106) *
1,7,0 107) *The scan through ATA lasts much less than with ATAPI, and you can burn with dev=ATA:1,0,0 or dev=/dev/burner, which is the new recommended way.
But as I said, scanning through ATA is not avaliable to normal users, so it is someway useless.
--
J.A. Magallon <jamagallon()able!es> \ Software is like sex:
werewolf!able!es \ It's better when it's free
Mandrakelinux release 10.2 (Cooker) for i586
Linux 2.6.10-rc2-jam3 (gcc 3.4.1 (Mandrakelinux 10.1 3.4.1-4mdk)) #1
Quoted 1 line
dev=ATAPI uses ide-scsi interface, through
/dev/sgX. And:
I do not have the ide-scsi.ko module even compiled, and it works. The ATA: scanbus thing works for me as a normal user too (forgot to add that)
Signature · 2 lines
Gesellschaft für Wissenschaftliche Datenverarbeitung Am Fassberg, 37077 Göttingen, www.gwdg.de
Quoted 8 lines · J.A. Magallon
dev=ATAPI uses ide-scsi interface, through
/dev/sgX. And:Quoted 4 lines
scsibus: -1 target: -1 lun: -1
Warning: Using ATA Packet interface.
Warning: The related Linux kernel interface code seems to be unmaintained.
Warning: There is absolutely NO DMA, operations thus are slow.dev=ATA uses direct IDE burning. Try that as root. In my box, as root:
Oh no, not this again... Please check the facts: the ATAPI method uses the SG_IO ioctl, which is direct-to-device. It does _not_ go through /dev/sgX, unless you actually give /dev/sgX as the device name. It has nothing to do with ide-scsi. Period.
ATA uses CDROM_SEND_PACKET. This has nothing to do with direct IDE burning, it's a crippled interface from the CDROM layer that should not be used for anything. scsi-linux-ata.c should be ripped from the cdrecord sources, or at least cdrecord should _never_ select that transport for 2.6 kernels. For 2.4 you are far better off using ide-scsi.
Quoted 2 lines
The scan through ATA lasts much less than with ATAPI, and you can burn with dev=ATA:1,0,0 or dev=/dev/burner, which is the new recommended way.
No! ATAPI is the recommended way.
Signature · 1 line
Jens Axboe
Quoted 22 lines · Jens Axboe
Quoted 8 lines · J.A. Magallon
dev=ATAPI uses ide-scsi interface, through
/dev/sgX. And:Quoted 4 lines
scsibus: -1 target: -1 lun: -1
Warning: Using ATA Packet interface.
Warning: The related Linux kernel interface code seems to be unmaintained.
Warning: There is absolutely NO DMA, operations thus are slow.dev=ATA uses direct IDE burning. Try that as root. In my box, as root:
Oh no, not this again... Please check the facts: the ATAPI method uses the
SG_IOioctl, which is direct-to-device. It does _not_ go through/dev/sgX, unless you actually give/dev/sgXas the device name. It has nothing to do with ide-scsi. Period.ATA uses
CDROM_SEND_PACKET. This has nothing to do with direct IDE burning, it's a crippled interface from the CDROM layer that should not be used for anything.scsi-linux-ata.cshould be ripped from the cdrecord sources, or at least cdrecord should _never_ select that transport for 2.6 kernels. For 2.4 you are far better off using ide-scsi.
Quoted 15 lines
Quoted 2 lines
The scan through ATA lasts much less than with ATAPI, and you can burn with dev=ATA:1,0,0 or dev=/dev/burner, which is the new recommended way.
No! ATAPI is the recommended way.
Signature · 7 lines
Jens Axboe - To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to [email protected] More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/
--
J.A. Magallon <jamagallon()able!es> \ Software is like sex:
werewolf!able!es \ It's better when it's free
Mandrakelinux release 10.2 (Cooker) for i586
Linux 2.6.10-rc2-jam3 (gcc 3.4.1 (Mandrakelinux 10.1 3.4.1-4mdk)) #1
Quoted 22 lines · Jens Axboe
Quoted 8 lines · J.A. Magallon
dev=ATAPI uses ide-scsi interface, through
/dev/sgX. And:Quoted 4 lines
scsibus: -1 target: -1 lun: -1
Warning: Using ATA Packet interface.
Warning: The related Linux kernel interface code seems to be unmaintained.
Warning: There is absolutely NO DMA, operations thus are slow.dev=ATA uses direct IDE burning. Try that as root. In my box, as root:
Oh no, not this again... Please check the facts: the ATAPI method uses the
SG_IOioctl, which is direct-to-device. It does _not_ go through/dev/sgX, unless you actually give/dev/sgXas the device name. It has nothing to do with ide-scsi. Period.ATA uses
CDROM_SEND_PACKET. This has nothing to do with direct IDE burning, it's a crippled interface from the CDROM layer that should not be used for anything.scsi-linux-ata.cshould be ripped from the cdrecord sources, or at least cdrecord should _never_ select that transport for 2.6 kernels. For 2.4 you are far better off using ide-scsi.
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines
The scan through ATA lasts much less than with ATAPI, and you can burn with dev=ATA:1,0,0 or dev=/dev/burner, which is the new recommended way.
No! ATAPI is the recommended way.
Ahh, I think I found the problem....
I tried scanning with dev=ATAPI, and cdrecord did not found anything. Then I tried in my home box, and it found the burner.
The problem is that in the 'strange' box the burner is hdh, and the hard drive for system is hde. The previous IDE channels are unused (an on-board promise with ide[01], hd[abcd]).
I use udev, so there is no hd[a-d] nodes on /dev. And cdrecord _EXITS_ as soon as it founds a non-existent device !!!
With a quick'n'dirty hack (ln -s hde hd[abcdfg]), cdrecord finally got the list:
nada:~> cdrecord dev=ATAPI -scanbus
Cdrecord-Clone 2.01-dvd (i686-pc-linux-gnu) Copyright (C) 1995-2004 J�g Schilling
Note: This version is an unofficial (modified) version with DVD support
Note: and therefore may have bugs that are not present in the original.
Note: Please send bug reports or support requests to <[email protected]>.
Note: The author of cdrecord should not be bothered with problems in this version.
scsidev: 'ATAPI'
devname: 'ATAPI'
scsibus: -2 target: -2 lun: -2
Warning: Using ATA Packet interface.
Warning: The related Linux kernel interface code seems to be unmaintained.
Warning: There is absolutely NO DMA, operations thus are slow.
Using libscg version 'schily-0.8'.
scsibus0:
0,0,0 0) *
0,1,0 1) 'HL-DT-ST' 'DVDRAM GSA-4040B' 'A300' Removable CD-ROM
0,2,0 2) *
0,3,0 3) *
0,4,0 4) *
0,5,0 5) *
0,6,0 6) *
0,7,0 7) *I will try to look at the cdrecord sources and make a real patch... I suppose cdrecord will have a bugzilla or mailing list.
Many things will have to change with udev ;)
Thanks for your time and explanations.
--
J.A. Magallon <jamagallon()able!es> \ Software is like sex:
werewolf!able!es \ It's better when it's free
Mandrakelinux release 10.2 (Cooker) for i586
Linux 2.6.10-rc2-jam3 (gcc 3.4.1 (Mandrakelinux 10.1 3.4.1-4mdk)) #1
Quoted 5 lines
I tried scanning with dev=ATAPI, and cdrecord did not found anything. Then I tried in my home box, and it found the burner.
The problem is that in the 'strange' box the burner is hdh, and the hard drive for system is hde. The previous IDE channels are unused (an on-board promise with ide[01], hd[abcd]).
IMO that should not worry cdrecord where the burner is.
Quoted 2 lines
I use udev, so there is no hd[a-d] nodes on /dev. And cdrecord _EXITS_ as soon as it founds a non-existent device !!!
You can find something that does not exist?
Quoted 1 line
Many things will have to change with udev ;)
I have udev AND like /dev/hdh, even though I don't have an extra IDE controller. Yay to static entries.
Try mknod'ding hda and so forth (instead of symlinking) and then scanbus the thing. Does it show up?
Jan Engelhardt
Signature · 1 line
ENOSPC
Quoted 5 lines · Jan Engelhardt
Quoted 3 lines
I use udev, so there is no hd[a-d] nodes on /dev. And cdrecord _EXITS_ as soon as it founds a non-existent device !!!
You can find something that does not exist?
Err, as it tries to open a device and it does not exist. I tries sequentially
hda, hdb, hdc.. up to 256 until it finds something to open. If it exists, but has not permissions, it keeps trying on the next. But if it is not present, cdrecord gives up.
--
J.A. Magallon <jamagallon()able!es> \ Software is like sex:
werewolf!able!es \ It's better when it's free
Mandrakelinux release 10.2 (Cooker) for i586
Linux 2.6.10-rc2-jam3 (gcc 3.4.1 (Mandrakelinux 10.1 3.4.1-4mdk)) #1
Quoted 5 lines
Err, as it tries to open a device and it does not exist. I tries sequentially
hda, hdb, hdc.. up to 256 until it finds something to open. If it exists, but has not permissions, it keeps trying on the next. But if it is not present, cdrecord gives up.
Reasonable procedure. Albeit, leaky:
Imagine you use devfs... open()ing something like hd* would probably always create a node. Although there is a max on possible, meaningful, nodes, someone could use this to fill up /dev with
ridiculuous amounts of nodes, all of which are to my knowledge in kernel space. "Well then, goodbye".
Luckily, even the very default config does not create arbitrarily nodes, and cdrecord doesnot probe arbitr. devices.
So I guess, yes, cdrecord should probe harder. Preferably by looking into /sys when using a 2.6 system.
Jan Engelhardt
Signature · 1 line
ENOSPC
Quoted 13 lines · Jan Engelhardt
Quoted 5 lines
Err, as it tries to open a device and it does not exist. I tries sequentially
hda, hdb, hdc.. up to 256 until it finds something to open. If it exists, but has not permissions, it keeps trying on the next. But if it is not present, cdrecord gives up.Reasonable procedure. Albeit, leaky:
Imagine you use devfs... open()ing something like hd* would probably always create a node. Although there is a max on possible, meaningful, nodes, someone could use this to fill up /dev with
ridiculuous amounts of nodes, all of which are to my knowledge in kernel space. "Well then, goodbye".
Quoted 6 lines
Luckily, even the very default config does not create arbitrarily nodes, and cdrecord doesnot probe arbitr. devices.
So I guess, yes, cdrecord should probe harder. Preferably by looking into /sys when using a 2.6 system.
Patch for cdrecord:
libscg/scsi-linux-ata.c renamed from libscg/scsi-linux-ata.c.orig +0 -2
@@ -385,8 +385,6 @@ device, f, errno); }return (-2 ); - }else if (errno ==ENOENT || errno ==ENODEV ) { -break ; } }else {/* ugly hack, make better, when you can. Alex */
--
J.A. Magallon <jamagallon()able!es> \ Software is like sex:
werewolf!able!es \ It's better when it's free
Mandrakelinux release 10.2 (Cooker) for i586
Linux 2.6.10-rc2-jam3 (gcc 3.4.1 (Mandrakelinux 10.1 3.4.1-4mdk)) #1
Re: cdrecord dev=ATA cannont scanbus as non-root [u]
In reply to Jens AxboeQuoted 22 lines · Jens Axboe
Quoted 8 lines · J.A. Magallon
dev=ATAPI uses ide-scsi interface, through
/dev/sgX. And:Quoted 4 lines
scsibus: -1 target: -1 lun: -1
Warning: Using ATA Packet interface.
Warning: The related Linux kernel interface code seems to be unmaintained.
Warning: There is absolutely NO DMA, operations thus are slow.dev=ATA uses direct IDE burning. Try that as root. In my box, as root:
Oh no, not this again... Please check the facts: the ATAPI method uses the
SG_IOioctl, which is direct-to-device. It does _not_ go through/dev/sgX, unless you actually give/dev/sgXas the device name. It has nothing to do with ide-scsi. Period.ATA uses
CDROM_SEND_PACKET. This has nothing to do with direct IDE burning, it's a crippled interface from the CDROM layer that should not be used for anything.scsi-linux-ata.cshould be ripped from the cdrecord sources, or at least cdrecord should _never_ select that transport for 2.6 kernels. For 2.4 you are far better off using ide-scsi.
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines
The scan through ATA lasts much less than with ATAPI, and you can burn with dev=ATA:1,0,0 or dev=/dev/burner, which is the new recommended way.
No! ATAPI is the recommended way.
Ok, so I am a bit confused here. We basically have 3 ways to use cdrecord on linux-2.6 without ide-scsi:
1) cdrecord dev=/dev/hdx
2) cdrecord dev=ATA
3) cdrecord dev=ATAPI
Now, if I run all three and grep for '^Warning', I get:
-----
$ cdrecord dev=/dev/cdrw -scanbus 2>&1 | grep '^Warning' Warning: Open by 'devname' is unintentional and not supported. $ cdrecord dev=ATA -scanbus 2>&1 | grep '^Warning' Warning: Using badly designed ATAPI via /dev/hd* interface. $ cdrecord dev=ATAPI -scanbus 2>&1 | grep '^Warning' Warning: Using ATA Packet interface. Warning: The related Linux kernel interface code seems to be unmaintained. Warning: There is absolutely NO DMA, operations thus are slow. $ -----
Which means:
1) dev=/dev/hdx - Open by 'devname' is unintentional and not supported.
2) dev=ATA - Using badly designed ATAPI via /dev/hd* interface.
3) dev=ATAPI - Using ATA Packet interface.
(And some nice things about it not being maintained and
slow)
If I check the source for that, I get:
-----
libscg $ grep "Open by 'devname' is unintentional and not supported." *scsi-linux-sg.c: "Warning: Open by 'devname' is unintentional and not supported.\n");
libscg $ grep 'Using badly designed ATAPI via /dev/hd\* interface.' *scsi-linux-sg.c: "Warning: Using badly designed ATAPI via /dev/hd* interface.\n");
libscg $ grep 'Using ATA Packet interface.' *scsi-linux-ata.c: error("Warning: Using ATA Packet interface.\n");
libscg #
-----
Which hopefully (without really checking the source) means each are implemented in these source files:
1) dev=/dev/hdx - scsi-linux-sg.c
2) dev=ATA - scsi-linux-sg.c
3) dev=ATAPI - scsi-linux-ata.c
So if I take note of you comment above about scsi-linux-ata.c (or actually give a fart about Jorg's warning about unmaintained and slow), should ATA rather than ATAPI not be the recommended way??
Also, how about having the kernel print a warning when the depreciated interface (ATAPI??) is used ?
Thanks,
Signature · 1 line
Martin Schlemmer
Re: cdrecord dev=ATA cannont scanbus as non-root [u]
Quoted 50 lines · Martin Schlemmer [c]
Quoted 22 lines · Jens Axboe
Quoted 8 lines · J.A. Magallon
dev=ATAPI uses ide-scsi interface, through
/dev/sgX. And:Quoted 5 lines
scsibus: -1 target: -1 lun: -1
Warning: Using ATA Packet interface.
Warning: The related Linux kernel interface code seems to be unmaintained. Warning: There is absolutely NO DMA, operations thus are slow.dev=ATA uses direct IDE burning. Try that as root. In my box, as root:
Oh no, not this again... Please check the facts: the ATAPI method uses the
SG_IOioctl, which is direct-to-device. It does _not_ go through/dev/sgX, unless you actually give/dev/sgXas the device name. It has nothing to do with ide-scsi. Period.ATA uses
CDROM_SEND_PACKET. This has nothing to do with direct IDE burning, it's a crippled interface from the CDROM layer that should not be used for anything.scsi-linux-ata.cshould be ripped from the cdrecord sources, or at least cdrecord should _never_ select that transport for 2.6 kernels. For 2.4 you are far better off using ide-scsi.Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines
The scan through ATA lasts much less than with ATAPI, and you can burn with dev=ATA:1,0,0 or dev=/dev/burner, which is the new recommended way.
No! ATAPI is the recommended way.
Ok, so I am a bit confused here. We basically have 3 ways to use cdrecord on linux-2.6 without ide-scsi:
1) cdrecord dev=/dev/hdx
2) cdrecord dev=ATA
3) cdrecord dev=ATAPINow, if I run all three and grep for '^Warning', I get:
-----
$ cdrecord dev=/dev/cdrw -scanbus 2>&1 | grep '^Warning' Warning: Open by 'devname' is unintentional and not supported. $ cdrecord dev=ATA -scanbus 2>&1 | grep '^Warning' Warning: Using badly designed ATAPI via /dev/hd* interface. $ cdrecord dev=ATAPI -scanbus 2>&1 | grep '^Warning' Warning: Using ATA Packet interface. Warning: The related Linux kernel interface code seems to be unmaintained. Warning: There is absolutely NO DMA, operations thus are slow. $ -----
Quoted 8 lines
Which means:
1) dev=/dev/hdx - Open by 'devname' is unintentional and not supported.
2) dev=ATA - Using badly designed ATAPI via/dev/hd*interface.
3) dev=ATAPI - Using ATA Packet interface.
(And some nice things about it not being maintained and
slow)
Well, dev=ATA:nr,nr,nr will not produce any warning and works correctly with full performance.
dev=ATAPI:* gives bad performance and as stated above, shouldn't be used. dev=/dev/hdx is just the same as dev=ATA:/dev/hdx, you can of course replace it with correct numbers if you know them or an alias
in /etc/defaults/cdrecord.dfl (The path's from Gentoo, may be different elsewhere.)
Re: cdrecord dev=ATA cannont scanbus as non-root [u]
Quoted 60 lines · Radoslaw Szkodzinski
Quoted 50 lines · Martin Schlemmer [c]
Quoted 22 lines · Jens Axboe
Quoted 8 lines · J.A. Magallon
dev=ATAPI uses ide-scsi interface, through
/dev/sgX. And:Quoted 5 lines
scsibus: -1 target: -1 lun: -1
Warning: Using ATA Packet interface.
Warning: The related Linux kernel interface code seems to be unmaintained. Warning: There is absolutely NO DMA, operations thus are slow.dev=ATA uses direct IDE burning. Try that as root. In my box, as root:
Oh no, not this again... Please check the facts: the ATAPI method uses the
SG_IOioctl, which is direct-to-device. It does _not_ go through/dev/sgX, unless you actually give/dev/sgXas the device name. It has nothing to do with ide-scsi. Period.ATA uses
CDROM_SEND_PACKET. This has nothing to do with direct IDE burning, it's a crippled interface from the CDROM layer that should not be used for anything.scsi-linux-ata.cshould be ripped from the cdrecord sources, or at least cdrecord should _never_ select that transport for 2.6 kernels. For 2.4 you are far better off using ide-scsi.Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines
The scan through ATA lasts much less than with ATAPI, and you can burn with dev=ATA:1,0,0 or dev=/dev/burner, which is the new recommended way.
No! ATAPI is the recommended way.
Ok, so I am a bit confused here. We basically have 3 ways to use cdrecord on linux-2.6 without ide-scsi:
1) cdrecord dev=/dev/hdx
2) cdrecord dev=ATA
3) cdrecord dev=ATAPINow, if I run all three and grep for '^Warning', I get:
-----
$ cdrecord dev=/dev/cdrw -scanbus 2>&1 | grep '^Warning' Warning: Open by 'devname' is unintentional and not supported. $ cdrecord dev=ATA -scanbus 2>&1 | grep '^Warning' Warning: Using badly designed ATAPI via /dev/hd* interface. $ cdrecord dev=ATAPI -scanbus 2>&1 | grep '^Warning' Warning: Using ATA Packet interface. Warning: The related Linux kernel interface code seems to be unmaintained. Warning: There is absolutely NO DMA, operations thus are slow. $ -----Quoted 8 lines
Which means:
1) dev=/dev/hdx - Open by 'devname' is unintentional and not supported.
2) dev=ATA - Using badly designed ATAPI via/dev/hd*interface.
3) dev=ATAPI - Using ATA Packet interface.
(And some nice things about it not being maintained and
slow)
Quoted 7 lines
Well, dev=ATA:nr,nr,nr will not produce any warning and works correctly with full performance.
dev=ATAPI:* gives bad performance and as stated above, shouldn't be used. dev=/dev/hdx is just the same as dev=ATA:/dev/hdx, you can of course replace it with correct numbers if you know them or an alias
in/etc/defaults/cdrecord.dfl(The path's from Gentoo, may be different elsewhere.)
Yes, I know .. its just that I have been under the impression (and also what experience shows) that 'dev=/dev/hdx' and 'dev=ATA' is the same thing, with 'dev=ATAPI' the depreciated one, but Jens stated differently above ...
Signature · 1 line
Martin Schlemmer
Re: cdrecord dev=ATA cannont scanbus as non-root [u]
In reply to Radoslaw SzkodzinskiQuoted 8 lines
Ok, so I am a bit confused here. We basically have 3 ways to use
Quoted 7 lines
cdrecord on linux-2.6 without ide-scsi:
1) cdrecord dev=/dev/hdx
2) cdrecord dev=ATA
3) cdrecord dev=ATAPINow, if I run all three and grep for '^Warning', I get:
Worse, yet, there is no DMA for any of these three :-(
Jan Engelhardt
Signature · 1 line
ENOSPC
Re: cdrecord dev=ATA cannont scanbus as non-root [u]
Quoted 10 lines · Jan Engelhardt
Quoted 8 lines
Ok, so I am a bit confused here. We basically have 3 ways to use
Quoted 7 lines
cdrecord on linux-2.6 without ide-scsi:
1) cdrecord dev=/dev/hdx
2) cdrecord dev=ATA
3) cdrecord dev=ATAPINow, if I run all three and grep for '^Warning', I get:
Worse, yet, there is no DMA for any of these three :-(
Not true in 2.6. 1 definitely uses DMA now (disregard the damn warning). And why would anyone use 2 or 3?
-Rahul
Re: cdrecord dev=ATA cannont scanbus as non-root [u]
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 7 lines
Ok, so I am a bit confused here. We basically have 3 ways to use
Quoted 6 lines
cdrecord on linux-2.6 without ide-scsi:
1) cdrecord dev=/dev/hdx
2) cdrecord dev=ATA
3) cdrecord dev=ATAPI
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Now, if I run all three and grep for '^Warning', I get:
Worse, yet, there is no DMA for any of these three :-(
Not true in 2.6. 1 definitely uses DMA now (disregard the damn warning). And why would anyone use 2 or 3?
Right, forgot to add. Read as "no DMA for any that does not give a cdrecord warning".
Jan Engelhardt
Signature · 1 line
ENOSPC
Re: cdrecord dev=ATA cannont scanbus as non-root [u]
Quoted 9 lines · Jan Engelhardt
Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 8 lines
Ok, so I am a bit confused here. We basically have 3 ways to use
Quoted 7 lines
cdrecord on linux-2.6 without ide-scsi:
1) cdrecord dev=/dev/hdx
2) cdrecord dev=ATA
3) cdrecord dev=ATAPINow, if I run all three and grep for '^Warning', I get:
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 1 line
Worse, yet, there is no DMA for any of these three :-(
Not true in 2.6. 1 definitely uses DMA now (disregard the damn warning). And why would anyone use 2 or 3?
Right, forgot to add. Read as "no DMA for any that does not give a cdrecord warning".
They all use DMA, whenever possible.
Signature · 1 line
Jens Axboe
Quoted 15 lines · Jens Axboe
Quoted 8 lines · J.A. Magallon
dev=ATAPI uses ide-scsi interface, through
/dev/sgX. And:Quoted 4 lines
scsibus: -1 target: -1 lun: -1
Warning: Using ATA Packet interface.
Warning: The related Linux kernel interface code seems to be unmaintained.
Warning: There is absolutely NO DMA, operations thus are slow.dev=ATA uses direct IDE burning. Try that as root. In my box, as root:
Oh no, not this again... Please check the facts: the ATAPI method uses the
SG_IOioctl, which is direct-to-device. It does _not_ go through/dev/sgX, unless you actually give/dev/sgXas the device name. It has nothing to do with ide-scsi. Period.
Quoted 6 lines
ATA uses
CDROM_SEND_PACKET. This has nothing to do with direct IDE burning, it's a crippled interface from the CDROM layer that should not be used for anything.scsi-linux-ata.cshould be ripped from the cdrecord sources, or at least cdrecord should _never_ select that transport for 2.6 kernels. For 2.4 you are far better off using ide-scsi.
Are you sure you don't mix ATA with ATAPI? I think ATA is equivalent to dev=/dev/hdX.
regards
Markus
Quoted 24 lines · Markus Plail
Quoted 15 lines · Jens Axboe
Quoted 8 lines · J.A. Magallon
dev=ATAPI uses ide-scsi interface, through
/dev/sgX. And:Quoted 4 lines
scsibus: -1 target: -1 lun: -1
Warning: Using ATA Packet interface.
Warning: The related Linux kernel interface code seems to be unmaintained.
Warning: There is absolutely NO DMA, operations thus are slow.dev=ATA uses direct IDE burning. Try that as root. In my box, as root:
Oh no, not this again... Please check the facts: the ATAPI method uses the
SG_IOioctl, which is direct-to-device. It does _not_ go through/dev/sgX, unless you actually give/dev/sgXas the device name. It has nothing to do with ide-scsi. Period.Quoted 6 lines
ATA uses
CDROM_SEND_PACKET. This has nothing to do with direct IDE burning, it's a crippled interface from the CDROM layer that should not be used for anything.scsi-linux-ata.cshould be ripped from the cdrecord sources, or at least cdrecord should _never_ select that transport for 2.6 kernels. For 2.4 you are far better off using ide-scsi.
Quoted 2 lines
Are you sure you don't mix ATA with ATAPI? I think ATA is equivalent to dev=/dev/hdX.
I did mix them up, my apologies til Magallon. As always you should just use -dev=/dev/hdX and it will work the best, there's no need to give ATA or ATAPI. They are too easy to mix up as the names don't really give you any hints on what access method they will utilize. Using -dev also means there's no reason to run -scanbus at all, since you know where the device is. If you don't, then you probably should be using k3b or some other helper to work out things for you.
Signature · 1 line
Jens Axboe
Quoted 28 lines · Jens Axboe
Quoted 24 lines · Markus Plail
Quoted 15 lines · Jens Axboe
Quoted 8 lines · J.A. Magallon
dev=ATAPI uses ide-scsi interface, through
/dev/sgX. And:Quoted 4 lines
scsibus: -1 target: -1 lun: -1
Warning: Using ATA Packet interface.
Warning: The related Linux kernel interface code seems to be unmaintained.
Warning: There is absolutely NO DMA, operations thus are slow.dev=ATA uses direct IDE burning. Try that as root. In my box, as root:
Oh no, not this again... Please check the facts: the ATAPI method uses the
SG_IOioctl, which is direct-to-device. It does _not_ go through/dev/sgX, unless you actually give/dev/sgXas the device name. It has nothing to do with ide-scsi. Period.Quoted 6 lines
ATA uses
CDROM_SEND_PACKET. This has nothing to do with direct IDE burning, it's a crippled interface from the CDROM layer that should not be used for anything.scsi-linux-ata.cshould be ripped from the cdrecord sources, or at least cdrecord should _never_ select that transport for 2.6 kernels. For 2.4 you are far better off using ide-scsi.Quoted 2 lines
Are you sure you don't mix ATA with ATAPI? I think ATA is equivalent to dev=/dev/hdX.
Quoted 8 lines
I did mix them up, my apologies til Magallon. As always you should just use -dev=/dev/hdX and it will work the best, there's no need to give ATA or ATAPI. They are too easy to mix up as the names don't really give you any hints on what access method they will utilize. Using -dev also means there's no reason to run -scanbus at all, since you know where the device is. If you don't, then you probably should be using k3b or some other helper to work out things for you.
Ahh, I'm going to kick my head on the table... Well, lets begin again. So:
- for 2.4, use ide-scsi
- for 2.6, use ATA
So cdrecord should stop to scan the ATAPI pseudo bus.
My problem is just that I want to set an easy way to burn for users. In other systems you just hav an app onto you throw your mp3 and get an audio disc, or d'n'd your files and get a cd.
And I don want to tell people to rune mkisofs with a ton of options (jolliet, rr, long names, etc...). So they must use a GUI tool. The best I like nowadays is gnomebaker.
The thing is that all frontends use cdrecord. In many you can't specify the device by hand, they just give you a menu based on cdrecord -scan output. They should tell cdrecord to scan SCSI and ATA buses, but not ATAPI.
And now, as root:
werewolf:~# cdrecord dev=ATA -scanbus
...
scsibus1:
1,0,0 100) 'HL-DT-ST' 'DVDRAM GSA-4120B' 'A102' Removable CD-ROMwerewolf:/store/tmp# cdrecord -dev=ATA:1,0,0 -dao -dummy *.iso Driver flags : MMC-3 SWABAUDIO BURNFREE Supported modes: TAO PACKET SAO SAO/R96P SAO/R96R RAW/R16 RAW/R96P RAW/R96R Speed set to 7056 KB/s Starting to write CD/DVD at speed 40.0 in dummy SAO mode for single session. ...
And as user:
werewolf:~> cdrecord dev=ATA -scanbus
...
cdrecord: Permission denied. Cannot open '/dev/hda'. Cannot open SCSI driver.
cdrecord: For possible targets try 'cdrecord -scanbus'. Make sure you are root.
cdrecord: For possible transport specifiers try 'cdrecord dev=help'.
werewolf:/store/tmp> cdrecord -dev=ATA:1,0,0 -dummy -dao *.iso
...
cdrecord: Permission denied. Cannot open '/dev/hda'. Cannot open SCSI driver.
cdrecord: For possible targets try 'cdrecord -scanbus'. Make sure you are root.
cdrecord: For possible transport specifiers try 'cdrecord dev=help'.
But:
werewolf:/store/tmp> cdrecord -dev=/dev/hdc -dummy -dao *.iso
...
cdrecord: Cannot allocate memory. WARNING: Cannot do mlockall(2).
cdrecord: WARNING: This causes a high risk for buffer underruns.
cdrecord: Operation not permitted. WARNING: Cannot set RR-scheduler
cdrecord: Permission denied. WARNING: Cannot set priority using setpriority().
cdrecord: WARNING: This causes a high risk for buffer underruns.
scsidev: '/dev/hdc'
devname: '/dev/hdc'
scsibus: -2 target: -2 lun: -2
Warning: Open by 'devname' is unintentional and not supported. Linux sg driver version: 3.5.27
WARNING ! Cannot gain SYS_RAWIO capability !
: Operation not permitted
...
Driver flags : MMC-3 SWABAUDIO BURNFREE
Supported modes: < EMPTY AGAIN !!!!!
cdrecord: Drive does not support SAO recording.
cdrecord: Illegal write mode for this drive.
werewolf:/store/tmp> ll /dev/hdc
brw-rw-rw- 1 magallon cdwriter 22, 0 2004.12.01 23:27 /dev/hdc
(pam did it for the console ;))
There are some bugs here:
- One in cdrecord, that exits as soon as it can't open a device, instead of trying till it gets the cdwriter.
- Other in cdrecord, the system does not behave the same way if I give /dev/hdc or ATA:1,0,0.
- Other in the kernel, that does not allow to query capabilities of the drive to a normal user.
I can hackpatch cdrecord, but have no idea of what to do with the kernel. I remember there were some mails time ago about adding allowed commands to cdrom/cdwiters, but can't find them.
Perhaps, someday, somwhere, I could burn a disc in Linux as plain user.
Thanks for bearing me...
--
J.A. Magallon <jamagallon()able!es> \ Software is like sex:
werewolf!able!es \ It's better when it's free
Mandrakelinux release 10.2 (Cooker) for i586
Linux 2.6.10-rc2-jam4 (gcc 3.4.1 (Mandrakelinux 10.1 3.4.1-4mdk)) #2