Skip to contentSkip to conversation

The bugzilla story

DISCUSSION Alexander Nyberg 6 participants 7 messages Dec 6, 2004 – Dec 8, 2004

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi

As some of you may have noticed I've been doing a run on bugzilla for the last few days to close old bugs and upgrade those who still are real bugs.

I have a few things that I would like to enforce on bugzilla to makes it more maintanable which it clearly hasn't been for a while - there are lots and lots of bugs open older than 2.6.0-final.

I think the alternative trees section should be dropped. This is especially a matter for -mm which has most reports of the alternative trees in bugzilla. -mm changes way too rapidly to keep track of at bugzilla ending up with open bugs that are fixed long ago.

I also think this goes for any alternative tree, that problems should be reported directly to the maintainer/LKML of the tree. Only if a problem can be reproduced with the mainline kernel should the bug be reported at bugzilla.

New bugzilla reports against other trees than mainline should be rejected and ask the submitter to report directly to the maintainer/LKML.

Andrew, what do you think about bug reports against -mm on bugzilla?

Does anyone see a problem with this?

Thanks
Alexander

#1 lore raw
Quoted 9 lines · Alexander Nyberg

I think the alternative trees section should be dropped. This is especially a matter for -mm which has most reports of the alternative trees in bugzilla. -mm changes way too rapidly to keep track of at bugzilla ending up with open bugs that are fixed long ago.

I also think this goes for any alternative tree, that problems should be reported directly to the maintainer/LKML of the tree. Only if a problem can be reproduced with the mainline kernel should the bug be reported at bugzilla.

Hi Alexander,
Yes i agree, -mm has so many bugs fixed and introduced inbetween
it's short releases that it does often lead to extremely short lived bug reports. Thanks for wading through them all.

Zwane

#2 lore raw
In reply to Alexander Nyberg
Quoted 18 lines

As some of you may have noticed I've been doing a run on bugzilla for the last few days to close old bugs and upgrade those who still are real bugs.

I have a few things that I would like to enforce on bugzilla to makes it more maintanable which it clearly hasn't been for a while - there are lots and lots of bugs open older than 2.6.0-final.

I think the alternative trees section should be dropped. This is especially a matter for -mm which has most reports of the alternative trees in bugzilla. -mm changes way too rapidly to keep track of at bugzilla ending up with open bugs that are fixed long ago.

I also think this goes for any alternative tree, that problems should be reported directly to the maintainer/LKML of the tree. Only if a problem can be reproduced with the mainline kernel should the bug be reported at bugzilla.

Quoted 7 lines

New bugzilla reports against other trees than mainline should be rejected and ask the submitter to report directly to the maintainer/LKML.

Andrew, what do you think about bug reports against -mm on bugzilla?

Does anyone see a problem with this?

The subtrees section was created for exactly that reason - to isolate the bugs in alternate trees, and keep the out of everyone else's hair. Now if one was to argue that bugs in -mm should be cleaned up much more agressively, that'd make a lot of sense ... but that should be fairly easy to do as they're in a separate category you can search by.

The main issue is that there haven't been many people doing what you're doing now ... going through and housekeeping the bugs.

M.

#3 lore raw
Quoted 26 lines · Martin J. Bligh
Quoted 18 lines

As some of you may have noticed I've been doing a run on bugzilla for the last few days to close old bugs and upgrade those who still are real bugs.

I have a few things that I would like to enforce on bugzilla to makes it more maintanable which it clearly hasn't been for a while - there are lots and lots of bugs open older than 2.6.0-final.

I think the alternative trees section should be dropped. This is especially a matter for -mm which has most reports of the alternative trees in bugzilla. -mm changes way too rapidly to keep track of at bugzilla ending up with open bugs that are fixed long ago.

I also think this goes for any alternative tree, that problems should be reported directly to the maintainer/LKML of the tree. Only if a problem can be reproduced with the mainline kernel should the bug be reported at bugzilla.

Quoted 7 lines

New bugzilla reports against other trees than mainline should be rejected and ask the submitter to report directly to the maintainer/LKML.

Andrew, what do you think about bug reports against -mm on bugzilla?

Does anyone see a problem with this?

Quoted 8 lines

The subtrees section was created for exactly that reason - to isolate the bugs in alternate trees, and keep the out of everyone else's hair. Now if one was to argue that bugs in -mm should be cleaned up much more agressively, that'd make a lot of sense ... but that should be fairly easy to do as they're in a separate category you can search by.

The main issue is that there haven't been many people doing what you're doing now ... going through and housekeeping the bugs.

The thing is that -mm changes so fast that a bug reported can be solved an hour later, leaving a stale bug report for a few days (or years). Whoever wants to pick up the bug quite much has to mail either the bug-submitter asking if the bug has been resolved, mail the maintainer of whatever area the bug concerns or mail akpm.

This leads me to thinking that bugzilla doesn't serve any functionality for at least -mm.

Alexander

#4 lore raw
Quoted 8 lines · Alexander Nyberg

The thing is that -mm changes so fast that a bug reported can be solved an hour later, leaving a stale bug report for a few days (or years). Whoever wants to pick up the bug quite much has to mail either the bug-submitter asking if the bug has been resolved, mail the maintainer of whatever area the bug concerns or mail akpm.

This leads me to thinking that bugzilla doesn't serve any functionality for at least -mm.

Sometimes they do - for looking back and finding when a problem came in, or for spotting common patterns. They are less useful but not of no use

#5 lore raw
Quoted 6 lines · Alan Cox
Quoted 5 lines · Alexander Nyberg

The thing is that -mm changes so fast that a bug reported can be solved an hour later, leaving a stale bug report for a few days (or years). Whoever wants to pick up the bug quite much has to mail either the bug-submitter asking if the bug has been resolved, mail the maintainer of whatever area the bug concerns or mail akpm.

I have stopped reporting the -mm issues using bugizlla exactly for this reason. Apparently, the reports get more attention when they are sent to LKML. ;-)

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines

This leads me to thinking that bugzilla doesn't serve any functionality for at least -mm.

Sometimes they do - for looking back and finding when a problem came in, or for spotting common patterns. They are less useful but not of no use

Yes, but many things are not reported there anyway. IMVHO the bugzilla is an overkill for -mm bug reporting. The -mm kernels are released too often, they change too much, and the issues are often too simple to be reported this way.

Greets,
RJW

Signature · 3 lines
- Would you tell me, please, which way I ought to go from here?
- That depends a good deal on where you want to get to.
		-- Lewis Carroll "Alice's Adventures in Wonderland"
#6 lore raw
In reply to Alexander Nyberg
Quoted 9 lines · Alexander Nyberg

Hi

As some of you may have noticed I've been doing a run on bugzilla for the last few days to close old bugs and upgrade those who still are real bugs.

I have a few things that I would like to enforce on bugzilla to makes it more maintanable which it clearly hasn't been for a while - there are lots and lots of bugs open older than 2.6.0-final.

Thanks for running through these...

Jeff