User mode drivers: part 2: PCI device handling (patch 1/2 for 2.6.11)
Quoted 6 lines · Peter Chubb
There are three new system calls:
long
usr_pci_open(int bus, int slot, int function, __u64 dma_mask);
Returns a filedescriptor for the PCI device described by bus,slot,function. It also enables the device, and sets it up as a bus-mastering DMA device, with the specified dma mask.
You forgot the PCI domain (a.k.a. hose, phb...) number. Also, you might encode bus,slot,function according to the PCI spec. So that gives:
long usr_pci_open(unsigned pcidomain, unsigned devspec, __u64 dmamask);
(with the user library returning an int instead of long)
Quoted 6 lines
You forgot the PCI domain (a.k.a. hose, phb...) number. Also, you might encode bus,slot,function according to the PCI spec. So that gives:
long
usr_pci_open(unsigned pcidomain, unsigned devspec, __u64 dmamask);
Still insufficient because the device might be hotplugged on you. You need a file handle that has the expected revocation effects on unplug and refcounts
Alan
Quoted 9 lines · Alan Cox
Quoted 5 lines
You forgot the PCI domain (a.k.a. hose, phb...) number. Also, you might encode bus,slot,function according to the PCI spec. So that gives:
long
usr_pci_open(unsigned pcidomain, unsigned devspec, __u64 dmamask);Still insufficient because the device might be hotplugged on you. You need a file handle that has the expected revocation effects on unplug and refcounts
I was under the impression that a file handle would be returned.
I'm not so sure that is a sane way to handle hot-plug though. First of all, in general, it's going to be like this:
Fan, meet shit.
Shit, meet fan.
Those who care might best be served by SIGBUS with si_code and si_info set appropriately. Perhaps a revoke() syscall that handled mmap() would work the same way.
Quoted 5 lines · Albert Cahalan
Quoted 3 lines
Still insufficient because the device might be hotplugged on you. You need a file handle that has the expected revocation effects on unplug and refcounts
I was under the impression that a file handle would be returned.
Then lets use that popular "open" system call