Skip to contentSkip to conversation

XFS corruption on move from xscale to i686

DISCUSSION Yura Pakhuchiy 4 participants 9 messages Jul 7, 2005 – Jul 14, 2005 VFS

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi,

I'm creadted XFS volume on 2.6.10 linux xscale/iq31244 box, then I copyied files on it and moved this hard drive to i686 machine. When I mounted it on i686, I found no files on it. I runned xfs_check, here is output:

pc299:/home/yura# xfs_check /dev/sda5
dir 128 size is 31, should be 13
dir 128 offsets too high
root directory 128 has .. 0
dir 131 entry  bad inode number 4030121216
dir 131 entry                                      SRPMS.base bad offset 0
dir 131 bad size in entry at 68
link count mismatch for inode 0 (name ?), nlink 0, counted 3
link count mismatch for inode 6303282 (name ?), nlink 0, counted 1
link count mismatch for inode 128 (name ?), nlink 3, counted 1
link count mismatch for inode 131 (name ?), nlink 5, counted 4
link count mismatch for inode 33554560 (name ?), nlink 2, counted 1
link count mismatch for inode 67108992 (name ?), nlink 2, counted 1
link count mismatch for inode 100663424 (name ?), nlink 2, counted 1
Signature · 2 lines
Best regards,
        Yura
#1 lore raw
Quoted 6 lines · Yura Pakhuchiy

Hi,

I'm creadted XFS volume on 2.6.10 linux xscale/iq31244 box, then I copyied files on it and moved this hard drive to i686 machine. When I mounted it on i686, I found no files on it. I runned xfs_check, here is output:

Someone else was doing this awhile back, and also had issues. Their trouble seemed to be related to xscale gcc miscompiling parts of XFS - search the linux-xfs archives for details.

cheers.

Signature · 1 line
Nathan
#2 lore raw

2005/7/8, Nathan Scott <[email protected]>:

Quoted 11 lines · Yura Pakhuchiy
Quoted 6 lines

Hi,

I'm creadted XFS volume on 2.6.10 linux xscale/iq31244 box, then I copyied files on it and moved this hard drive to i686 machine. When I mounted it on i686, I found no files on it. I runned xfs_check, here is output:

Someone else was doing this awhile back, and also had issues. Their trouble seemed to be related to xscale gcc miscompiling parts of XFS - search the linux-xfs archives for details.

I found patch by Greg Ungreger to fix this problem, but why it's still not in mainline? Or it's a gcc problem and should be fixed by gcc folks? BTW, my kernel on xscale is compiled using gcc 3.4.3.

Thanks,
Yura

#3 lore raw
Quoted 2 lines · Yura Pakhuchiy

I found patch by Greg Ungreger to fix this problem, but why it's still not in mainline? Or it's a gcc problem and should be fixed by gcc folks?

Yes, IIRC the patch was incorrect for other platforms, and it sure looked like an arm-specific gcc problem (this was ages back, so perhaps its fixed by now).

cheers.

Signature · 1 line
Nathan
#4 lore raw

2005/7/14, Nathan Scott <[email protected]>:

Quoted 7 lines · Yura Pakhuchiy
Quoted 2 lines

I found patch by Greg Ungreger to fix this problem, but why it's still not in mainline? Or it's a gcc problem and should be fixed by gcc folks?

Yes, IIRC the patch was incorrect for other platforms, and it sure looked like an arm-specific gcc problem (this was ages back, so perhaps its fixed by now).

AFAIR gcc-3.4.3 was released after this conversation take place at linux-xfs, maybe add something like this:

#ifdef XSCALE
/* We need this because some gcc versions for xscale are broken. */ [patched version here]
#else
[original version here]
#endif

Best regards,
Yura

#5 lore raw
Quoted 12 lines · Yura Pakhuchiy

2005/7/14, Nathan Scott <[email protected]>:

Quoted 7 lines · Yura Pakhuchiy
Quoted 2 lines

I found patch by Greg Ungreger to fix this problem, but why it's still not in mainline? Or it's a gcc problem and should be fixed by gcc folks?

Yes, IIRC the patch was incorrect for other platforms, and it sure looked like an arm-specific gcc problem (this was ages back, so perhaps its fixed by now).

AFAIR gcc-3.4.3 was released after this conversation take place at linux-xfs, maybe add something like this:

Quoted 6 lines

#ifdef XSCALE
/* We need this because some gcc versions for xscale are broken. */ [patched version here]
#else
[original version here]
#endif

no, just fix your compiler or let the gcc folks do it. Did anyone of the arm folks ever open a PR at the gcc bugzilla with a reproduced testcase? You're never get your compiler fixed with that attitude.

#6 lore raw

2005/7/14, Christoph Hellwig <[email protected]>:

Quoted 20 lines · Yura Pakhuchiy
Quoted 12 lines

2005/7/14, Nathan Scott <[email protected]>:

Quoted 7 lines · Yura Pakhuchiy
Quoted 2 lines

I found patch by Greg Ungreger to fix this problem, but why it's still not in mainline? Or it's a gcc problem and should be fixed by gcc folks?

Yes, IIRC the patch was incorrect for other platforms, and it sure looked like an arm-specific gcc problem (this was ages back, so perhaps its fixed by now).

AFAIR gcc-3.4.3 was released after this conversation take place at linux-xfs, maybe add something like this:

Quoted 6 lines

#ifdef XSCALE
/* We need this because some gcc versions for xscale are broken. */ [patched version here]
#else
[original version here]
#endif

Quoted 3 lines

no, just fix your compiler or let the gcc folks do it. Did anyone of the arm folks ever open a PR at the gcc bugzilla with a reproduced testcase? You're never get your compiler fixed with that attitude.

Yes, but a lof of people use older versions of compilers and suffer from this bug.
I personally was very unhappy when lost my data.

Best regards,
Yura

#7 lore raw
Quoted 3 lines · Yura Pakhuchiy

Yes, but a lof of people use older versions of compilers and suffer from this bug.
I personally was very unhappy when lost my data.

then host the patch somewhere and make sure to apply it.

#8 lore raw
In reply to Nathan Scott

2005/7/14, Nathan Scott <[email protected]>:

Quoted 7 lines · Yura Pakhuchiy
Quoted 2 lines

I found patch by Greg Ungreger to fix this problem, but why it's still not in mainline? Or it's a gcc problem and should be fixed by gcc folks?

Yes, IIRC the patch was incorrect for other platforms, and it sure looked like an arm-specific gcc problem (this was ages back, so perhaps its fixed by now).

AFAIR gcc-3.4.3 was released after this conversation take place at linux-xfs, maybe add something like this:

#ifdef XSCALE
/* We need this because some gcc versions for xscale are broken. */ [patched version here]
#else
[original version here]
#endif

Best regards,
Yura