sata_sil 3112 activity LED patch
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
Hello,
I have tested the patch against my DawiControl DC-150 RAID controller which is basically an add-on card with a SiI 3112 ASIC and a flash ROM. The activity LED of my case is directly connected to the add-on card.
Unfortunately your patch doesn't have any effect on the LED. The activity LED gets turned on by the card's BIOS at boot time and continues to shine until I shut down the computer.
On the other hand it did not erase my Flash ROM and I haven't spotted any data loss so far.
The LED does work as expected under that other OS as soon as Silicon Image's reference driver is loaded, hence it is connected correctly.
Test setup:
I'm using DawiControl's version of the BIOS and not the reference BIOS of Silicon Image. The test system is a Tualatin Celeron 1400 with an i440BX based mainboard. The following hard disk is connected to the
controller: Seagate ST3160827AS (native SATA interface). The sata_sil driver is loaded as a module.
Test kernel is vanilla 2.6.12.2. No tainted modules were used while doing these tests.
If you require more information, don't hesitate to contact me.
Regards
Christian Kroll
- --
Christian Kroll <christian dot kroll at bglug dot org> GnuPG Fingerprint: DA5D 5BFA 5C95 FD09 2A72 517E 10CB DCD5 71ED 7E35
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.1 (GNU/Linux)
iD8DBQFC1xsQEMvc1XHtfjURAqKQAJ0fp5EtdymeUsiklcqYsCR9Q7VyngCeIfKV Sb/wTjlvfk6MPMk/KEBkBPY=
=g7Vc
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Quoted 9 lines · Christian Kroll
I have tested the patch against my DawiControl DC-150 RAID controller which is basically an add-on card with a SiI 3112 ASIC and a flash ROM. The activity LED of my case is directly connected to the add-on card.
Unfortunately your patch doesn't have any effect on the LED. The activity LED gets turned on by the card's BIOS at boot time and continues to shine until I shut down the computer.
On the other hand it did not erase my Flash ROM and I haven't spotted any data loss so far.
No data loss is a good thing! That was my biggest worry, as I have no documentation for the addon card case. Out of curiosity, did the LED usage change at all before and after the patch, or was it totally unaffected. I would guess the latter.
Unfortunately, what documentation I do have shows (briefly) that add on cards implement their LED via a different mechanism. If I knew the addresses for the flash read and write strobes (FL_RDN and FL_WRN), I might be able to work something out. So as it stands, there is not much hope for the people with addon cards.
Quoted 1 line
If you require more information, don't hesitate to contact me.
Thanks, I will. I have emailed Silicon Image in the (slim) chance that they will provide me with the information I require. If they come through then I might be able to whip something up and have you test it.
If anyone has any data on the 3112a (or 3512 as I believe they are register compatible) and isn't bound by an NDA, I'd like to hear from you.
Signature · 2 lines
Aric Cyr <acyr at alumni dot uwaterloo dot ca> (http://acyr.net) gpg fingerprint: 943A 1549 47AC D766 B7F8 D551 6703 7142 C282 D542
Quoted 3 lines · Aric Cyr
Out of curiosity, did the LED
usage change at all before and after the patch, or was it totally unaffected. I would guess the latter.
It was totally unaffected. If the LED is turned on by the BIOS (while it examines the bus at boot time), it remains on as long as Linux is running. If it isn't turned on by the BIOS (Silicon Image's reference BIOS), it doesn't light up under Linux as well.
Quoted 4 lines
Thanks, I will. I have emailed Silicon Image in the (slim) chance that they will provide me with the information I require. If they come through then I might be able to whip something up and have you test it.
Thanks for looking into this!
Signature · 2 lines
Christian Kroll <[email protected]> GnuPG Fingerprint: DA5D 5BFA 5C95 FD09 2A72 517E 10CB DCD5 71ED 7E35