R52 hdaps support?
I recently splurged on a new ThinkPad R52 (because it was one of the few laptops in the store with /all/ linux-supported hardware), but the 2.6.14-rc1 kernel I just compiled says "hdaps: supported laptop not found".
Looking at the source I notice there's a whitelist of models that goes up to R51... How badly could it break if I just went ahead and added R52? Should it be "NORMAL" or "INVERT"?
Keenan Pepper
Quoted 9 lines · Keenan Pepper
I recently splurged on a new ThinkPad R52 (because it was one of the few laptops in the store with /all/ linux-supported hardware), but the 2.6.14-rc1 kernel I just compiled says "hdaps: supported laptop not found".
Looking at the source I notice there's a whitelist of models that goes up to R51... How badly could it break if I just went ahead and added R52? Should it be "NORMAL" or "INVERT"?
Keenan Pepper
Hi Keenan,
We don't have the X42 nor the R52 in the list of supported laptops.
Please send an email to [email protected] so that we can do something about adding your laptop to the dmi list.
Additionally, the X41 should be in the list of supported laptops (Kconfig)
Thanks,
.Alejandro
Quoted 7 lines · Keenan Pepper
I recently splurged on a new ThinkPad R52 (because it was one of the few laptops in the store with /all/ linux-supported hardware), but the 2.6.14-rc1 kernel I just compiled says "hdaps: supported laptop not found".
Looking at the source I notice there's a whitelist of models that goes up to R51... How badly could it break if I just went ahead and added R52? Should it be "NORMAL" or "INVERT"?
The R52 should work and nothing should break. If it works, I'll add it.
As for normal versus inverted: You probably want NORMAL, but you will have to verify it and let me know. You'll know you have the wrong one when the readings are, well, inverted.
Robert Love
Quoted 7 lines · Robert Love
The R52 should work and nothing should break. If it works, I'll add it.
As for normal versus inverted: You probably want NORMAL, but you will have to verify it and let me know. You'll know you have the wrong one when the readings are, well, inverted.
Robert Love
OK, it's compiled and running, but how do I tell if it's inverted? The laptop is on a horizontal surface and /sys/devices/platform/hdaps/position reads (482,508). What does that mean?
Keenan Pepper
Quoted 3 lines · Keenan Pepper
OK, it's compiled and running, but how do I tell if it's inverted? The laptop is on a horizontal surface and
/sys/devices/platform/hdaps/positionreads (482,508). What does that mean?
Well, you can use the joystick device and see that the axises are correct.
The other thing would be to grab the pivot program from the hdaps package at http://www.kernel.org/pub/linux/kernel/people/rml/hdaps/ and run it.
Tilting the laptop to you run and toward you should be (positive, positive) I think.
Robert Love
Quoted 7 lines · Keenan Pepper
Quoted 6 lines · Robert Love
The R52 should work and nothing should break. If it works, I'll add it.
As for normal versus inverted: You probably want NORMAL, but you will have to verify it and let me know. You'll know you have the wrong one when the readings are, well, inverted.
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 1 line
Robert Love
OK, it's compiled and running, but how do I tell if it's inverted? The laptop is on a horizontal surface and
/sys/devices/platform/hdaps/positionreads (482,508). What does that mean?Keenan Pepper
Keenan,
You may try using the hdaps-gl located at the hdaps.sf.net download
section which will take you to the SF Repository.
.Alejandro
Quoted 6 lines · Alejandro Bonilla Beeche
Keenan,
You may try using the hdaps-gl located at the hdaps.sf.net download
section which will take you to the SF Repository..Alejandro
Oh wow! That's really cool. And my R52 definitely works as "NORMAL", so you can go ahead and add it to the whitelist.
Keenan
Quoted 2 lines · Keenan Pepper
Oh wow! That's really cool. And my R52 definitely works as "NORMAL", so you can go ahead and add it to the whitelist.
Done. Will be in the next patch I send to Linus.
Robert Love
Quoted 8 lines · Robert Love
Quoted 2 lines · Keenan Pepper
Oh wow! That's really cool. And my R52 definitely works as "NORMAL", so you can go ahead and add it to the whitelist.
Done. Will be in the next patch I send to Linus.
Robert Love
Robert,
We have some laptops missing from the HDAPS list.
X41 and X42? (I think)
.Alejandro
Quoted 2 lines · Alejandro Bonilla Beeche
We have some laptops missing from the HDAPS list.
X41 and X42? (I think)
I added X41 in the patch I sent out today.
X42: I don't think I have ever gotten any reports.
Robert Love