tty locking again :)
Hi Alan !
(Asking you since I know you did some TTY locking work a while ago).
I noticed that there doesn't seem to be any kind of locking in tty_(un)register_driver. It can very easily race with tty_open() doing a get_tty_driver(). Shouldn't tty_(un)register_driver be changed to take the tty_sem at least while manipulating the list ?
I noticed that while chasing a different bug (a driver bug actually), but I don't see how we are protected here. And considering the race I found in the driver, I tend to think we aren't protected at all
FYI. The hvc driver issue was basically that it was allowing struct console->device (the kernel console callback to link to the tty driver) to return the tty_driver pointer before it called tty_register_driver, thus a racing tty_open() of the default console was blow up accessing driver->ttys.
Ben.
Quoted 4 lines · Benjamin Herrenschmidt
I noticed that there doesn't seem to be any kind of locking in tty_(un)register_driver. It can very easily race with
tty_open()doing aget_tty_driver(). Shouldn't tty_(un)register_driver be changed to take thetty_semat least while manipulating the list ?
Its totally racy. Its on the todo list but I'm waiting for the buffering changes to get into the Linus kernel and tested before doing the next chunk of work on it (firstly fixing the rx/tx locking, then removing TTY_DONT_FLIP which is a precursor to sanity for polled serial devices and DMA)
Quoted 3 lines
I noticed that while chasing a different bug (a driver bug actually), but I don't see how we are protected here. And considering the race I found in the driver, I tend to think we aren't protected at all
It all needs considerable work. Fixing the receive/transmit locking is IMHO by far the most important however now the buffers are done.
Alan