linux 2.6.* sound problems
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Bodo Eggert ha scritto:
Quoted 15 lines
Quoted 11 lines · Patrizio Bassi
starting from 2.6.0 (2 years ago) i have the following bug.
and https://bugtrack.alsa-project.org/alsa-bug/view.php?id=230
fast summary:
when playing audio and using a bit the harddisk (i.e. md5sum of a 200mb file)
i hear noises, related to disk activity. more hd is used, more chicks and ZZZZ noises happen.
Quoted 2 lines
Maybe you just need to tune down unused and non-connected inputs in the mixer, especially microphone? Happened to me once.
no, it's good configured, all fields are off
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Ray Lee ha scritto:
Quoted 84 lines · Patrizio Bassi
Quoted 33 lines
Quoted 33 lines · Patrizio Bassi
Quoted 9 lines
starting from 2.6.0 (2 years ago) i have the following bug.
fast summary:
when playing audio and using a bit the harddisk (i.e. md5sum of a 200mb file) i hear noises, related to disk activity. more hd is used, more chicks and ZZZZ noises happen.Does hdparm -i (or -I) show differences between the 2.4 kernels and 2.6? 2.6 has new IDE drivers, and so perhaps your system isn't using the best driver any more.
You may also want to compare lspci -vv of your IDE controller and sound card between 2.4 and 2.6, and see if there are any differences.
No guarantees, but this is where you'd start.
Quoted 1 line
Ready to test any patch/solution.
Try that. If nothing obvious appears in the examination, you may want to try the 2.6.14-rt1 patchset from Ingo Molnar. It's designed to reduce latency in the kernel, but also has a latency tracer that may be particularly useful for your problem. (Assuming it's a latency issue, and not a hardware misconfiguration due to 2.6 doing something wrong.)
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 1 line
Ray
actually i don't have any more 2.4 kernels due to some problems with other devices.
I'd suggest installing one and at minimum booting it to single user mode to run some tests. If 2.4 works great, then it's worthwhile to find out what it's getting right that 2.6 is getting wrong. The only way to find that out is to compare the two.
Quoted 1 line
however i remember i checked that and it was pretty the same
Well, I barely trust my own memory in general, so I'd suggest that we check. Humor me. This is the standard way to find out where a problem is. Check the good, check the bad, compare the two.
Quoted 1 line
kernel is perfectly tuned.
<?> How do you know?
Quoted 5 lines
i notice that with dma disabled it works much better. problem happens with hda/hdc, so both ide channels.
hdparm -i
/dev/hdaIt'd be more useful to see hdparm 2.4 versus 2.6, so we can see if there's any difference. If we don't see the 2.4 version, then we can't tell if this is something worthwhile to tweak. Does that make sense? If they are set the same between both 2.4 and 2.6, then we know we can rule the hard drive settings out as the source of the problem.
Quoted 2 lines
BuffType=DualPortCache, BuffSize=1916kB, MaxMultSect=16, MultSect=off BuffType=DualPortCache, BuffSize=1821kB, MaxMultSect=16, MultSect=off
MultiSect is off on both, can you turn that on and see if that makes a difference? Without multisect set on (and set to 16), your hard drives are transferring one sector per interrupt, instead of a max of 16. This makes for a lot more interrupts on the system, and might be the source of the problem.
Quoted 7 lines
If that doesn't change anything, you may also try what Mike Fowler hinted at, and recompile your kernel with Hz set to 100 instead of the default 250. As well as trying the RT patchset and seeing if that shows any sources of problems.
Ray
2.4 is hard to try for me....i'll try if i can...
i set 16 to sectors setting, but nothing changed, no real changes.
i'll recompile tomorrow -git4 with 100Hz option to check if timer can help me
Quoted 41 lines · Patrizio Bassi
Ray Lee ha scritto:
Quoted 39 lines · Patrizio Bassi
Quoted 38 lines
Quoted 38 lines · Patrizio Bassi
Quoted 11 lines
starting from 2.6.0 (2 years ago) i have the following bug.
fast summary:
when playing audio and using a bit the harddisk (i.e. md5sum of a 200mb file) i hear noises, related to disk activity. more hd is used, more chicks and ZZZZ noises happen.Does hdparm -i (or -I) show differences between the 2.4 kernels and 2.6? 2.6 has new IDE drivers, and so perhaps your system isn't using the best driver any more.
You may also want to compare lspci -vv of your IDE controller and sound card between 2.4 and 2.6, and see if there are any differences.
No guarantees, but this is where you'd start.
Quoted 1 line
Ready to test any patch/solution.
Try that. If nothing obvious appears in the examination, you may want to try the 2.6.14-rt1 patchset from Ingo Molnar. It's designed to reduce latency in the kernel, but also has a latency tracer that may be particularly useful for your problem. (Assuming it's a latency issue, and not a hardware misconfiguration due to 2.6 doing something wrong.)
I've seen something like this yesterday on ECS P6EXP-Me board (i440EX chipset) with onboard CMI8338 PCI sound chip. The sound was distorted when e.g. moving mouse in Windows. When I disabled "PCI 2.1 support" in BIOS, the problem disappeared in Windows. But when I booted Slax LiveCD, the same problem appeared - so I think that Linux enables something that's causing these problems with some PCI sound devices on these chipsets.
Signature · 1 line
Ondrej Zary
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Ondrej Zary ha scritto:
Quoted 47 lines
Quoted 44 lines · Patrizio Bassi
Ray Lee ha scritto:
Quoted 42 lines · Patrizio Bassi
Quoted 41 lines
Quoted 40 lines · Patrizio Bassi
Quoted 7 lines
starting from 2.6.0 (2 years ago) i have the following bug.
Quoted 6 lines
fast summary:
when playing audio and using a bit the harddisk (i.e. md5sum of a 200mb
file) i hear noises, related to disk activity. more hd is used, more chicks
and ZZZZ noises happen.Does hdparm -i (or -I) show differences between the 2.4 kernels and 2.6? 2.6 has new IDE drivers, and so perhaps your system isn't using the best driver any more.
You may also want to compare lspci -vv of your IDE controller and sound card between 2.4 and 2.6, and see if there are any differences.
No guarantees, but this is where you'd start.
Quoted 1 line
Ready to test any patch/solution.
Try that. If nothing obvious appears in the examination, you may want to try the 2.6.14-rt1 patchset from Ingo Molnar. It's designed to reduce latency in the kernel, but also has a latency tracer that may be particularly useful for your problem. (Assuming it's a latency issue, and not a hardware misconfiguration due to 2.6 doing something wrong.)
Quoted 8 lines
I've seen something like this yesterday on ECS P6EXP-Me board (i440EX chipset) with onboard CMI8338 PCI sound chip. The sound was distorted when e.g. moving mouse in Windows. When I disabled "PCI 2.1 support" in BIOS, the problem disappeared in Windows. But when I booted Slax LiveCD, the same problem appeared - so I think that Linux enables something that's causing these problems with some PCI sound devices on these chipsets.
i played a bit with bios, but no luck.
considering that in my windows copy i have no problems, i'm sure it's linux 2.6
update: can't use linux 2.4, i have nptl only and acpi problems too. i'll play with timers and latency
Quoted 6 lines · Patrizio Bassi
i played a bit with bios, but no luck.
considering that in my windows copy i have no problems, i'm sure it's linux 2.6update: can't use linux 2.4, i have nptl only and acpi problems too. i'll play with timers and latency
One more suggestion:
try running distributed-net or something else that uses 100% cpu. I also have "bad sound" from on-board audio (hp nx9110 notebook and some elcheap asus motherboard). Usually it is a bad or cheap motherboard design.
If using your CPU 100% fixes or mostly diminishes your audio distortion, you can be 100% sure that the audio part has a very bad design (no separate voltage controllers or good power supply filters, and no separate power supply circuit, and of course a good deal of crosstalk between analog lines and "digital" lines).
Signature · 3 lines
begin LOVE-LETTER-FOR-YOU.txt.vbs I am a signature virus. Distribute me until the bitter end
Quoted 7 lines · Ard van Breemen
Quoted 6 lines · Patrizio Bassi
i played a bit with bios, but no luck.
considering that in my windows copy i have no problems, i'm sure it's linux 2.6update: can't use linux 2.4, i have nptl only and acpi problems too. i'll play with timers and latency
Quoted 11 lines
One more suggestion:
try running distributed-net or something else that uses 100% cpu. I also have "bad sound" from on-board audio (hp nx9110 notebook and some elcheap asus motherboard). Usually it is a bad or cheap motherboard design.
If using your CPU 100% fixes or mostly diminishes your audio distortion, you can be 100% sure that the audio part has a very bad design (no separate voltage controllers or good power supply filters, and no separate power supply circuit, and of course a good deal of crosstalk between analog lines and "digital" lines).
Please try to isolate whether the PCI latency timer change OR the change from HZ=250 to HZ=100 fixed the problem.
Lee
Lee Revell ha scritto:
Quoted 28 lines · Ard van Breemen
Quoted 13 lines · Patrizio Bassi
Quoted 10 lines
i played a bit with bios, but no luck.
considering that in my windows copy i have no problems, i'm sure it's linux 2.6update: can't use linux 2.4, i have nptl only and acpi problems too. i'll play with timers and latency
Quoted 13 lines
One more suggestion:
try running distributed-net or something else that uses 100% cpu. I also have "bad sound" from on-board audio (hp nx9110 notebook and some elcheap asus motherboard). Usually it is a bad or cheap motherboard design.
If using your CPU 100% fixes or mostly diminishes your audio distortion, you can be 100% sure that the audio part has a very bad design (no separate voltage controllers or good power supply filters, and no separate power supply circuit, and of course a good deal of crosstalk between analog lines and "digital" lines).
Quoted 8 lines
Please try to isolate whether the PCI latency timer change OR the change from HZ=250 to HZ=100 fixed the problem.
Lee
it seems both.
now i'm using 1000hz with 0x40 latency.
i still get some noises but lower than before (lat = 0x20).
however i saw you marked it closed as hardware problem, i'm sure it isn't.
it' a linux 2.6 problem for me, as 2.4 and windows works perfectly. stop :) a windows copy, running under vmware on linux 2.6, seems to work good too.
Quoted 4 lines · Patrizio Bassi
it seems both.
now i'm using 1000hz with0x40latency.
i still get some noises but lower than before (lat =0x20).
Quoted 8 lines
however i saw you marked it closed as hardware problem, i'm sure it isn't.
it' a linux 2.6 problem for me, as 2.4 and windows works perfectly. stop :)
a windows copy, running under vmware on linux 2.6, seems to work good too.
If the noise is caused by higher HZ settings then that is a hardware problem. Windows and Linux 2.4 use a lower HZ setting than Linux 2.6.
Lee
Lee Revell ha scritto:
Quoted 18 lines · Patrizio Bassi
Quoted 6 lines
it seems both.
now i'm using 1000hz with0x40latency.
i still get some noises but lower than before (lat =0x20).Quoted 10 lines
however i saw you marked it closed as hardware problem, i'm sure it isn't.
it' a linux 2.6 problem for me, as 2.4 and windows works perfectly. stop :)
a windows copy, running under vmware on linux 2.6, seems to work good too.
Quoted 8 lines
If the noise is caused by higher HZ settings then that is a hardware problem. Windows and Linux 2.4 use a lower HZ setting than Linux 2.6.
Lee
i'm not sure of this, however i trust you as you'll have more experience than me.
i'll buy no more creative cheap hw.