Why the DOS has many ntfs read and write driver,but the linux can't for a long time
and the dos ntfs driver was not released by the MS offical.So,what' wrong?
Somebody who can explain this ?
Quoted 3 lines · Boxer Gnome
and the dos ntfs driver was not released by the MS offical.So,what' wrong?
Somebody who can explain this ?
Sure, thats easy. You havn't paid Anton and Richard to quit their jobs to work full time on finishing full linux ntfs support. It is really quite amazing how many "linux can't do foo" type problems could be quickly solved by sending large amounts of money to the right people.
-Erik
--
Erik B. Andersen http://codepoet-consulting.com/
--This message was written using 73% post-consumer electrons--
2006/1/9, Erik Andersen <[email protected]>:
Quoted 11 lines · Boxer Gnome
Quoted 3 lines
and the dos ntfs driver was not released by the MS offical.So,what' wrong?
Somebody who can explain this ?
Sure, thats easy. You havn't paid Anton and Richard to quit their jobs to work full time on finishing full linux ntfs support. It is really quite amazing how many "linux can't do foo" type problems could be quickly solved by sending large amounts of money to the right people.
Quoted 6 lines
-Erik
--
Erik B. Andersen http://codepoet-consulting.com/
--This message was written using 73% post-consumer electrons--
But the dos' ntfs drive was free software,no ne need pay.
I see, the ntfs' spec is not so hard to know.I always think it hard to be supported before, for the ntfs' spec belongs to MS.
Quoted 12 lines · Boxer Gnome
2006/1/9, Erik Andersen <[email protected]>:
Quoted 11 lines · Boxer Gnome
Quoted 3 lines
and the dos ntfs driver was not released by the MS offical.So,what' wrong?
Somebody who can explain this ?
Sure, thats easy. You havn't paid Anton and Richard to quit their jobs to work full time on finishing full linux ntfs support. It is really quite amazing how many "linux can't do foo" type problems could be quickly solved by sending large amounts of money to the right people.
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 6 lines
-Erik
--
Erik B. Andersen http://codepoet-consulting.com/
--This message was written using 73% post-consumer electrons--But the dos' ntfs drive was free software,no ne need pay.
Only the read-only version is monetarily free.
Quoted 2 lines
I see, the ntfs' spec is not so hard to know.I always think it hard to be supported before, for the ntfs' spec belongs to MS.
Do you mean NTFSDOS from SysInternals? If so, look at it again and you'll see that it uses the NTFS.sys and NTOSKRNL.exe files from an NT installation. They worked around the need to understand the filesystem by just writing a wrapper for the NTFS driver that MS released. And if you care to trust that sort of wrapper take a look at CaptiveNTFS and you'll see the exact same thing for Linux, except you don't have to pay for write support with CaptiveNTFS. You just have to pray that it works right.
Jim.
Hi, Eric,
Quoted 10 lines · Erik Andersen
Quoted 3 lines · Boxer Gnome
and the dos ntfs driver was not released by the MS offical.So,what' wrong?
Somebody who can explain this ?
Sure, thats easy. You havn't paid Anton and Richard to quit their jobs to work full time on finishing full linux ntfs support. It is really quite amazing how many "linux can't do foo" type problems could be quickly solved by sending large amounts of money to the right people.
Could or would you be so kind to provide at least moderately complete pricelist ? Whom and how much should I pay to have correct support for intel graphics chipset, 2200BG Wi-Fi, complete suspend-to-disk/suspend-to-ram and to get an overall performance boost ?
Signature · 1 line
Managing your Territory since the dawn of times ...
Quoted 15 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Hi, Eric,
Quoted 11 lines · Erik Andersen
Quoted 4 lines · Boxer Gnome
and the dos ntfs driver was not released by the MS offical.So,what' wrong?
Somebody who can explain this ?
Sure, thats easy. You havn't paid Anton and Richard to quit their jobs to work full time on finishing full linux ntfs support. It is really quite amazing how many "linux can't do foo" type problems could be quickly solved by sending large amounts of money to the right people.
Quoted 4 lines
Could or would you be so kind to provide at least moderately complete pricelist ? Whom and how much should I pay to have correct support for intel graphics chipset, 2200BG Wi-Fi, complete suspend-to-disk/suspend-to-ram and to get an overall performance boost ?
Since these are all supported in 2.6.15, $0 would be my quote.
Signature · 6 lines
Cheers, Alistair. 'No sense being pessimistic, it probably wouldn't work anyway.' Third year Computer Science undergraduate. 1F2 55 South Clerk Street, Edinburgh, UK.
Hi,
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 1 line
money to the right people.
Could or would you be so kind to provide at least moderately complete pricelist ? Whom and how much should I pay to have correct support for intel graphics chipset, 2200BG Wi-Fi, complete suspend-to-disk/suspend-to-ram and to get an overall performance boost ?
Since these are all supported in 2.6.15, $0 would be my quote.
I've mentioned _correct_ support. Contrary to current rather sad state of things.
855GM still has no support for non-VESA videomodes (1280x800 can be enabled only via VBIOS hacks, and is not always properly restored on resume) (and don't supported with intelfb) (which, AFAIK, has no support for dualhead)
2200BG sometimes starts to unacceptably lag and drop packets after going out of suspend (either STR or STD) and until reboot. (And this is driver issue)
Suspend to ram works, more or less, but drains power like hungry cat drinks milk, and I just can't leave my laptop in STR for more than two days without worrying about my on-the-road availability.
Suspend to disk has nasty tendency to ruin my whole hot live X session, since X can't properly restore VT on resume. Overall performance isn't that bad, either, but I just can't understand, why KATE (Kde more or less advanced editor) takes twice as long to start as UltraEdit in _emulated_ (VMWare) Windows XP running on this same box.
So, the question remains the same - whom and how much I need to pay to solve abovementioned problems ?
Signature · 1 line
Managing your Territory since the dawn of times ...
Quoted 1 line · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Suspend to disk has nasty tendency to ruin my whole hot live X session, since X can't properly restore VT on resume.
Not necessarily a solution but have you thought of putting chvt in the suspend/resume sequence? chvt to a terminal before suspending and chvt to X after resume.
This was one of the things I used to do when I had BIOS suspend to disk working (it was nice but then gateway *spit* decided to remove it in a bios upgrade).
Still, the above might help you until you find someone to throw money at. ;)
Signature · 3 lines
"To the extent that we overreact, we proffer the terrorists the
greatest tribute."
- High Court Judge Michael KirbyHi,
Quoted 6 lines · CaT
Quoted 1 line · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Suspend to disk has nasty tendency to ruin my whole hot live X session, since X can't properly restore VT on resume.
Not necessarily a solution but have you thought of putting chvt in the suspend/resume sequence? chvt to a terminal before suspending and chvt to X after resume.
Yes, of course. I've spent countless hours trying to figure solution for this particular problem. Tried generic Linux suspend-to-disk and swsusp2, changing terminals before/after suspend, delay sleeps, vbetool and all that fuss and jazz. Looks like race condition somewhere between kernel and X driver.
Quoted 3 lines
Still, the above might help you until you find someone to throw money at. ;)
Ahhh. Sweet dream - to be able to offer money to fix extremely annoying bugs or to add missing features. Unfortunately, bounties doesn't work :-/
Quoted 1 line
Signature · 1 line
Managing your Territory since the dawn of times ...
Quoted 3 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Ahhh. Sweet dream - to be able to offer money to fix extremely annoying bugs or to add missing features. Unfortunately, bounties doesn't work :-/
Depends on how much money you have to offer. If you have the resources to hire a programmer full-time until your favourite problem is solved - no problem I think.
If funding development alone is a bit much, consider starting with one particular problem and try collecting money from other interested people.
Money can surely get the work done - but then you usually have to pay enough that the programmer can make a living while working for you. The cheap alternative is enthusiasts who will write a hardware driver if they get the hw for free.
Helge Hafting
Quoted 10 lines · Helge Hafting
Quoted 4 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Ahhh. Sweet dream - to be able to offer money to fix extremely annoying bugs or to add missing features. Unfortunately, bounties doesn't work :-/
Depends on how much money you have to offer. If you have the resources to hire
a programmer full-time until your favourite problem is solved - no problem I think.
Well, some docs would usually be very helpful. Reverse engineering is usually too slow IMO.
Quoted 9 lines
If funding development alone is a bit much, consider starting with one particular problem and try collecting money from other interested people.
Money can surely get the work done - but then you usually have to pay enough that the programmer can make a living while working for you. The cheap alternative is enthusiasts who will write a hardware driver if they get
the hw for free.
Signature · 1 line
~Randy
Quoted 1 line · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Unfortunately, bounties doesn't work :-/
No? Bounties seems to work fine for Asterisk. Is the problem, still no central linux kernel bounty system?
--
David L Nicol
high on complexity
Quoted 7 lines · David Nicol
Quoted 1 line · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Unfortunately, bounties doesn't work :-/
No? Bounties seems to work fine for Asterisk. Is the problem, still no central linux kernel bounty system?
Many bounties don't work because they are too low, too vague or both. For example several months ago Ubuntu offered $500 to "fix all remaining ALSA issues for PowerMac hardware". HA! That's like 5 or 6 diffent drivers which ranged from not working at all, to sound works but no system beeps, etc...
Lee
Quoted 10 lines · Lee Revell
Quoted 7 lines · David Nicol
Quoted 1 line · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Unfortunately, bounties doesn't work :-/
No? Bounties seems to work fine for Asterisk. Is the problem, still no central linux kernel bounty system?
Quoted 7 lines
Many bounties don't work because they are too low, too vague or both. For example several months ago Ubuntu offered $500 to "fix all remaining ALSA issues for PowerMac hardware". HA! That's like 5 or 6 diffent drivers which ranged from not working at all, to sound works but no system beeps, etc...
Lee
How did they offer this bounty? Through the ubuntu announcements channels?
Like if, say, Linux International was to partner with TipJar.com to create and maintain an organized open bounty system where stakeholders wanting to see something could contribute to the pot for the feature and the first implementor who passes the tests (including code readability!) gets the pot.
Write me off-list to become involved in this project or to direct me to an already existing project so I don't waste more time on wheel reinvention?
David "tipjar" Nicol
--
David L Nicol
awrsagfagoijneaghnjhda
Quoted 22 lines · David Nicol
Quoted 10 lines · Lee Revell
Quoted 7 lines · David Nicol
Quoted 1 line · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Unfortunately, bounties doesn't work :-/
No? Bounties seems to work fine for Asterisk. Is the problem, still no central linux kernel bounty system?
Quoted 7 lines
Many bounties don't work because they are too low, too vague or both. For example several months ago Ubuntu offered $500 to "fix all remaining ALSA issues for PowerMac hardware". HA! That's like 5 or 6 diffent drivers which ranged from not working at all, to sound works but no system beeps, etc...
Lee
How did they offer this bounty? Through the ubuntu announcements channels?
Quoted 7 lines
Like if, say, Linux International was to partner with TipJar.com to create and maintain an organized open bounty system where stakeholders wanting to see something could contribute to the pot for the feature and the first implementor who passes the tests (including code readability!) gets the pot.
Write me off-list to become involved in this project or to direct me to an already existing project so I don't waste more time on wheel reinvention?
Heh, I only found out about it when some Ubuntu user mentioned it in an ALSA bug report. I guess they just expect people to find them somehow. So yes, there needs to be a single, central resource for OSS bounties.
I think a lot of these problems with the PPC drivers were later solved. But my point was really that $500 was not nearly enough for the amount of work that would have been required. It's a nice bonus for someone who would have done it for free anyway but I was under the impression that bounties were created to solve problems too tricky or unrewarding or uninteresting for someone to do for free.
Lee
Quoted 16 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Hi,
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 1 line
money to the right people.
Could or would you be so kind to provide at least moderately complete pricelist ? Whom and how much should I pay to have correct support for intel graphics chipset, 2200BG Wi-Fi, complete suspend-to-disk/suspend-to-ram and to get an overall performance boost ?
Since these are all supported in 2.6.15, $0 would be my quote.
I've mentioned _correct_ support. Contrary to current rather sad state of things.
855GM still has no support for non-VESA videomodes (1280x800 can be enabled only via VBIOS hacks, and is not always properly restored on resume) (and don't supported with intelfb) (which, AFAIK, has no support for dualhead)
2200BG sometimes starts to unacceptably lag and drop packets after going out of suspend (either STR or STD) and until reboot. (And this is driver issue)
Suspend to ram works, more or less, but drains power like hungry cat drinks milk, and I just can't leave my laptop in STR for more than two days
Quoted 4 lines
without worrying about my on-the-road availability.
Suspend to disk has nasty tendency to ruin my whole hot live X session, since X can't properly restore VT on resume. Overall performance isn't that bad, either, but I just can't understand, why KATE (Kde more or less advanced editor) takes twice as long to start as UltraEdit in _emulated_ (VMWare) Windows XP running on this same box.
i can not take this seriously.. on both my laptop and workstation, the kate window is up in less than a second after i either run kate from a terminal, or select it in the kde menu..
unless ofcourse you are not using kde, and kate is the first kde application you start, then it will need to load much more than simply kate, at which point you cant really say what you are doing, since it would be somewhat like comparing half of windows's startup time + ultraedit startup time to kate startup time...
Quoted 3 lines
So, the question remains the same - whom and how much I need to pay to solve abovementioned problems ?
Hi, Kasper,
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
without worrying about my on-the-road availability.
Suspend to disk has nasty tendency to ruin my whole hot live X session, since X can't properly restore VT on resume. Overall performance isn't that bad, either, but I just can't understand, why KATE (Kde more or less advanced editor) takes twice as long to start as UltraEdit in _emulated_ (VMWare) Windows XP running on this same box.i can not take this seriously.. on both my laptop and workstation, the kate window is up in less than a second after i either run kate from a terminal, or select it in the kde menu..
Well, I could find more or less reasonable explanation of this behaviour - different VM policies of two OSes and
strangely strong and persistent belief "Free RAM is a wasted RAM" among kernel devs. Free RAM is not a wasted RAM, its a memory waiting to be used ! Whenever it is needed by apps I'm launching or working with.
Quoted 6 lines
unless ofcourse you are not using kde, and kate is the first kde application you start, then it will need to load much more than simply kate, at which point you cant really say what you are doing, since it would be somewhat like comparing half of windows's startup time + ultraedit startup time to kate startup time...
No. Fully loaded KDE session (without kdesktop and kwin, since I don't use first and using my own WM instead of second). So almost all necessary libraries are hot and loaded, and all what's missing is a dozen of Window's and Pixmap's to allocate and two threads to handle events. And it takes seconds, not tens of a second, as in UltraEdit case
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 4 lines
So, the question remains the same - whom and how much I need to pay to solve abovementioned problems ?
Signature · 1 line
Managing your Territory since the dawn of times ...
Quoted 7 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
No. Fully loaded KDE session (without kdesktop and kwin, since I don't use first and using my own WM instead of second).
So almost all necessary libraries are hot and loaded, and all what's missing is a dozen of Window's and Pixmap's to allocate and two threads to
handle events. And it takes seconds, not tens of a second, as in UltraEdit case
Currently Linux performance loading large binaries is at least perceptually worse than Windows (some of that is perceptual tricks windows apps pull, some of it real). There is an openoffice.org related analysis project currently under way to sort that out.
A second problem is the popularity of some very inefficiently written desktops which badly need a good optimise, a diet and/or stuffing where the sun doesn't shine. The kernel can only do so much of the work and comparing xfce4 with gnome/kde shows that the kernel isn't the only party involved in this....
Alan
Quoted 3 lines · Alan Cox
Currently Linux performance loading large binaries is at least perceptually worse than Windows (some of that is perceptual tricks windows apps pull, some of it real).
Would you care to elaborate on this statement? It's not clear to me how perception could differ from reality in this case. If it seems faster doesn't that mean it is faster?
Lee
Quoted 3 lines · Lee Revell
Would you care to elaborate on this statement? It's not clear to me how perception could differ from reality in this case. If it seems faster doesn't that mean it is faster?
Depends who is measuring and what is being measured.
If you want to understand how to make the kernel faster you care about real speed changes. Application authors may well want to look at perceptual tricks (like splash screens, opening windows early before you have the code even loaded to do much else etc)
Alan
Quoted 8 lines · Lee Revell
Quoted 3 lines · Alan Cox
Currently Linux performance loading large binaries is at least perceptually worse than Windows (some of that is perceptual tricks windows apps pull, some of it real).
Would you care to elaborate on this statement? It's not clear to me how perception could differ from reality in this case. If it seems faster doesn't that mean it is faster?
You can have a window opened without being ready to accept input yet for instance. XEmacs does that[1] when it opens its window before parsing the user's configuration which can load a number of things and hence take a while to run. "Ok I'm going to open your application" animations allow to win some perceptual time too.
Humans are fundamentally easy to fool for 1-2 seconds as long as they have feedback. Longer gets harder :-)
OG.
[1] For technical reasons, not perceptual.
Quoted 4 lines · Alan Cox
Currently Linux performance loading large binaries is at least perceptually worse than Windows (some of that is perceptual tricks windows apps pull, some of it real). There is an openoffice.org related analysis project currently under way to sort that out.
Desktop performance has become a such hot topic that I wonder if it would be worth to setup a dedicated mailing list somewhere where all the parts involved (kernel, kde/gnome, x.org, libc) can analyze what are the real problems are.
Quoted 8 lines · Diego Calleja
Quoted 4 lines · Alan Cox
Currently Linux performance loading large binaries is at least perceptually worse than Windows (some of that is perceptual tricks windows apps pull, some of it real). There is an openoffice.org related analysis project currently under way to sort that out.
Quoted 4 lines
Desktop performance has become a such hot topic that I wonder if it would be worth to setup a dedicated mailing list somewhere where all the parts involved (kernel, kde/gnome, x.org, libc) can analyze what are the real problems are.
There already is one:
http://lists.osdl.org/pipermail/desktop_architects/2005-December/thread.html#522
Lee
Quoted 20 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Hi,
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 1 line
money to the right people.
Could or would you be so kind to provide at least moderately complete pricelist ? Whom and how much should I pay to have correct support for intel graphics chipset, 2200BG Wi-Fi, complete suspend-to-disk/suspend-to-ram and to get an overall performance boost ?
Since these are all supported in 2.6.15, $0 would be my quote.
I've mentioned _correct_ support. Contrary to current rather sad state of things.
855GM still has no support for non-VESA videomodes (1280x800 can be enabled only via VBIOS hacks, and is not always properly restored on resume) (and don't supported with intelfb) (which, AFAIK, has no support for dualhead)
2200BG sometimes starts to unacceptably lag and drop packets after going out of suspend (either STR or STD) and until reboot. (And this is driver issue)
Suspend to ram works, more or less, but drains power like hungry cat drinks milk, and I just can't leave my laptop in STR for more than two days without worrying about my on-the-road availability.
Suspend to disk has nasty tendency to ruin my whole hot live X session, since X can't properly restore VT on resume. Overall performance isn't that bad, either, but I just can't understand, why KATE (Kde more or less advanced editor) takes twice as long to start as UltraEdit in _emulated_ (VMWare) Windows XP running on this same box.
Quoted 2 lines
So, the question remains the same - whom and how much I need to pay to solve abovementioned problems ?
Where are the bug reports? You didn't expect these to just fix themselves did you?
Lee
Hi, Lee,
Quoted 4 lines · you
Quoted 1 line
Where are the bug reports? You didn't expect these to just fix themselves did you?
Been there, done that. Bugreport about malfunctioning (due to ACPI) 3c556 in IBM ThinkPad T20 was looked at once in a few months without any progress, and I've finally lost track of it after changing hardware. In more than a year this problem wasn't solved, so I'm assuming bugreports aren't so effective. 2200BG ping and packet loss problem was reported in ipw2200-devel mailing list recently (by another user), and the only answer was "Switch to version 1.0.0" (which is tooo old and missing needed features and bugfixes, so recommentation was unacceptable). So I'm assuming addressing developers directly is not too effective either.
Two other options I see are to debug/fix it by myself and try to stimulate others monetarily. First option isn't really affordable for me , so I'm trying to research second.
Signature · 1 line
Managing your Territory since the dawn of times ...
Quoted 6 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Hi, Lee,
Quoted 4 lines · you
Quoted 1 line
Where are the bug reports? You didn't expect these to just fix themselves did you?
Quoted 7 lines
Been there, done that. Bugreport about malfunctioning (due to ACPI) 3c556 in IBM ThinkPad T20 was looked at once in a few months without any progress, and I've finally lost track of it after changing hardware. In more than a year this problem wasn't solved, so I'm assuming bugreports aren't so effective. 2200BG ping and packet loss problem was reported in ipw2200-devel mailing list recently (by another user), and the only answer was "Switch to version 1.0.0" (which is tooo old and missing needed features and bugfixes, so recommentation was unacceptable). So I'm assuming addressing developers directly is not too effective either.
Two other options I see are to debug/fix it by myself and try to stimulate others monetarily. First option isn't really affordable for me , so I'm trying to research second.
Bug reports certainly are effective, but if no one else can reproduce your problem then obviously it can't be fixed.
A bug report that gets no responses is a good sign that you need to provide more information or work a little harder to debug it yourself.
Lee
Quoted 15 lines · Lee Revell
Quoted 6 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Hi, Lee,
Quoted 4 lines · you
Quoted 1 line
Where are the bug reports? You didn't expect these to just fix themselves did you?
Quoted 7 lines
Been there, done that. Bugreport about malfunctioning (due to ACPI) 3c556 in IBM ThinkPad T20 was looked at once in a few months without any progress, and I've finally lost track of it after changing hardware. In more than a year this problem wasn't solved, so I'm assuming bugreports aren't so effective. 2200BG ping and packet loss problem was reported in ipw2200-devel mailing list recently (by another user), and the only answer was "Switch to version 1.0.0" (which is tooo old and missing needed features and bugfixes, so recommentation was unacceptable). So I'm assuming addressing developers directly is not too effective either.
Two other options I see are to debug/fix it by myself and try to stimulate others monetarily. First option isn't really affordable for me , so I'm trying to research second.
Quoted 2 lines
Bug reports certainly are effective, but if no one else can reproduce your problem then obviously it can't be fixed.
That's not a good attitude IMO. I'd bet that Linus and Andrew have fixed lots of bugs that they couldn't reproduce.
Quoted 2 lines
A bug report that gets no responses is a good sign that you need to provide more information or work a little harder to debug it yourself.
Signature · 1 line
~Randy
Quoted 17 lines · Randy.Dunlap
Quoted 15 lines · Lee Revell
Quoted 13 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Hi, Lee,
Quoted 4 lines · you
Quoted 1 line
Where are the bug reports? You didn't expect these to just fix themselves did you?
Been there, done that. Bugreport about malfunctioning (due to ACPI) 3c556 in IBM ThinkPad T20 was looked at once in a few months without any progress, and I've finally lost track of it after changing hardware. In more than a year this problem wasn't solved, so I'm assuming bugreports aren't so effective. 2200BG ping and packet loss problem was reported in ipw2200-devel mailing list recently (by another user), and the only answer was "Switch to version 1.0.0" (which is tooo old and missing needed features and bugfixes, so recommentation was unacceptable). So I'm assuming addressing developers directly is not too effective either.
Two other options I see are to debug/fix it by myself and try to stimulate others monetarily. First option isn't really affordable for me , so I'm trying to research second.
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Bug reports certainly are effective, but if no one else can reproduce your problem then obviously it can't be fixed.
That's not a good attitude IMO. I'd bet that Linus and Andrew have fixed lots of bugs that they couldn't reproduce.
It makes sense for not-yet-mature stuff like ipw....
Signature · 1 line
Thanks, Sharp!
Hi,
Quoted 5 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Been there, done that. Bugreport about malfunctioning (due to ACPI) 3c556 in IBM ThinkPad T20 was looked at once in a few months without any progress, and I've finally lost track of it after changing hardware. In more than a year this problem wasn't solved, so I'm assuming bugreports aren't so effective.
Unfortunately bug reports are sometimes lost in the noise. How many times did you resend the bug report? Did you report all the required information? Were you able to isolate the failing subsystem? Was there a working kernel version? Did you try to isolate the changeset that introduced the bug? Sometimes you have to complain many times and do a bit of investigative work yourself. There are plenty of bug reports on LKML which are being ignored because the original reported fails to follow up on the problem.
Quoted 5 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
2200BG ping and packet loss problem was reported in ipw2200-devel mailing list recently (by another user), and the only answer was "Switch to version 1.0.0" (which is tooo old and missing needed features and bugfixes, so recommentation was unacceptable). So I'm assuming addressing developers directly is not too effective either.
IPW2200 hardware documentation is closed which narrows down the amount of people who can help you out, sorry. Perhaps you could complain to your vendor?
Pekka
Quoted 20 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Hi,
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 1 line
money to the right people.
Could or would you be so kind to provide at least moderately complete pricelist ? Whom and how much should I pay to have correct support for intel graphics chipset, 2200BG Wi-Fi, complete suspend-to-disk/suspend-to-ram and to get an overall performance boost ?
Since these are all supported in 2.6.15, $0 would be my quote.
I've mentioned _correct_ support. Contrary to current rather sad state of things.
855GM still has no support for non-VESA videomodes (1280x800 can be enabled only via VBIOS hacks, and is not always properly restored on resume) (and don't supported with intelfb) (which, AFAIK, has no support for dualhead)
2200BG sometimes starts to unacceptably lag and drop packets after going out of suspend (either STR or STD) and until reboot. (And this is driver issue)
Suspend to ram works, more or less, but drains power like hungry cat drinks milk, and I just can't leave my laptop in STR for more than two days without worrying about my on-the-road availability.
Suspend to disk has nasty tendency to ruin my whole hot live X session, since X can't properly restore VT on resume. Overall performance isn't that bad, either, but I just can't understand, why KATE (Kde more or less advanced editor) takes twice as long to start as UltraEdit in _emulated_ (VMWare) Windows XP running on this same box.
Quoted 1 line
So, the question remains the same - whom and how much I need to pay to solve abovementioned problems ?
The best place to ask this question is IMHO the respective development lists and/or maintainers. If both of this does not exist, find recent patch submitters (who provided patches for more than whitespace and similar cleanups) and ask them.
Bernd
Signature · 3 lines
Firmix Software GmbH http://www.firmix.at/
mobil: +43 664 4416156 fax: +43 1 7890849-55
Embedded Linux Development and ServicesQuoted 24 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Hi,
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 1 line
money to the right people.
Could or would you be so kind to provide at least moderately complete pricelist ? Whom and how much should I pay to have correct support for intel graphics chipset, 2200BG Wi-Fi, complete suspend-to-disk/suspend-to-ram and to get an overall performance boost ?
Since these are all supported in 2.6.15, $0 would be my quote.
I've mentioned _correct_ support. Contrary to current rather sad state of things. 855GM still has no support for non-VESA videomodes (1280x800 can be enabled only via VBIOS hacks, and is not always properly restored on resume) (and don't supported with intelfb) (which, AFAIK, has no support for dualhead) 2200BG sometimes starts to unacceptably lag and drop packets after going out of suspend (either STR or STD) and until reboot.
(And this is driver issue)Suspend to ram works, more or less, but drains power like hungry cat drinks milk, and I just can't leave my laptop in STR for more than two days without worrying about my on-the-road availability.
Suspend to disk has nasty tendency to ruin my whole hot live X session, since X can't properly restore VT on resume.
Quoted 3 lines
Overall performance isn't that bad, either, but I just can't understand, why KATE (Kde more or less advanced editor) takes twice as long to start as UltraEdit in _emulated_ (VMWare) Windows XP running on this same box.
stracing kate with -t, -tt, -ttt and/or -T options may help. man strace. (Do you have such tool in Windows?)
Quoted 2 lines
So, the question remains the same - whom and how much I need to pay to solve abovementioned problems?
Maybe RedHat, or Suse, or some other commercial distro. --
vda
Quoted 4 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Overall performance isn't that bad, either, but I just can't understand, why KATE (Kde more or less advanced editor) takes twice as long to start as UltraEdit in _emulated_ (VMWare) Windows XP running on this same box.
So, the question remains the same - whom and how much I need to pay to solve abovementioned problems ?
X.org and related freedesktop projects would be a good start. There's a _lot_ of things that need to be done for X.org and nobody is doing them, and they benefit all the desktops not just KDE. Fontconfig eats 1/3 of the time it takes to start a kde app (with warm caches), for example.
Quoted 8 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Hi,
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 1 line
money to the right people.
Could or would you be so kind to provide at least moderately complete pricelist ? Whom and how much should I pay to have correct support for intel graphics chipset, 2200BG Wi-Fi, complete suspend-to-disk/suspend-to-ram and to get an overall performance boost ?
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 1 line
Since these are all supported in 2.6.15, $0 would be my quote.
I've mentioned _correct_ support. Contrary to current rather sad state of things.
855GM still has no support for non-VESA videomodes (1280x800 can be enabled only via VBIOS hacks, and is not always properly restored on resume) (and don't supported with intelfb) (which, AFAIK, has no support for dualhead)
This can be fixed with money, send me lots of it and I'd swear I'd fix it, however I'm lacking the other thing which is time, I'm nearly sure I've gotten enough information to start working on some basic modesetting for some of the external parts for these chips, however TMDS controllers for laptop screen is probably the one area which is going to be more difficult and at that stage it usually involves cracking open the laptop and looking inside, or doing some "looking" at the BIOS.
The thing is Intel could do this work as well, but they probably don't want to release source code to drive other vendors chips (the external chips are never from Intel) as they may not have the proper NDAs in place, however a company like Intel could also just bully the smaller vendors into supplying them with such NDAs, and pull the finger out.
Also the fact that the OEMs just put whatever chip onto the board they can, and fix the Win32 drivers to use them, means Intel don't know in a lot of cases what has been stuck to the end of the i855 chipset to drive the internal flat panel or DVI connectors.
Dave.
Hi!
Quoted 19 lines
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 1 line
money to the right people.
Could or would you be so kind to provide at least moderately complete pricelist ? Whom and how much should I pay to have correct support for intel graphics chipset, 2200BG Wi-Fi, complete suspend-to-disk/suspend-to-ram and to get an overall performance boost ?
Since these are all supported in 2.6.15, $0 would be my quote.
I've mentioned _correct_ support. Contrary to current rather sad state of things.
855GM still has no support for non-VESA videomodes (1280x800 can be enabled only via VBIOS hacks, and is not always properly restored on resume) (and don't supported with intelfb) (which, AFAIK, has no support for dualhead)
2200BG sometimes starts to unacceptably lag and drop packets after going out of suspend (either STR or STD) and until reboot. (And this is driver issue)
Suspend to ram works, more or less, but drains power like hungry cat drinks milk, and I just can't leave my laptop in STR for more than two days without worrying about my on-the-road availability.
Suspend to disk has nasty tendency to ruin my whole hot live X session, since X can't properly restore VT on resume. Overall performance isn't that bad, either, but I just can't understand, why KATE (Kde more or less advanced editor) takes twice as long to start as UltraEdit in _emulated_ (VMWare) Windows XP running on this same box.
Quoted 1 line
So, the question remains the same - whom and how much I need to pay to solve abovementioned problems ?
Buy SLES with support contract. We should be able to help with s-t-disk and ipw2200... 2 days in s-t-ram sounds quite ok, why do you think anytink is wrong there?
Pavel
Signature · 1 line
Thanks, Sharp!
Quoted 7 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Hi, Eric,
Quoted 5 lines · Erik Andersen
Quoted 3 lines · Boxer Gnome
and the dos ntfs driver was not released by the MS offical.So,what' wrong?
Somebody who can explain this ?
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Sure, thats easy. You havn't paid Anton and Richard to quit their jobs to work full time on finishing full linux ntfs support. It is really quite amazing how many "linux can't do foo" type problems could be quickly solved by sending large amounts of money to the right people.
Could or would you be so kind to provide at least moderately complete pricelist ? Whom and how much should I pay to have correct support for intel graphics chipset, 2200BG Wi-Fi, complete suspend-to-disk/suspend-to-ram and to get an overall performance boost ?
You do understand that most of these types of problem are due to incomplete hardware specs, and that no amount of money thrown at the developers can help - you need to talk to the vendors.
Lee
Quoted 8 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Hi, Eric,
Quoted 5 lines · Erik Andersen
Quoted 3 lines · Boxer Gnome
and the dos ntfs driver was not released by the MS offical.So,what' wrong?
Somebody who can explain this ?
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Sure, thats easy. You havn't paid Anton and Richard to quit their jobs to work full time on finishing full linux ntfs support. It is really quite amazing how many "linux can't do foo" type problems could be quickly solved by sending large amounts of money to the right people.
Could or would you be so kind to provide at least moderately complete pricelist ? Whom and how much should I pay to have correct support for intel graphics chipset, 2200BG Wi-Fi, complete suspend-to-disk/suspend-to-ram and to get an overall performance boost ?
A quick grep indicates that you reported zero bugs to this mailing list in 2005.
Please preapre quality bug reports (preferably in less-than-80-column emails) and direct them to the relevant maintainers and be prepared to work with those maintainers in the resolution of the bugs.
Quoted 15 lines · Andrew Morton
Quoted 6 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Quoted 5 lines · Erik Andersen
Quoted 3 lines · Boxer Gnome
and the dos ntfs driver was not released by the MS offical.So,what' wrong?
Somebody who can explain this ?
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Sure, thats easy. You havn't paid Anton and Richard to quit their jobs to work full time on finishing full linux ntfs support. It is really quite amazing how many "linux can't do foo" type problems could be quickly solved by sending large amounts of money to the right people.
Could or would you be so kind to provide at least moderately complete pricelist ? Whom and how much should I pay to have correct support for intel graphics chipset, 2200BG Wi-Fi, complete suspend-to-disk/suspend-to-ram and to get an overall performance boost ?
Quoted 6 lines
A quick grep indicates that you reported zero bugs to this mailing list in 2005.
Please preapre quality bug reports (preferably in less-than-80-column emails) and direct them to the relevant maintainers and be prepared to work with those maintainers in the resolution of the bugs.
Andrew, I think this is a rare (on lkml at least) case when guy does not want to participate in development in a Linux way but wants to just pay for development instead:
"I want this <hardware> to work good under Linux. I want to pay up to <sum> to whoever will agree to do that. Anybody?"
Do not dismiss him lightly. There are LOTS of people which aren't hackish at all. An order of magniture more than 'us' computer geeks. M$ is successful because it uses this resource.
We may want to think how can we use it too.
No, I don't think you, or someone else on this list can efficiently use it, but distros, being more commercially oriented, maybe can. --
vda
On Tuesday 10 January 2006 02:33, Denis Vlasenko wrote:
<snip>
Quoted 6 lines
Andrew, I think this is a rare (on lkml at least) case when guy does not want to participate in development in a Linux way but wants to just pay for development instead:
"I want this <hardware> to work good under Linux. I want to pay up to <sum> to whoever will agree to do that. Anybody?"
Quoted 7 lines
Do not dismiss him lightly. There are LOTS of people which aren't hackish at all. An order of magniture more than 'us' computer geeks. M$ is successful because it uses this resource.
We may want to think how can we use it too.No, I don't think you, or someone else on this list can efficiently use it, but distros, being more commercially oriented, maybe can.
This is true. The types of bounties I have seen in OS development do not usually reach much beyond $500. If distro's were to get behind this and start offering bounties of large sums for _working_ code for hardware there might be a response. As you've said, M$ is successful because it can throw money at the problems. Sadly, another reason why M$ is successful are their NDA's and the terms of any number of the contracts they offer hardware vendors and the like. (And yet another reason is the fact that they got their foot in the doo at just the right time. However, IMHO (and I have seen this recently), Now is the time for Linux to start really stepping up to bat. I have had any number of freinds and relatives ask me if there is an alternative to Windows and how it takes so much work to keep running (I teach them basic windows maintenance so I don't have to spend weekends going from house to house fixing problems)
- sadly I've had to tell them they are stuck with Windows for various reasons. (Nothing to do with the Kernel, but the state of the available software))
But if the larger distro vendors would start offering bounties, all the various small kernel problems that would stymie them would probably disappear. Then the only problem is the market penetration and the availability of software many people have come to depend on. (I have two relatives who rely on the newest Yahoo IM clients voice chat and web-cam abilities. Yahoo has not, and apparently will not, update their "Official" client for Linux to have these capabilities and none of the alternative clients have them.) When (I'm quite hopeful) Linux begins to get more market penetration these problems of software should start to disappear.
_That_ is a goal Linux is (hopefully) aiming towards. This one persons offer of money isn't enough - but more than likely larger offered sums will lure more of the "Less Hackish" developers to start doing work for Linux. The other problem is one of the legality of binary-only modules. I, personally, have seen _very_ few with any "binary only" code that directly accesses kernel facilities - those interfaces are always released openly. (I cannot verify this for the two binary only modules I have had to deal with recently
- if just because I don't actually have the time to disassemble the object files they ship to check for kernel function use. (Which would mean inclusion of portions of the Kernel Headers. Which, I'm afraid, to me would signify them being derivative works and therefore in violation of the GPL.)
I've wasted enough bandwidth here. Note that all flames will be read and laughed at :)
D. Hazelton
Quoted 2 lines · D. Hazelton
This is true. The types of bounties I have seen in OS development do not usually reach much beyond $500. If distro's were to get behind this and start
Well - just pay for redhat/suse/whatever license, you can ask them to fix the problem. That's why they exist in first place.
Quoted 13 lines · D. Hazelton
On Tuesday 10 January 2006 02:33, Denis Vlasenko wrote:
<snip>Quoted 11 lines
Andrew, I think this is a rare (on lkml at least) case when guy does not want to participate in development in a Linux way but wants to just pay for development instead:
"I want this <hardware> to work good under Linux. I want to pay up to <sum> to whoever will agree to do that. Anybody?"Do not dismiss him lightly. There are LOTS of people which aren't hackish at all. An order of magniture more than 'us' computer geeks. M$ is successful because it uses this resource.
We may want to think how can we use it too.
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines
No, I don't think you, or someone else on this list can efficiently use it, but distros, being more commercially oriented, maybe can.
This is true. The types of bounties I have seen in OS development do not usually reach much beyond $500. If distro's were to get behind this and start offering bounties of large sums for _working_ code for hardware there might be a response.
I meant a different thing. Distro is a commercial entity. Users can buy services from businesses. "Write (or fix) me a driver" is a service.
People inclined to just pay for code instead of helping with coding may have greater success talking to distros.
Of course, distros then will hire someone from lkml crowd to actually do it.
If there will be enough of cash flow from such requests, this can becode somebody's full time job.
--
vda
Quoted 27 lines · Denis Vlasenko
Quoted 14 lines · D. Hazelton
On Tuesday 10 January 2006 02:33, Denis Vlasenko wrote:
<snip>Quoted 11 lines
Andrew, I think this is a rare (on lkml at least) case when guy does not want to participate in development in a Linux way but wants to just pay for development instead:
"I want this <hardware> to work good under Linux. I want to pay up to <sum> to whoever will agree to do that. Anybody?"Do not dismiss him lightly. There are LOTS of people which aren't hackish at all. An order of magniture more than 'us' computer geeks. M$ is successful because it uses this resource.
We may want to think how can we use it too.Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines
No, I don't think you, or someone else on this list can efficiently use it, but distros, being more commercially oriented, maybe can.
This is true. The types of bounties I have seen in OS development do not usually reach much beyond $500. If distro's were to get behind this and start offering bounties of large sums for _working_ code for hardware there might be a response.
I meant a different thing. Distro is a commercial entity. Users can buy services from businesses. "Write (or fix) me a driver" is a service.
Quoted 8 lines
People inclined to just pay for code instead of helping with coding may have greater success talking to distros.
Of course, distros then will hire someone from lkml crowd to actually do it.
If there will be enough of cash flow from such requests, this can becode somebody's full time job.
Almost exactly what I meant. Truth is, though, that I mentioned the "bounty" system because its flexible enough that the distro's wouldn't have to hire someone full-time. However, I can see that it would make a difference in several respects. Statement withdrawn.
D. Hazelton
Hi, Denis,
Quoted 6 lines
Andrew, I think this is a rare (on lkml at least) case when guy does not want to participate in development in a Linux way but wants to just pay for development instead:
"I want this <hardware> to work good under Linux. I want to pay up to <sum> to whoever will agree to do that. Anybody?"
Well, yes. I want my hardware to work properly. And, given amount of problems with my current setup and _knowing_ how much time it will take for me to debug them by myself , I'm deciding that in the end run it will be faster and more efficent to pay relevant people to fix bugs in subsystems they write/maintain than to participate in (sometimes) never ending bugfix mode.
Quoted 5 lines
Do not dismiss him lightly. There are LOTS of people which aren't hackish at all. An order of magniture more than 'us' computer geeks. M$ is successful because it uses this resource.
We may want to think how can we use it too.
Well. Regarding myself, your assumptions are totally wrong.
My Linux experience started in 1995, as an admin/coder, and since 2000 I'm Linux-only almost 100% And up to some point I was fixing bugs that were critical for me in kernels I was using. But now, given amount of other tasks before me (my regular daily/nightly job) , to spend a few weeks to understand why my WiFi starts to drop packets after resume is more than I could afford.
Signature · 1 line
Managing your Territory since the dawn of times ...
Hi, Andrew,
Quoted 7 lines · Andrew Morton
A quick grep indicates that you reported zero bugs to this mailing list in 2005.
Please preapre quality bug reports (preferably in less-than-80-column emails) and direct them to the relevant maintainers and be prepared to work with those maintainers in the resolution of the bugs.
Bug #1188 . See for yourself about quality of reported data, relevant maintainers and my prepareness to work with them to resolve. (P.S. Two fscking years.)
Signature · 1 line
Managing your Territory since the dawn of times ...
Quoted 2 lines · Yaroslav Rastrigin
Bug #1188 . See for yourself about quality of reported data, relevant maintainers and my prepareness to work with them to resolve. (
P.S. Two fscking years.)
I see 44 comentaries there. It's not that people haven't tried to help you (several of them don't get any money for helping to fix stuff). In fact they've been following the bug for two years, which proves how good bugzilla maintainers the intel acpi guys are. You've indeed helped people to debug the problem, but there're some bugs that just are hard to fix (and hardware manufacturers not collaborating to make their hardware work in linux doesn't makes it easier).
Quoted 3 lines · Boxer Gnome
and the dos ntfs driver was not released by the MS offical.So,what' wrong?
Somebody who can explain this ?
The NTFS vendor is identical to the DOS vendor. Therefore it has access to current, correct and complete documentation and can control and test changes on dedicated test systems before bugs hits users seriously. In case of filesystems (like here), "hitting the user seriously" means "loosing the whole filesystem. Go and look for a recent backup.".
Bernd
Signature · 3 lines
Firmix Software GmbH http://www.firmix.at/
mobil: +43 664 4416156 fax: +43 1 7890849-55
Embedded Linux Development and Services