Results of an informal GPLv3 poll amongst kernel contributors
These are basically just the votes and who voted. There's also a nice graphical tally but I'll attach that by replying to this message so it doesn't get eaten by people's "no mime at all" spam filters.
James
-------------------------------------
Vote key:
I wouldn't want to use v3 (I really dislike it, or my company would have serious problems allowing me
-3 to participate using the v3 draft)
-2 I think v3 is much worse than v2
-1 I think v2 is better, but I don't care that deeply
0 I don't really care at all
1 I think v3 is better, but I don't care that deeply
2 I think v3 is much better than v2
I wouldn't want to use v2 (I really dislike it, or my company would have serious problems allowing me
3 to participate using the GPLv2)
These votes are opinions of the persons listed in their capacities as kernel maintainers only. In no regard should any opinion expressed herein be construed to represent the views of any entities employing or being associated with any of the authors.
Name Vote ==== ==== Linus Torvalds -2.5 Alan Cox -2.0 James Bottomley -3.0 Ingo Molnar -1.0 Tony Luck -2.0 Neil Brown -1.0 Al Viro -2.0 Jeff Garzik -2.0 Mauro Carvalho Chehab -2.0 Arjan van de Ven -3.0 David Woodhouse -2.0 Greg Kroah Hartman -3.0 Ralf Baechle -1.5 Stephen Hemminger -2.0 Andrew Morton -3.0 Dmitry Torokhov -2.0 Tejun Heo -2.0 Thomas Gleixner -3.0 Takashi Iwai -2.0 Trond Myklebust -2.5 Roland Dreier -2.0 Dave Jones -2.0 Russell King -2.0 John W. Linville -2.0 Andi Kleen -2.0 Patrick McHardy -1.0
David S. Miller 0.0
Christoph Hellwig -2.0
Paul Mackerras -1.0
Total Votes Cast 29
Average Vote -2.0 +/- 0.7
Lowest Vote -3.0
Highest Vote 0.0
Median Vote -2.0
Quoted 3 lines · James Bottomley
These are basically just the votes and who voted. There's also a nice graphical tally but I'll attach that by replying to this message so it doesn't get eaten by people's "no mime at all" spam filters.
And here's the nice graphic.
James
Quoted 6 lines
These are basically just the votes and who voted. There's also a nice graphical tally but I'll attach that by replying to this message so it doesn't get eaten by people's "no mime at all" spam filters.
Average Vote -2.0 +/- 0.7
No surprise here :)
Jan Engelhardt
Quoted 9 lines · Jan Engelhardt
Quoted 7 lines
These are basically just the votes and who voted. There's also a nice graphical tally but I'll attach that by replying to this message so it doesn't get eaten by people's "no mime at all" spam filters.
Average Vote -2.0 +/- 0.7
No surprise here :)
Well, I actually think there were some surprises to some people.
The people involved with the vote were basically selected to be the most active kernel developers (by just doing some trivial statistics over the last 18 months and just picking the top ~30 people). I added Alan Cox to the list, just because, but basically it's otherwise a totally unbiased selection.
And trust me when I say that we're an argumentative lot. Some people consider the kernel mailing list to be somewhat argumentative at times, but I think people are even more open in their opinions when they're allowed to vent freely.
And we certainly had some "heated discussion" over a number of details, but as you can see from the actual votes, I think the conclusion people had come to (regardless of their opinions on some issues) were more uniform than you might have expected.
I think a number of outsiders also believed that I personally was just the odd man out, because I've been so publicly not a huge fan of the GPLv3.
So I think some people who see the results - especially people who haven't been active in kernel development themselves - might be surprised to see that I wasn't even an outlier in the kernel group.
So I suspect your lack of surprise is because you've been on the kernel mailing list for too long, and already know the personalities of the people involved.
Linus