Postgrey experiment at VGER
Hello,
I am running an experiment with Postgrey to delay (for 300 seconds
minimum) incoming emails. If the clients don't retry after this
delay, then the messages don't usually get in.
The "postgrey" in question is the very same thing that exists for the Postfix MTA with various automatic whitelistings of repeatedly successfull senders, etc.
I do already see spammers smart enough to retry addresses from the zombie machine, but that share is now below 10% of all emails. My prediction for next 200 days is that most spammers get the clue, but it gives us perhaps 3 months of less leaked junk.
/Matti Aarnio -- one of <postmaster at vger.kernel.org>
Quoted 4 lines · Matti Aarnio
I do already see spammers smart enough to retry addresses from the zombie machine, but that share is now below 10% of all emails. My prediction for next 200 days is that most spammers get the clue, but it gives us perhaps 3 months of less leaked junk.
IMHO this is only an step in an "arms race".
What you will do in three months, remove this check because it will prove useless since the spammers will also retry ? If yes, why install it in the first place ?
Signature · 4 lines
Cioby Opinions expressed do not belong to any company. I'm not sure they belong to me either.
Quoted 10 lines · Dumitru Ciobarcianu
Quoted 4 lines · Matti Aarnio
I do already see spammers smart enough to retry addresses from the zombie machine, but that share is now below 10% of all emails. My prediction for next 200 days is that most spammers get the clue, but it gives us perhaps 3 months of less leaked junk.
IMHO this is only an step in an "arms race".
What you will do in three months, remove this check because it will prove useless since the spammers will also retry ? If yes, why install it in the first place ?
Why ever do anything? You're going to die eventually anyway...
Trond
Quoted 6 lines · Dumitru Ciobarcianu
Quoted 4 lines · Matti Aarnio
I do already see spammers smart enough to retry addresses from the zombie machine, but that share is now below 10% of all emails. My prediction for next 200 days is that most spammers get the clue, but it gives us perhaps 3 months of less leaked junk.
Quoted 6 lines
IMHO this is only an step in an "arms race".
What you will do in three months, remove this check because it will prove useless since the spammers will also retry ? If yes, why install it in the first place ?
spammers are already re-trying; but they give up after 10 minutes. As the delay time increases, the chances of getting on a blacklist increase, which makes it easier to identify a machine as a spamming bot.
I normally let my greyfilters run at 30 minutes deny, and 72hrs of lease time on a IP/To/From tuplet. This setting seams to be pretty effective in dropping spam; at one point, upto 10k spam vs. a couple hundred ham messages.
thomsa
In article <[email protected]>,
Quoted 3 lines · Matti Aarnio
I am running an experiment with Postgrey to delay (for 300 seconds
minimum) incoming emails. If the clients don't retry after this
delay, then the messages don't usually get in.
So far it is working very well. Usually I have quite a few spams to delete from my archives during the day. Today I've had zero.