Interrupt routing broken on TiBook IV with 2.6.21.x ?
Hi all,
With the availability of the stable 2.6.21.x kernels I recently started to move over from OSS to ALSA for audio I/O. Along with that move came the surprise that not the simplest audio output works anymore (actually, this was the case with the stable 2.6.20.x kernels and OSS already which I therefore opted to avoid).
The problem I ran into is that no matter which application (speaker-test, aplay, xmms, gxine) using either the native ALSA API or via the OSS compatibility layer, none of these is able to sustain audio output for more than 7 seconds. In fact, most attempts max out at statistically one second (with many even shorter than that). After the signal at the output jack died, the application appears to be blocking forever (it does not spin) with no signs of ending its output.
I initially presented this problem on [email protected] where someone suggested that it might actually be caused by (broken) interrupt routing for the built-in audio device. This assumption may be supported by the observation that once the sound previously produced by the application (speaker-test in the simplest case) stopped being sent through the output jack, no increase in the interrupt counter occurs.
An example output of /proc/interrupts on my machine looks like this (why eth0 does not show up in this listing is beyond me):
CPU0
19: 39005 MPIC 1 Level ide0 20: 34 MPIC 1 Level ide1 25: 151785 MPIC 1 Level VIA-PMU 26: 131 MPIC 1 Level keywest i2c 27: 1 MPIC 1 Level ohci_hcd:usb1 28: 1 MPIC 1 Level ohci_hcd:usb2 30: 197 MPIC 1 Edge PMac Output 31: 1 MPIC 1 Edge PMac Input 40: 2 MPIC 1 Level ohci1394 42: 0 MPIC 1 Level keywest i2c 47: 7682 MPIC 1 Level GPIO1 ADB 48: 39571 MPIC 1 Level radeon@pci:0000:00:10.0 57: 0 MPIC 1 Level eth1 58: 1 MPIC 1 Level yenta 61: 1 MPIC 1 Edge Sound Headphone Detection
BAD: 0
Has anyone any idea what causes the audio output to die prematurely ?
Cheers,
Christian
Quoted 2 lines
Has anyone any idea what causes the audio output to die prematurely ?
Nope... it can't be a routing problem since interrupt -is- routed (you are getting it !) unless I missed some subtle breakage in the device-tree.
Which exact tipb model is this ? (cat /proc/device-tree/model)
Cheers,
Ben.
Quoted 2 lines · Benjamin Herrenschmidt
Nope... it can't be a routing problem since interrupt -is- routed (you are getting it !)
Actually, these were the exact words from the ALSA developer. For some
reason, however, the interrupt count does not increase after some (variable)
time. It looks as if the ALSA code waits for but not receiving them. After
a restart, an audio signal does leave the jack and the interrupt count
increases but only for about a second (sometimes more, often less). No idea whether interrupts must be routed/are routable on this very machine I have at all ...
Quoted 1 line
Which exact tipb model is this ? (cat
/proc/device-tree/model)
PowerBook3,5 of the 2002-11 release variety.
I stuck to OSS up to the 2.6.19.x kernels where everything (surprisingly) ``just worked''. Then came the 2.6.20.x series and <root>/sound/oss/\dmasound/dmasound_awacs.c started spitting out loads of ``tx-irq: xfer died - patching it up...'' messages with stuttering audio output but nothing different in their respective implementations from 2.6.19.x to 2.6.20.x.
Is there anything particular I can dive into myself to expedite finding the cause of the problem without learning the full details of the PPC implemen- tation ?
Cheers,
Christian
Quoted 5 lines · Christian Böhme
Quoted 2 lines · Benjamin Herrenschmidt
Nope... it can't be a routing problem since interrupt -is- routed (you are getting it !)
Quoted 7 lines
Actually, these were the exact words from the ALSA developer. For some reason, however, the interrupt count does not increase after some (variable) time. It looks as if the ALSA code waits for but not receiving them. After a restart, an audio signal does leave the jack and the interrupt count increases but only for about a second (sometimes more, often less). No idea whether interrupts must be routed/are routable on this very machine I have at all ...
Or it could be the DMA channel going dead though I fail to see why it would just start doing that now.
Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 1 line
Which exact tipb model is this ? (cat
/proc/device-tree/model)PowerBook3,5 of the 2002-11 release variety.
Ok, I think I have access to one of these, I'll try to reproduce myself.
Quoted 9 lines
I stuck to OSS up to the 2.6.19.x kernels where everything (surprisingly) ``just worked''. Then came the 2.6.20.x series and <root>/sound/oss/\
dmasound/dmasound_awacs.cstarted spitting out loads of ``tx-irq: xfer died - patching it up...'' messages with stuttering audio output but nothing different in their respective implementations from 2.6.19.x to 2.6.20.x.Is there anything particular I can dive into myself to expedite finding the cause of the problem without learning the full details of the PPC implemen- tation ?
Not sure where to start :-) I'll first see if I can reproduce.
Cheers,
Ben.
Quoted 2 lines · Benjamin Herrenschmidt
Or it could be the DMA channel going dead though I fail to see why it would just start doing that now.
...
Quoted 1 line
Not sure where to start :-) I'll first see if I can reproduce.
It's not that I am not interested nor completely new to this, it's just that I am currently a little short on time for things like these. The last time I checked, the Linux people have just started to make use of DMA maps, a concept that other OS/architecture combos employed for years already. Is that what is used in the TiBooks to allocate DMA channels ?
Cheers,
Christian
Quoted 5 lines · Christian Böhme
It's not that I am not interested nor completely new to this, it's just that I am currently a little short on time for things like these. The last time I checked, the Linux people have just started to make use of DMA maps, a concept that other OS/architecture combos employed for years already. Is that what is used in the TiBooks to allocate DMA channels ?
I'm not sure what you are talking about here. DMA mapping has existed in linux for years.
Ben.
Quoted 2 lines · Benjamin Herrenschmidt
I'm not sure what you are talking about here. DMA mapping has existed in linux for years.
I do admit that it's been a while since that last look ;) The topic came up when discussing PCI and bus systems in general with micro/real-time kernel people whom I assumed to be experts in this since they had Linux kernels running on top of their scheduling scheme. As it turned out, using an abstraction such as a DMA map was a totally new concept to them. They even questioned the usefulness of such an approach.
Cheers,
Christian