thoughts on checkpointing /proc/mounts
Christoph's suggestion that we go add f_ops individually is a really good way to get people thinking about individual cases that we have to deal with.
Can we checkpoint an *open* /proc/mounts? I don't think we want to. It could get really nasty really fast. But, what if the f_pos is 0? That makes it a lot easier.
If the "may checkpoint" flag is per-container (as Alexey has said) and one-way (as Ingo has said), does a single 'cat /proc/mounts' 5 days ago keep a container from being checkpointed today?
I just don't think the container-wide flag works if it is one way.
I think making it per-process or per-resource (so it can be more easily tracked at fork()/clone()/exec()) is the only way to go. It makes it so simple since only the 'cat /proc/mounts' process becomes uncheckpointable. Once it exits, we are OK and can checkpoint again. That all seems right to me.
-- Dave
Quoted 14 lines · Dave Hansen
Christoph's suggestion that we go add
f_opsindividually is a really good way to get people thinking about individual cases that we have to deal with.Can we checkpoint an *open*
/proc/mounts? I don't think we want to. It could get really nasty really fast. But, what if thef_posis 0? That makes it a lot easier.If the "may checkpoint" flag is per-container (as Alexey has said) and one-way (as Ingo has said), does a single 'cat
/proc/mounts' 5 days ago keep a container from being checkpointed today?I just don't think the container-wide flag works if it is one way.
Quoted 7 lines
I think making it per-process or per-resource (so it can be more easily tracked at fork()/clone()/exec()) is the only way to go. It makes it so simple since only the 'cat
/proc/mounts' process becomes uncheckpointable. Once it exits, we are OK and can checkpoint again. That all seems right to me.-- Dave
Well one way to look at it:
the files_struct may_checkpoint is the short-term big stick to put pressure on us to fix things that are fixable.
the per-file ->checkpoint() will (I guess) always be able to return an error. So for now an open /proc/mounts fd will irreversibly make the process non-checkpointable. But eventually the files_struct may_checkpoint flag will go away, and we'll just let each fd decide at checkpoint time whether it's ok to checkpoint.
-serge