query regarding 'map_user_kiobuf'
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Quoted 24 lines · in fa.linux.kernel you
Quoted 11 lines · [email protected] said:
After using the '
map_user_kiobuf', I observed the followiing:1. 'kiobuf->maplist[0]->virtual' contains a different virtual address than the user space buffer address
2. But these two addresses are mapped as when i write something using the address 'kiobuf->maplist[0]->virtual' inside the kernel, I see the same data in the user space buffer in my application.
3. I use the 'virt_to_phys' operation to the virtual address 'kiobuf->maplist[0]->virtual' to get the physical address.
4. I use this physical address for DMA operations.Quoted 6 lines
Now, using this information I do a DMA from card to system memory. What I have noticed is that DMA happens somewhere else in the system memory. I am not able to execute most of the commands (ls, chmod, cat, clear etc) after my user program exits.
Am I doing the steps 3 and 4 above right?
After calling
map_user_kiobuf(), I believe you should be locking the pages in memory by callinglock_kiovec(). Otherwise, nothing prevents them from being paged out again.
Quoted 7 lines
Also, the pages may be in high memory and not directly accessible. You should use
kmap()before touching them from the kernel rather than just usingpage->virtual, and obviouslykunmap()afterwards.The PCI DMA interface is more complex than simply using
virt_to_phys()too, if you want to deal correctly with the highmem case. I'm sure others will give you the details or pointers to the documentation.
David,
I have a couple of user DMA drivers up and running, but in light of your comment, I am not so sure.
I see the following w/map_user_kiobuf() in memory.c (2.4.4)
...
/*
* Force in an entire range of pages from the current process's user VA,
* and pin them in physical memory.
*/
#define dprintk(x...)
int map_user_kiobuf(int rw, struct kiobuf *iobuf, unsigned long va, size_t
len)
...
What is the difference between pinning and locking? I had the impression that locking had more to do with ownership.
Thanks,
Bill
---------------------------------------
Bill Waddington
Bainbridge Island, WA, USA
[email protected]
[email protected]
---------------------------------------
Quoted 2 lines · [email protected] said:
I have a couple of user DMA drivers up and running, but in light of
your comment, I am not so sure.
I'm sorry, it seems I lied. Although map_user_kiobuf in 2.2 used to lock the pages, apparently that's no longer necessary. You just need to make sure they're marked dirty before you unmap the kiobuf.
--
dwmw2