Skip to contentSkip to conversation

libsoup license

DISCUSSION Sander Visser 3 participants 4 messages Sep 11, 2015 – Sep 18, 2015

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi

Does anyone know why the license is marked LGPL2 and not LGPL2+ in libsoup-2.4_2.50.0.bb? It seems "or (at your option) any later version" is allowed via for example libsoup/soup-requester.h.

Nowhere could I see that the "or (at your option) any later version" is missing.

/Regards Sander

#1 lore raw

Hi all,

[CC'ing Dan Winship, the libsoup maintainer]

Quoted 7 lines · Sander Visser

Does anyone know why the license is marked LGPL2 and not LGPL2+ in libsoup-2.4_2.50.0.bb? It seems "or (at your option) any later version" is allowed via for example libsoup/soup-requester.h.

Nowhere could I see that the "or (at your option) any later version" is missing.

To be honest libsoup isn't very clear - the COPYING is the standard LGPL boilerplate, the README just says "LGPL", and very few source files specify the license at all.

Dan: exactly what license is libsoup under? LGPL v2 precisely, or LGPL v2 or greater?

Thanks,
Ross

#2 lore raw
Quoted 1 line · Ross

To be honest libsoup isn't very clear

...

Quoted 2 lines

Dan: exactly what license is libsoup under? LGPL v2 precisely, or LGPL v2 or greater?

I don't know either. :-)

It was initially written at a time when Ximian was explicitly using the "v2 only" license on evolution (because reasons), so it's possible that libsoup was intended to be v2 only, since it was more-or-less part of evolution. But then, Novell relicensed evolution to v2+ later on, so presumably, if libsoup actually was v2-only at that point (which it may not have been), then surely Novell *intended* to also make libsoup v2+, despite not having said so. So... "maybe it used to be v2+" + "probably it was intended to have been changed to v2+ later if it wasn't already" + "certainly everything written since 2007 was intended to be v2+" == "probably definitely it's v2+ now" ? That's totally how the law works, right?

-- Dan

#3 lore raw
Quoted 12 lines · Dan Winship

It was initially written at a time when Ximian was explicitly using the "v2 only" license on evolution (because reasons), so it's possible that libsoup was intended to be v2 only, since it was more-or-less part of evolution. But then, Novell relicensed evolution to v2+ later on, so presumably, if libsoup actually was v2-only at that point (which it may not have been), then surely Novell *intended* to also make libsoup v2+, despite not having said so. So... "maybe it used to be v2+" + "probably it was intended to have been changed to v2+ later if it wasn't already" + "certainly everything written since 2007 was intended to be v2+" == "probably definitely it's v2+ now" ? That's totally how the law works, right?

Thanks for the reply Dan, and yes that's totally how the law works. Maybe you should clarify this somewhere, or do you prefer the ambiguity?

Sander, a patch to make libsoup LGPLv2+ would be accepted by me on this basis.

Ross