Skip to contentSkip to conversation

performance computing review of a180

parisc-linux Justin Maurer 4 participants 4 messages May 13, 1999 – May 17, 1999

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

by popular request, here are some key bits from the review of the a180 in this month's _unix's review's performance computing_:

(the machine as test was priced at $16,568. it had one cpu (lc), 1gb ram, two 4gb drives, and hp-ux 11.0)

(the article begins discussing racks and space issues, etc.)

"most recent non-intel servers have 64-bit cpus, but the core of the a-class is hp's pa-7300, a 32-bit processor. this may seem a bit retro, but there is little about internet services that actually benefits from 64-bit processor"

"one of the more interesting design deatures of the a-class is its integration of hp's secure web console." (a lengthy discussion of the swc/rs-232/ethernet, etc.)

"the only printed documentation that ships with the a-class is a small booklet showing basic cable connections and outlining the customary safety and regulatory statements. all other documentation is either part of the installed hp-ux os (for example, online manual pages...additionally, the hp instant information cd-rom, a collection of documentation is available as a $300 option. thus, to install the a-class, it is cubersome (though necessary) to have another system on hand to various documentation web sites."

the article then talks about hp-ux and the bundled software. it is more a feature list than an opinion/review bit, so i'll leave it out.

finally, the last thing before the closing comments is a bit on performance:
"...the 180-mhz a-class also produces spec scores lower than the 400mhz pentium ii xeon processor, which is fairly common in intel-based servers. interestingly, hp has chosen not to publish, at least at press time, benchmark results for the a-class for the specweb96 benchmark, which would be an obvious choice for a web-specific system design...." its spec scores are then compared to several other 64-bit systems..

"...for example, the system memory is comparatively expensive, evidenced by the price of the system we tested. thus, while the a-class hits the design mark for high-density rackmount servers (20 in a two-meter rack), more-robust configurations are pricey. as a result, design gets a two-flag rating on our scale--average."

"...expansion is not a big issue...the version of bind should have been upgraded to bind 8, and not including sendmail 8.9 we feel is a mistake...performance is not a primary objective for hp with the a-class.."

in short, they give it "poor" on installation and documentation, "average" on design, expandibility, performance, and *overall*, and "good" on operation. they basically give it a few nice compliments, then rag on the same things and more. more towards the negative side, overall.

Signature · 6 lines
-------------------------------------------------------------
# Justin Maurer                                GNOME Hacker #
# [email protected]                         Slashdot Author #
# http://slashdot.org/           Debian GNU/Linux Developer #
#     09 84 FC 03 13 AA 4A AF  F6 A4 85 9D 8C 96 B6 A4      #
-------------------------------------------------------------
#1 lore raw
Quoted 2 lines

by popular request, here are some key bits from the review of the a180 in this month's _unix's review's performance computing_:

I think there are some bits there that are interesting.

Quoted 2 lines

(the machine as test was priced at $16,568. it had one cpu (lc), 1gb ram, two 4gb drives, and hp-ux 11.0)

1 GB RAM sounds a bit much if you later whine about the RAM being too expensive. Furthermore, they seem to have enough money to buy 1 GB of RAM, but not enough to buy the A180C version, which scores at 130% of the A180 in SPECweb96 (650 vs 500) according to HP's docs.

Quoted 3 lines

"most recent non-intel servers have 64-bit cpus, but the core of the a-class is hp's pa-7300, a 32-bit processor. this may seem a bit retro, but there is little about internet services that actually benefits from 64-bit processor"

What is a bit retro about the 7300LC, according to HP's website, is it is manufactured in 0.50 um-process. This could be the reason for it being clocked comparably low at 180 MHz.

Quoted 7 lines

"the only printed documentation that ships with the a-class is a small booklet showing basic cable connections and outlining the customary safety and regulatory statements. all other documentation is either part of the installed hp-ux os (for example, online manual pages...additionally, the hp instant information cd-rom, a collection of documentation is available as a $300 option. thus, to install the a-class, it is cubersome (though necessary) to have another system on hand to various documentation web sites."

This attitude, if it is more common, could make Linux on the A180 a lot more popular. Linux is fairly standardized, you can get most Documentation as hardcopy or read it on an x86 box etc.

Quoted 7 lines

finally, the last thing before the closing comments is a bit on performance:
"...the 180-mhz a-class also produces spec scores lower than the 400mhz pentium ii xeon processor, which is fairly common in intel-based servers. interestingly, hp has chosen not to publish, at least at press time, benchmark results for the a-class for the specweb96 benchmark, which would be an obvious choice for a web-specific system design...." its spec scores are then compared to several other 64-bit systems..

I don't know if the information HP gave us was publically available before, but it gives SPECweb96 results.

Quoted 9 lines

"...for example, the system memory is comparatively expensive, evidenced by the price of the system we tested. thus, while the a-class hits the design mark for high-density rackmount servers (20 in a two-meter rack), more-robust configurations are pricey. as a result, design gets a two-flag rating on our scale--average."

"...expansion is not a big issue...the version of bind should have been upgraded to bind 8, and not including sendmail 8.9 we feel is a mistake...performance is not a primary objective for hp with the a-class.."

This should be no problem with Linux.

Quoted 4 lines

in short, they give it "poor" on installation and documentation, "average" on design, expandibility, performance, and *overall*, and "good" on operation. they basically give it a few nice compliments, then rag on the same things and more. more towards the negative side, overall.

sounds as there seems to be interest in Linux on the A180.

#2 lore raw

Am 14.05.1999 um 07:39:13 +0000 schrieb Philipp Rumpf folgendes:

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines

"...expansion is not a big issue...the version of bind should have been upgraded to bind 8, and not including sendmail 8.9 we feel is a mistake...performance is not a primary objective for hp with the a-class.."

This should be no problem with Linux.

Neither with 10.x or 11.x, BTW

Signature · 3 lines
Ralf Hildebrandt <[email protected]> www.stahl.bau.tu-bs.de/~hildeb
Applying computer technology is simply finding the right wrench to
pound in the correct screw. 
#3 lore raw
In reply to Philipp Rumpf
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines

hp-ux os (for example, online manual pages...additionally, the hp instant information cd-rom, a collection of documentation is available as a $300 option. thus, to install the a-class, it is cubersome (though necessary) to have another system on hand to various documentation web sites."

This attitude, if it is more common, could make Linux on the A180 a lot more popular. Linux is fairly standardized, you can get most Documentation as hardcopy or read it on an x86 box etc.

Most of the instant information cdrom is online at www.docs.hp.com.

Rich