Skip to contentSkip to conversation

XOR [ was: Linux stifles innovation.]

DISCUSSION [email protected] 4 participants 9 messages Feb 18, 2001 – Feb 19, 2001

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw
Quoted 2 lines · Dan Hollis

Did you ignore it or did you pay up?
FWIW I recall there was prior art dating back to 1974 at the very least...

Here is editing version of some correspondence that answers your question.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line

US Patent #4,197,590 held by NuGraphics, Inc.

Quoted 3 lines · David Relson

The patent was for using the technique of using XOR for dragging/moving parts of a graphics image without erasing other parts. Also, since the patent was granted in 1980, the inventors have had their 17 years of

Quoted 4 lines · Brian Litzinger
Quoted 4 lines

In 1984 I received a demand letter for $10,000 from a company, representing itself as the owner of the patent discuss above, as a unlimited license for use of the patent and another patent. At the time I ran a company that made graphics cards for IBM PCs.

Quoted 1 line · David Relson

Ouch! What did you do?

While I was President, the company was large enough that I can't be certain of the details.

I do recall that I railed against the company. I had actually met the people at the company making the demand some years earlier. I went on and on about the same things you see today about patents and copyrights.

Our graphics platform had support for both XOR and save under cursors.

I believe we did the following:

made 'save under cursor' the default

argued that since NEC made the graphics chips (7220A), which included
the XOR function, that NEC rightly was the target of their demands, and that we would be a licensee as a part of having paid for the chip which included the technology.

The other patent that was represented that they held had to do with the movement of bits from a memory storage device to an memory device that was mapped to a display.

We argued mountains of prior art

My instructions where that we were not to pay. We might have paid though. Not only might someone in the legal department have authorized the payment, but someone within the company was embezzling money at the time, so they might have sneaked out $10K under the guise of paying the demand.

About a year later I was talking with a group of business owners who had also received a similar demand letter. Some paid, some didn't. Those who didn't pay were not pursued other than the occasional copy of the demand letter.

Since that time, about 1986, I learned that there is a whole cottage industry of going through old, but not too old, patents and seeing how they can be misconstrued to apply to current technology, buying the patent for cheap, and then threatening "infringers". More or less an extortion racket. Generally the license fee demanded is low enough
that is more cost effective, in the short term, to pay. And with
shareholder lawsuits the way they are, short term thinking is the only thinking shareholders accept, and the extortionists know it.

Signature · 10 lines
Brian Litzinger <[email protected]>

    Copyright (c) 2000 By Brian Litzinger, All Rights Reserved

----- End forwarded message -----

-- 
Brian Litzinger <[email protected]>

    Copyright (c) 2000 By Brian Litzinger, All Rights Reserved
#1 lore raw
Quoted 4 lines · On Sun, 18 Feb 2001 [email protected] wrote:

About a year later I was talking with a group of business owners who had also received a similar demand letter. Some paid, some didn't. Those who didn't pay were not pursued other than the occasional copy of the demand letter.

Probably they did not pursue because they knew their patent was invalid, and if they did fight they would probably be found guilty of bad faith patent enforcement - treble damages, the whole bit. And maybe criminal fraud, if they had collected enough money under the bad patent.

The XOR patent and the fraudulent enforcement of it is the purest embodiment of everything that is wrong with the patent system and IP law.

Quoted 5 lines

Since that time, about 1986, I learned that there is a whole cottage industry of going through old, but not too old, patents and seeing how they can be misconstrued to apply to current technology, buying the patent for cheap, and then threatening "infringers". More or less an extortion racket.

RICO statutes anyone?

-Dan

#2 lore raw
In reply to [email protected]
| Since that time, about 1986, I learned that there is a whole cottage
| industry of going through old, but not too old, patents and seeing how
| they can be misconstrued to apply to current technology, buying the
| patent for cheap, and then threatening "infringers".  More or less
| an extortion racket.  Generally the license fee demanded is low enough
| that is more cost effective, in the short term, to pay.   And with
| shareholder lawsuits the way they are, short term thinking
| is the only thinking shareholders accept, and the extortionists
| know it.

Those of them that didn't end up in jail went on to form RAMBUS in the 90s.

#3 lore raw
In reply to [email protected]
| Since that time, about 1986, I learned that there is a whole cottage
| industry of going through old, but not too old, patents and seeing how
| they can be misconstrued to apply to current technology, buying the
| patent for cheap, and then threatening "infringers".  More or less
| an extortion racket.  Generally the license fee demanded is low enough
| that is more cost effective, in the short term, to pay.   And with
| shareholder lawsuits the way they are, short term thinking
| is the only thinking shareholders accept, and the extortionists
| know it.

Those of them that didn't end up in jail went on to form RAMBUS in the 90s.

#4 lore raw

Re: Money stifles innovation [was: Linux stifles innovation.]

In reply to [email protected]
Quoted 6 lines · On Sun, 18 Feb 2001 [email protected] wrote:
Quoted 4 lines

About a year later I was talking with a group of business owners who had also received a similar demand letter. Some paid, some didn't. Those who didn't pay were not pursued other than the occasional copy of the demand letter.

Quoted 2 lines · Dan Hollis

The XOR patent and the fraudulent enforcement of it is the purest embodiment of everything that is wrong with the patent system and IP law.

As a person with a some decades of experience with patents and trademarks, and playing among the various sides, I can state quite unequivocally that the problem is money.

Courts, or rights, can simply be bought with enough money. And not necessarily in the way you would think.

Here is a recent and true example:

I owned the domain DemandTV.com, and had applied for a trademark.

DirecTV, or DirectV, the satellite people, and subsidiary of Hughes Aerospace, contested my trademark application calling it 'confusingly similar'.

Of course its not confusing similar as trademarks go. They started by subpoena'ing anyone that could find related to the trademark. Hours and hours of questions over multiple days.

My own lawyers, a well respected big name law firm, said they really had no standing whatsoever and for a measly 1/2 million dollars we'd get the trademark through the PTO process.

However, that is not the end. Even though the PTO would have blessed our trademark of DemandTV, it would still be up to District Courts as to decide whether we were infringing. And that is individual district courts all over the country. Hughes/DirectV could file basically as much as they want and we would be required to respond.

We could try to sue for injunctive relief, but we would never "win" because we couldn't sustain the hemorrhage'ing of money.

So they problem is that they have money and you don't so they win.

Hughes was able to obtain the outcome they wanted simply because they had more money.

Isn't that the golden rule? "He who has the gold makes the rules."

Signature · 3 lines
Brian Litzinger <[email protected]>

    Copyright (c) 2000 By Brian Litzinger, All Rights Reserved
#5 lore raw

Re: Money stifles innovation [was: Linux stifles innovation.]

Quoted 6 lines · On Sun, 18 Feb 2001 [email protected] wrote:
Quoted 2 lines · Dan Hollis

The XOR patent and the fraudulent enforcement of it is the purest embodiment of everything that is wrong with the patent system and IP law.

As a person with a some decades of experience with patents and trademarks, and playing among the various sides, I can state quite unequivocally that the problem is money.

Actually the problem is lack of morals and bad people who are really evil at the core (you wouldnt want them for your neighbor).

-Dan

#6 lore raw

Re: Money stifles innovation [was: Linux stifles innovation.]

In reply to [email protected]
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines · Dan Hollis
Quoted 2 lines

The XOR patent and the fraudulent enforcement of it is the purest embodiment of everything that is wrong with the patent system and IP law.

Quoted 3 lines · On Sun, 18 Feb 2001 [email protected] wrote:

As a person with a some decades of experience with patents and trademarks, and playing among the various sides, I can state quite unequivocally that the problem is money.

Quoted 2 lines · Dan Hollis

Actually the problem is lack of morals and bad people who are really evil at the core (you wouldnt want them for your neighbor).

Many have heard the saying 'money is the root of all evil'.

The quote is in fact 'the pursuit of money is the root of all evil'.

Thanks go to Dan Hollis for reminding me of this.

Signature · 3 lines
Brian Litzinger <[email protected]>

    Copyright (c) 2000 By Brian Litzinger, All Rights Reserved
#7 lore raw

[OT] Re: Money stifles innovation

In reply to [email protected]
Quoted 10 lines · Dan Hollis
Quoted 6 lines · On Sun, 18 Feb 2001 [email protected] wrote:
Quoted 2 lines · Dan Hollis

The XOR patent and the fraudulent enforcement of it is the purest embodiment of everything that is wrong with the patent system and IP law.

As a person with a some decades of experience with patents and trademarks, and playing among the various sides, I can state quite unequivocally that the problem is money.

Actually the problem is lack of morals and bad people who are really evil at the core (you wouldnt want them for your neighbor).

Actually, it's because we've made it illegal to corporations to behave ethically when it conflicts with short-term shareholder profits.

http://www.ratical.com/corporations/

It would be nice if it were so simple as to declare the involved parties as evil.

#8 lore raw

Re: [OT] Re: Money stifles innovation

Quoted 8 lines · Gregory Maxwell
Quoted 2 lines · Dan Hollis

Actually the problem is lack of morals and bad people who are really evil at the core (you wouldnt want them for your neighbor).

Actually, it's because we've made it illegal to corporations to behave ethically when it conflicts with short-term shareholder profits.
http://www.ratical.com/corporations/
It would be nice if it were so simple as to declare the involved parties as evil.

I know both good and bad people at corporations. The bad people were mean and nasty before they joined the corporation, the corporation became a vehicle for them to abuse others and directly translated to the misbehaviour of that corporation. Doing bad things comes naturally to them.

The good people went out of their way to prevent the corporation from doing evil things, or left the corporation so they would not be party to the unethical behaviour.

-Dan