/proc/meminfo swap counter wraparound in 2.2
Hi there
Having put 8Gb of swap on one of our production database servers[1], I found that "top", "free" et al report the amount of available swap space incorrectly.
This is because they all parse /proc/meminfo, and its counters seem to wrap when they encounter very high numbers. The relevant bit is the totalswap member of "struct sysinfo"
sean@lisa:~$ cat /proc/swaps Filename Type Size Used Priority /dev/rd/c0d2p1 partition 530104 41436 10 /usr/SWAPFILE1 file 1048568 56 2 /usr/local/SWAPFILE1 file 1048568 52 2 /usr/SWAPFILE2 file 1572856 0 3 /usr/local/SWAPFILE2 file 1572856 0 3 /var/SWAPFILE2 file 1572856 0 3 /home/SWAPFILE2 file 1572856 0 -6
sean@lisa:~$ cat /proc/meminfo
total: used: free: shared: buffers: cached:
Mem: 4125683712 2820616192 1305067520 0 82919424 232722432
Swap: 542777344 42541056 500236288
MemTotal: 4028988 kB
MemFree: 1274480 kB
MemShared: 0 kB
Buffers: 80976 kB
Cached: 227268 kB
BigTotal: 3111908 kB
BigFree: 1266988 kB
SwapTotal: 530056 kB
SwapFree: 488512 kBsean@lisa:~$ uname -a Linux lisa.sportingbet.com 2.2.19-6.2.7enterprise #1 SMP Thu Jun 14 07:34:12 EDT 2001 i686 unknown
As you can see, we are running redhat's "enterprise" 2.2.19 kernel.
I would be amazed if this bug were not also in the main 2.2.x tree. Is a fix likely or even possible in 2.2 ?
Sean
[1]One of several changes to avoid random oracle 600 errors under heavy load.
Quoted 2 lines
I would be amazed if this bug were not also in the main 2.2.x tree. Is a fix likely or even possible in 2.2 ?
No fix is planned for 2.2
Quoted 5 lines · Alan Cox
Quoted 2 lines
I would be amazed if this bug were not also in the main 2.2.x tree. Is a fix likely or even possible in 2.2 ?
No fix is planned for 2.2
OK, thanks. I'm a little reluctant to move this box to 2.4 yet (before Monday we had almost a year's uptime out of it- frequent reboots are frowned upon), but looking at the 2.4 source, the relevant bits of fs/proc/array.c and include/linux/kernel.h look exactly the same, so the problem could be there as well.
Am I being dumb?
Sean
Quoted 7 lines · Sean Hunter
Quoted 5 lines · Alan Cox
Quoted 2 lines
I would be amazed if this bug were not also in the main 2.2.x tree. Is a fix likely or even possible in 2.2 ?
No fix is planned for 2.2
Quoted 7 lines
OK, thanks. I'm a little reluctant to move this box to 2.4 yet (before Monday we had almost a year's uptime out of it- frequent reboots are frowned upon), but looking at the 2.4 source, the relevant bits of
fs/proc/array.candinclude/linux/kernel.hlook exactly the same, so the problem could be there as well.Am I being dumb?
Yes, of course I am. Having now Actually Tried It Instead Of Just Talking Bollocks[tm], I can confirm that large amounts of swap space seem to work just fine in 2.4.
Sorry for wasting people's time.
Sean