How errorproof is ext2 fs?
Otto Wyss <[email protected]>:
Quoted 14 lines
While reading the thread about "HFS Plus on Linux?" at "[email protected]" I had the following experience:
Within an hour I had to hard reset both of my computers, first my Linux-i386 due to a complete lockup of the system while using el3diag, second my MacOS-powermac due to an not responding USB-keyboard/-mouse (what a nice coincident). Now while the Mac restarted without any fuse I had to fix the ext2-fs manually for about 15 min. Luckily it seems I haven't lost anything on both system.
This leaves me a bad taste of Linux in my mouth. Does ext2 fs really behave so worse in case of a crash? Okay Linux does not crash that often as MacOS does, so it does not need a good error proof fs. Still can't ext2 be made a little more error proof?
Quoted 4 lines
Okay, there are other fs for Linux which cope better with such a situation, but are they really more errorproof or are they just better in fixing up the mess afterwards? Could there be more attention in not creating errors instead of fixing them afterwards?
I've used linux for about 8 years now. The only time I've had a catastrophic failure was with a disk drive went south.
About the only times I've seen ext2fs require manual repair is a crash/power failure during fsck on boot. It doesn't happen very often. Even then, it may not be a serious falure, just the type of error that requires a choice in fix - missing inode/partially written inode in the root file system will usually require the choice of deleting, or putting in lost+found.
No file system is immune to that level of failure. Some are better at hiding the damage (xfs will lose free data blocks like mad - 3 in a row lost 6GB out of 12, though no used data was (visibly) lost.
15 minutes isn't that bad - wait until you have to spend 30 minutes to 3 hours on an NTFS or FAT32 rebuild, only to find you have to reinstall.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Jesse I Pollard, II
Email: [email protected]
Any opinions expressed are solely my own.