Athlon/K7-Opimisation problems
Hi,
here's my data regarding the K7 optimisation problem.
Until last week I had a 1GHz Athlon with 133MHz FSB. I then bought a 1.4GHz Athlon, again 133MHz FSB.
I never had any problems with the 1GHz processor, but as soon as I stuck the 1.4GHz processor in, the kernel oopsed itself to oblivion. (That was with kernel 2.4.5-ac5, approximately)
I also noticed that the computer booted ok with the Debian bootfloppies, which use a kernel compiled for i386. So after several kernel compile/boot cycles, I found out that I had to disable K7 optimisation to make the system boot again.
The mainboard is a Tyan Trinity KT-A (S2390B) with a VIA KT133A chipset.
After reading here that it may be the PSU, I upgraded my 300W PSU to a 431W Enermax, which made no difference.
The only difference I can make out between the working and the non-working CPU is the internal clockspeed of the CPU and the stepping (old: 2, new: 4).
Appended is the output of /proc/cpuinfo (I sold the old CPU, but the guy who bought it sent me the output).
I really hope this helps someone. If anyone needs any more data, or wants me to test something, contact me.
Yours,
leo
Old CPU:
processor : 0vendor_id : AuthenticAMD
cpu family : 6
model : 4
model name : AMD Athlon(tm) Processor
stepping : 2
cpu MHz : 1012.530
cache size : 256 KBfdiv_bug : nohlt_bug : nosep_bug : nof00f_bug : nocoma_bug : no
fpu : yesfpu_exception : yes
cpuid level : 1
wp : yes
flags : fpu vme de pse tsc msr 6 mce cx8 sep mtrr pge 14 cmov
pat 17 psn mmxext mmx fxsr 3dnowext 3dnow
bogomips : 2018.51
New CPU:
processor : 0vendor_id : AuthenticAMD
cpu family : 6
model : 4
model name : AMD Athlon(tm) Processor
stepping : 4
cpu MHz : 1400.098
cache size : 256 KBfdiv_bug : nohlt_bug : nof00f_bug : nocoma_bug : no
fpu : yesfpu_exception : yes
cpuid level : 1
wp : yes
flags : fpu vme de pse tsc msr pae mce cx8 sep mtrr pge mca cmov pat pse36 mmx fxsr syscall mmxext 3dnowext 3dnow
bogomips : 2791.83
Quoted 10 lines · Carsten Leonhardt
Hi,
here's my data regarding the K7 optimisation problem.
Until last week I had a 1GHz Athlon with 133MHz FSB. I then bought a 1.4GHz Athlon, again 133MHz FSB.
I never had any problems with the 1GHz processor, but as soon as I stuck the 1.4GHz processor in, the kernel oopsed itself to oblivion. (That was with kernel 2.4.5-ac5, approximately)
This is common enough it's becoming absurd.
Quoted 9 lines
I also noticed that the computer booted ok with the Debian bootfloppies, which use a kernel compiled for i386. So after several kernel compile/boot cycles, I found out that I had to disable K7 optimisation to make the system boot again.
The mainboard is a Tyan Trinity KT-A (S2390B) with a VIA KT133A chipset.
Quoted 6 lines
After reading here that it may be the PSU, I upgraded my 300W PSU to a 431W Enermax, which made no difference.
The only difference I can make out between the working and the non-working CPU is the internal clockspeed of the CPU and the stepping (old: 2, new: 4).
Heat anyone? stepping 4 hasn't seemed to be the problem, at least not directly
What's the tempature difference between your 1Ghz and 1.4Ghz? both CPU and system? What kind of cooling do you have?
In article <01090915115400.00173@c779218-a> you write:
| On Sunday 09 September 2001 10:07 am, Carsten Leonhardt wrote: | > Hi, | > | > here's my data regarding the K7 optimisation problem. | > | > Until last week I had a 1GHz Athlon with 133MHz FSB. I then bought a | > 1.4GHz Athlon, again 133MHz FSB. | > | > I never had any problems with the 1GHz processor, but as soon as I | > stuck the 1.4GHz processor in, the kernel oopsed itself to | > oblivion. (That was with kernel 2.4.5-ac5, approximately) | | This is common enough it's becoming absurd.
Never had a slower Athlon than 1.4, but I suppose the system could be underclocked as well;-) However, I have to think there's other stuff happen, see below.
| > | > I also noticed that the computer booted ok with the Debian | > bootfloppies, which use a kernel compiled for i386. So after several | > kernel compile/boot cycles, I found out that I had to disable K7 | > optimisation to make the system boot again. | > | > The mainboard is a Tyan Trinity KT-A (S2390B) with a VIA KT133A | > chipset. | > | > After reading here that it may be the PSU, I upgraded my 300W PSU to a | > 431W Enermax, which made no difference. | > | > The only difference I can make out between the working and the | > non-working CPU is the internal clockspeed of the CPU and the | > stepping (old: 2, new: 4). | | Heat anyone? stepping 4 hasn't seemed to be the problem, at least not | directly | What's the tempature difference between your 1Ghz and 1.4Ghz? both CPU | and system? What kind of cooling do you have?
In my case, if I compile a 686 kernel it is nice and stable, while an Athlon kernel is not. With all due respect I bet the temperature is dead the same regardless of kernel, so I can't blame temperature.
The problem I have is seen only when I use Athlon code enabled with menuconfig, so the question is if the code is bad (as in timing sensitive), or if the compiler might be generating bad code for Athlon.
Just a data point, I believe that the problems (at least those which are bugging me) are releated to something other than temperature.
Signature · 4 lines
bill davidsen <[email protected]> "If I were a diplomat, in the best case I'd go hungry. In the worst case, people would die." -- Robert Lipe
From: "Nicholas Knight" <[email protected]>
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines
The only difference I can make out between the working and the non-working CPU is the internal clockspeed of the CPU and the stepping (old: 2, new: 4).
Heat anyone? stepping 4 hasn't seemed to be the problem, at least not directly
What's the tempature difference between your 1Ghz and 1.4Ghz? both CPU and system? What kind of cooling do you have?
What about the power supply. If it is at all marginal the power consumption boost going to 1.4G is likely a killer.
{^_^} Joanne Dow, [email protected]
Quoted 6 lines · J. Dow
From: "Nicholas Knight" <[email protected]>
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 3 lines
The only difference I can make out between the working and the non-working CPU is the internal clockspeed of the CPU and the stepping (old: 2, new: 4).
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Heat anyone? stepping 4 hasn't seemed to be the problem, at least not directly
What's the tempature difference between your 1Ghz and 1.4Ghz? both CPU and system? What kind of cooling do you have?What about the power supply. If it is at all marginal the power consumption boost going to 1.4G is likely a killer.
Well, he didn't mention the amperage outputs, but he said 431W Enermax, from what I hear Enermax PSU's are good.
I still have trouble dealing with the idea that the optimizations cause power consumption like this, but then, I have trouble with my own idea that it causes sufficient heat increase in the chipset that soon after boot.
Do most people that experience this problem also experience after a cold-boot where the system had been off for at least 10-15 minutes? And has ANYONE sucsesfully cured this problem by changing power supplies?
From: "Nicholas Knight" <[email protected]>
Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 2 lines
What about the power supply. If it is at all marginal the power consumption boost going to 1.4G is likely a killer.
Well, he didn't mention the amperage outputs, but he said 431W Enermax, from what I hear Enermax PSU's are good.
I still have trouble dealing with the idea that the optimizations cause power consumption like this, but then, I have trouble with my own idea that it causes sufficient heat increase in the chipset that soon after boot.
Quoted 3 lines
Do most people that experience this problem also experience after a cold-boot where the system had been off for at least 10-15 minutes? And has ANYONE sucsesfully cured this problem by changing power supplies?
Don't forget that there are two regulators involved. First there is the primary power supply's regulator down to either 3.3 or 5 volts. Then there is the motherboard regulator down to the 1.7 volt range. If THAT one is not up to handling the required oompf during certain CPU loads that is a sure way to glitch the machine.
{^_^}
Quoted 17 lines · J. Dow
From: "Nicholas Knight" <[email protected]>
Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 2 lines
What about the power supply. If it is at all marginal the power consumption boost going to 1.4G is likely a killer.
Well, he didn't mention the amperage outputs, but he said 431W Enermax, from what I hear Enermax PSU's are good.
I still have trouble dealing with the idea that the optimizations cause power consumption like this, but then, I have trouble with my own idea that it causes sufficient heat increase in the chipset that soon after boot.Quoted 4 lines
Do most people that experience this problem also experience after a cold-boot where the system had been off for at least 10-15 minutes? And has ANYONE sucsesfully cured this problem by changing power supplies?
Quoted 5 lines
Don't forget that there are two regulators involved. First there is the primary power supply's regulator down to either 3.3 or 5 volts. Then there is the motherboard regulator down to the 1.7 volt range. If THAT one is not up to handling the required oompf during certain CPU loads that is a sure way to glitch the machine.
Now THAT I'll buy... It would certainly explain why some KT133A motherboards work and some don't, but the relation would be a little complex, the chipset might be exposing general problems with regulators used in motherboards.
Verifying this would require both extensive analysis of the motherboards and chipsets, and the regulators.
You'd also need to verify the manufacturing place, batch and time/date for at least 50 to 100 motherboards to begin verifying this.
Quoted 7 lines · Nicholas Knight
Quoted 6 lines · J. Dow
From: "Nicholas Knight" <[email protected]>
Quoted 4 lines
Heat anyone? stepping 4 hasn't seemed to be the problem, at least not directly
What's the tempature difference between your 1Ghz and 1.4Ghz? both CPU and system? What kind of cooling do you have?
I sold the 1GHz, so I can't tell anymore. I have a huge heatsink with a Papst-fan. I have to admit that it was sold to me as being good enough for 1.33GHz (by the manufacturer himself), but that shouldn't be the problem, see below.
(If someone wants to know exactly:
http://www.tiger-electronics.de/english/cooler2.htm and look at PDA38000BC, for a picture look at cooler1.htm SDA38000BC and pretend you see the Papst-Fan on the top -- the pages seem to be outdated, the invoice says the fan is good for a 1.33GHz Athlon).
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines
What about the power supply. If it is at all marginal the power consumption boost going to 1.4G is likely a killer.
Well, he didn't mention the amperage outputs, but he said 431W Enermax, from what I hear Enermax PSU's are good.
Here's the data from the PSU's label:
Model: EG465P-VE
DC Output: +3.3V: 38A
+5V : 44A
+12V : 20A
-5V : 2A
-12V : 1A
+5Vsb: 2.2A
+3.3V & 5V : 220W max
total power : 431WQuoted 2 lines
Do most people that experience this problem also experience after a cold-boot where the system had been off for at least 10-15 minutes?
I just switched the machine off for about 10min, and for good measure, jumpered the board to 100MHz FSB, so the CPU runs at 1050MHz (thus being well below the spec for the heatsink). It may have gotten a tad further in the boot process, but if so, not much. Luckily, it never reaches the point where filesystems get mounted rw...
Without the optimisation the machine runs smoothly with steady cpu-load generated by a distributed-net client.
Currently I added a burnK7 and a burnMMX to the load, I'll see if the machine is still alive in the morning...
leo
Quoted 2 lines · Nicholas Knight
Do most people that experience this problem also experience after a cold-boot where the system had been off for at least 10-15 minutes? And has ANYONE sucsesfully cured this problem by changing power supplies?
I can get it to oops before the rc scripts are done, even from cold boot. I have not swapped power supplies. I seriously doubt that's the problem.
Signature · 3 lines
David Hollister Driversoft Engineering: http://devicedrivers.com Digital Audio Resources: http://digitalaudioresources.org
From: "Carsten Leonhardt" <[email protected]>
Quoted 10 lines
Here's the data from the PSU's label:
Model: EG465P-VE
DC Output: +3.3V: 38A+5V : 44A +12V : 20A -5V : 2A -12V : 1A +5Vsb: 2.2A +3.3V & 5V : 220W max
Hm, with CPUs running out close to 100 watts of late that number sounds just a wee bit low of the rest of the system is a full set of power hungry boards.
Quoted 5 lines
I just switched the machine off for about 10min, and for good measure, jumpered the board to 100MHz FSB, so the CPU runs at 1050MHz (thus being well below the spec for the heatsink). It may have gotten a tad further in the boot process, but if so, not much. Luckily, it never reaches the point where filesystems get mounted rw...
10 minutes is not enough time to run temperatures WAY down. Leave it off over night and power it up while cool in the AM. If it is temperature that should so it up pretty clearly.
Quoted 4 lines
Without the optimisation the machine runs smoothly with steady cpu-load generated by a distributed-net client.
Currently I added a burnK7 and a burnMMX to the load, I'll see if the machine is still alive in the morning...
Far better is run burnK7 and burnMMX alternately in one second on one second off cycles alternating the loads with each on second. This gives you the dubious benefit of the voltage drops and raises that will happen when the CPU load alters appreciably. With a constant load the voltage regulators can compensate. It may be that the problem is related to voltage regulators that cannot respond to transient loads properly. (I've been there. I have the tee- shirt. I try to forget the experience. {^_-})
{^_^}
Quoted 13 lines · J. Dow
From: "Carsten Leonhardt" <[email protected]>
Quoted 10 lines
Here's the data from the PSU's label:
Model: EG465P-VE
DC Output: +3.3V: 38A+5V : 44A +12V : 20A -5V : 2A -12V : 1A +5Vsb: 2.2A +3.3V & 5V : 220W max
Quoted 3 lines
Hm, with CPUs running out close to 100 watts of late that number sounds just a wee bit low of the rest of the system is a full set of power hungry boards.
Maybe. But your model is not recommened by AMD. Only the EG365P-VE is from Enermax, which is 350W/185W combined.
Check their site.
-K.
Quoted 6 lines · J. Dow
From: "Carsten Leonhardt" <[email protected]>
Quoted 2 lines
Currently I added a burnK7 and a burnMMX to the load, I'll see if the machine is still alive in the morning...
Far better is run burnK7 and burnMMX alternately in one second on one second off cycles alternating the loads with each on second. This gives you the
The one Duron I have access to which doesn't like the athlon optimsed kernels did crash some seconds after starting a little test program which does use the kernel copy code in user space.
Note that neither burnK7 nor burnMMX use the kernel copy code, but Robert Redelmeier (author of these two programs) has a burnMMX3 program which uses kernel-equivalent code.
Jan