Skip to contentSkip to conversation

OFF TOPIC: HOWTO: compromising Microsoft

DISCUSSION Jesse Pollard 1 participant 1 message Oct 24, 2001

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

"Rick A. Hohensee" <[email protected]>:
...

Quoted 11 lines

Consider legislation declaring Microsoft operating system products to be "specifically compromised intellectual property". The "compromise" is to allow anyone to "reverse-engineer" and resell Microsoft operating system products no less than five years after thier release dates, on a permanent, continuing, version-by-version basis. If such a law were enacted today that would mean that e.g. Windows 95 and earlier are fair game for modification and/or reselling by others as of today, as are early versions of NT, I believe. Windows 98 and later would still be exclusively Microsoft's protected property for a couple years. This is the measured approach to take, measured against, and in the units of, the industry in question. Five years is a long time for a great engine of innovation. I

Quoted 8 lines

believe a five year product lag of this nature will destroy Microsoft, unless they rapidly become the great engine of innovation they so ardently pose as. However, this scenario has clear advantages for Microsoft even as they exist now versus other proposals. Meanwhile, viable alternatives to Microsoft as a source of operating systems for PCs can reasonably be expected to arise rapidly. This approach puts Microsoft in level competition with thier own past, thier only possible source of substantive competition in the short term.

Won't work. MS would immediately report the true amount of new code in the protected stuff includes 90% of the code in the old stuff, and therefore still protected. The 10% of unprotected stuff would be the interfaceing code already released (system calls, include files, library calls ...) plus a few drivers for hardware no longer available. And removed comments...

Quoted 4 lines

The advantages to Microsoft are that this approach leaves them as the pilot of thier own compromised ship, the sole architects of all thier own products, the sole judge of what should be in a Microsoft OS and what shouldn't, and otherwise spares them from government micromanagement.

Quoted 8 lines

Government involvement would be very limited, stating what is and is not bundled. For example, MSN-related client software is bundled and compromisable, the MSN network itself isn't. Et cetera. This leaves them free to be thier rusticly charming proprietary selves vis-a-vis the products they have not yet bundled into Windows, such as (last I heard,) Office, which reflects the idea that the operating system has public-interest aspects that ancillary products may not. Thus Internet Explorer and so on would be subject to compromise in due time.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Jesse I Pollard, II
Email: [email protected]

Any opinions expressed are solely my own.