Skip to contentSkip to conversation

You WIN ...

DISCUSSION Willem Riede 1 participant 1 message Dec 31, 2001 1 message not in the archive

lore
Share & tools
lore

A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]

#1 lore raw
Quoted 10 lines · On 2001.12.31 07:58 Jens Axboe wrote:

(sat on this for a few days not to boil over)

Quoted 5 lines · Andre Hedrick

Jens,

You win -- it is not worth trying to work with you at this time. All you and I have done is become bitter enemies.

I'm not sure that entering this debate is a good idea, but it is so sad to see two such valuable contributers to Linux bicker with each other...

On the infrequent occasion that I had to exchange email with Andre, I've realized it is very hard to communicate with him (sorry Andre), so I understand how Jens must be feeling.

On the other hand - and that may just be my problem, as I don't claim to have enough expertise - I've read Suparna's and Jens' notes, reviewed the code changes and still don't understand where the whole ide/scsi/block/char i/o re-design is going. (I can see what has been done - that's well documented, but not what's coming or why - a discussion of the decomposition in layers, what is each' responsibility and what's the api between them, simplifications/improvements that result)

Likewise, I've not been able to discern from Andre's posts what it is he's trying to do. No idea how that violates what Jens wants.

But Andre is clearly an unrivaled expert in his area, and the recent results posted to this list are impressive, so I understand that Andre feels frustrated not to be able to get those improvements into the kernel.

As a linux user, I certainly want the benefit of what both parties have to offer. It would have to satisfy Linus' taste, fit Jens' design, and realize Andre's improvements. There ought to be a way for that to happen.

Now, if only I was smart enough to figure that one out :-(

Regards, Willem Riede.
(maintainer of osst tape driver)