New scheduler in 2.4. series?
Hello World,
Hello Marcelo,
Is there any chance, that the new scheduler will be in the 2.4 series soon?
Regards
Andreas
Signature · 5 lines
Andreas Tscharner [email protected] ------------------------------------------------------------------------- "Programming today is a race between software engineers striving to build bigger and better idiot-proof programs, and the Universe trying to produce bigger and better idiots. So far, the Universe is winning." -- Rich Cook
Seeing the new scheduler in 2.4 would be nice! However, soon wouldn't be nice, because there are a lot of 3rd party kernel modules that try to make calls against the old scheduler that don't seem to work. My personal case in point is Bestcrypt ( www.jetico.sci.fi ). Just my thoughts on the matter.
--Brandon
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-Previous Message(s)-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Quoted 13 lines
Hello World,
Hello Marcelo,Is there any chance, that the new scheduler will be in the 2.4 series soon?
Regards
AndreasSignature · 5 lines
Andreas Tscharner [email protected] ------------------------------------------------------------------------- "Programming today is a race between software engineers striving to build bigger and better idiot-proof programs, and the Universe trying to produce bigger and better idiots. So far, the Universe is winning." -- Rich Cook
Quoted 3 lines · Brandon Low
Seeing the new scheduler in 2.4 would be nice! However, soon wouldn't be nice, because there are a lot of 3rd party kernel modules that try to make calls against the old scheduler that don't seem to work. My personal case in point is Bestcrypt ( www.jetico.sci.fi ). Just my thoughts on the matter.
If you're speaking of Ingo's O1-scheduler I won't vote for inclusion now. I still have some trouble with high priority nice levels (renice -20). For some seconds the system gets totally unresponsive for user requests while switching between those processes. The last one I've tried was J2.
*Kristian
:... [snd.science] ...:
::
:: http://www.korseby.net
:: http://gsmp.sf.net
:.........................:: ~/$ [email protected] :
Quoted 3 lines · Kristian
[...] I still have some trouble with high priority nice levels (renice -20). For some seconds the system gets totally unresponsive for user requests while switching between those processes. [...]
if you are using nice -20 tasks then they might take CPU time away from lower priority tasks. This is why bigger negative nice levels should only be used sparingly. (and this is why it can only be done as root.)
Quoted 1 line
The last one I've tried was J2.
that's a pretty old patch, the current one is -K2.
Ingo
Quoted 3 lines · Ingo Molnar
if you are using nice -20 tasks then they might take CPU time away from lower priority tasks. This is why bigger negative nice levels should only be used sparingly. (and this is why it can only be done as root.)
Of course. But with the good old scheduler I've never had any problems. The system was very slow but continuously responsive. (low frequency timeslices between process rotations) With your -J2 patch it's getting really unusable. Maybe I should give -K2 a try.
*Kristian
:... [snd.science] ...:
::
:: http://www.korseby.net
:: http://gsmp.sf.net
:.........................:: ~/$ [email protected] :
Quoted 2 lines · Kristian
Of course. But with the good old scheduler I've never had any problems. The system was very slow but continuously responsive. [...]
true, the old scheduler did not do much with the nice level. In the new scheduler there is some real difference between nice levels - and this is a feature. I'd suggest for you to try something like nice -5. What kind of application are you renicing?
Ingo
Quoted 4 lines · Ingo Molnar
true, the old scheduler did not do much with the nice level. In the new scheduler there is some real difference between nice levels - and this is a feature. I'd suggest for you to try something like nice -5. What kind of application are you renicing?
Just multiple 'nice -n -20 tar -cvjf` in a row for "high priority backup when my DTLA drives makes wierd noises again". I'm just compiling -K2. (BTW: -J2 behaves really bad while moving windows during a kernel compilation.)
*Kristian
:... [snd.science] ...:
::
:: http://www.korseby.net
:: http://gsmp.sf.net
:.........................:: ~/$ [email protected] :
Hello.
-K2 behaves much better as -J2 did. The system gets continuously responsive again. But with nicelevel -5 at the beginning of each 'tar` the systems stalls for 2 or 3 seconds.
*Kristian
:... [snd.science] ...:
::
:: http://www.korseby.net
:: http://gsmp.sf.net
:.........................:: ~/$ [email protected] :
Quoted 3 lines · Kristian
-K2 behaves much better as -J2 did. The system gets continuously responsive again. But with nicelevel -5 at the beginning of each 'tar` the systems stalls for 2 or 3 seconds.
yes, it takes 2-3 seconds for the system to notice that the 'tar' process started from your interactive shell is in fact a 'CPU hog'. The system was honoring root's request for CPU time.
this should not happen if you start it at nice -2, which should still give 'tar' enough of an advantage.
Ingo