IDE-DVD problems [excuse former idiotic topic]
Quoted 4 lines · Benjamin LaHaise
Have you tried commenting out the hdparm commands in the initscripts and booted with a kernel that enables DMA (instead of using hdparm -d1)?
-ben
I can give that a whirl, but it bothers me the way it currently "works":
* Performance is terrible
* booting with noapic makes no difference
* Performance seems to indicate some kind of difficulties in the kernel, perhaps connected to interrupt handling
I have another RH 7.3 box sitting next to the new one, which has a Sony DVD-ROM. I just enabled DMA with hdparm and it works very well. That is not what happens on the other (troublesome) machine.
So I am wondering:
* Kernel interrupt handling problem (should there be ERR if apic is enabled? which it is)
* IRQ problem? I haven't tried changing around IRQs.
* IDE controller problem? Probably not, because the drive seems to work the same on the Highpoint controller.
* Problem with this specific drive? Perhaps. I've never used it before--the last "combo" drive I used was SCSI. I bought this one because it was the same brand as the SCSI drive I used before, and as an IDE device it would be about $500 cheaper (no SCSI card needed). I will check to see if a firmware download is available.
* Some other m/b problem? Perhaps, but I've not tried this drive in another box. I am inclined to try that next.
I am also inclined to try the Sony DVD-ROM in the new box to see if it exhibits the same behavior.
What is the "combo drive" used by the iMac et al.?
-joseph
Quoted 35 lines · Joseph N. Hall
Quoted 29 lines
Yes, DMA makes the drive completely non functional and eventually hangs the machine after some amount of attempted use. This is regardless of when DMA is enabled, whether via the standard RedHat "harddiskn" mechanism or manually with hdparm.
-joseph
Quoted 21 lines · Matthew Dharm
Have you tried enabling DMA on the drive?
Matt
Quoted 15 lines · Joseph N. Hall
Dear Kernel Folks,
I am trying to determine the cause of the poor performance of a an IDE DVD device on my new machine. I have an IDE Panasonic DF-210-type DVD-RAM/R/ROM in a new machine with Soyo KT333 motherboard. It transfers data slowly (below DVD speed), consumes large amounts of system time, and slows down the user interface and even system clock (which can run as slow as 1/4 speed while the drive is going).
The interrupt ERR count below seems to be mostly related to use of the DVD drive.
Maybe it's something simple. If not, I'll be glad to do further work to help diagnose the problem.
Signature · 1 line
"You will be reincarnated as a toad; and you will be much happier."