tbench as a load - DDOS attack?
Zwane M suggested using tbench as a load to test one of his recent patches and gave me the idea to try using tbench_load in contest. Here are the first set of results I got while running tbench 4 continuously (uniprocessor machine):
tbench_load:
Kernel [runs] Time CPU% test2420 1 180 38.9 test2561 1 970 7.7
This is a massive difference. Sure tbench was giving better numbers on 2.5.61 but it caused a massive slowdown. I wondered whether this translates into being more susceptible to ping floods or DDOS attacks? You should have seen tbench 16 - 3546 seconds!
comments?
Con
Quoted 10 lines · Con Kolivas
Zwane M suggested using tbench as a load to test one of his recent patches and gave me the idea to try using
tbench_loadin contest. Here are the first set of results I got while running tbench 4 continuously (uniprocessor machine):
tbench_load:Kernel [runs] Time CPU% test2420 1 180 38.9 test2561 1 970 7.7
Quoted 6 lines
This is a massive difference. Sure tbench was giving better numbers on 2.5.61 but it caused a massive slowdown. I wondered whether this translates into being more susceptible to ping floods or DDOS attacks? You should have seen tbench 16 - 3546 seconds!
comments?
Are you running this via loopback? Can you send a profile during the 2.4.20 run?
Thanks,
Zwane
Signature · 1 line
function.linuxpower.ca
Quoted 16 lines · Zwane Mwaikambo
Quoted 15 lines · Con Kolivas
Zwane M suggested using tbench as a load to test one of his recent patches and gave me the idea to try using
tbench_loadin contest. Here are the first set of results I got while running tbench 4 continuously (uniprocessor machine):
tbench_load:Kernel [runs] Time CPU% test2420 1 180 38.9 test2561 1 970 7.7This is a massive difference. Sure tbench was giving better numbers on 2.5.61 but it caused a massive slowdown. I wondered whether this translates into being more susceptible to ping floods or DDOS attacks? You should have seen tbench 16 - 3546 seconds!
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 1 line
comments?
Are you running this via loopback? Can you send a profile during the 2.4.20 run?
Loopback.
Con
Quoted 7 lines · Con Kolivas
Zwane M suggested using tbench as a load to test one of his recent patches and gave me the idea to try using
tbench_loadin contest. Here are the first set of results I got while running tbench 4 continuously (uniprocessor machine):
tbench_load:
Quoted 9 lines
Kernel [runs] Time CPU% test2420 1 180 38.9 test2561 1 970 7.7This is a massive difference. Sure tbench was giving better numbers on 2.5.61 but it caused a massive slowdown. I wondered whether this translates into being more susceptible to ping floods or DDOS attacks? You should have seen tbench 16 - 3546 seconds!
Yes, something is wrong with the CPU scheduler. Simple test case:
./tbench_srv & while true do ./tbench 4 done & cd /usr/src/util-linux time make -j4
The tbench activity takes the time to compile util-linux from 13 second to 133 seconds.
But that is not the whole story. The compilation appeared to make no progress at all while tbench was running - it was only in the gaps between ending one tbench run and starting another that the compilation did anything.
When I changed the load to one instance of
while true do ./tbench 2 done and one instance of while true do ./tbench 3 done
the compilation made no progress except for those rare instances when the two shell scripts were restarting the tbench run at the same time. After a while the scripts fell itno synchronism, and the compilation took 260 seconds.
Conclusion: tbench completely starves the `make'.
It mainly seems to affect uniprocessor builds. SMP was much better behaved.
Adding the sched-f3 patch basicaly fixed it all up. The 133 second build came down to 55 seconds, and the compilation was visibly making progress during the tbench runs.