Never ever send Pavel private mail unless you want him to publish
Quoted 13 lines · Stuart MacDonald
Quoted 4 lines
I'm under the impression that postcards do not carry an expectation of privacy due to their readability during transmission. I'd expect that email would be found to have the similar lack of expectation were it to be tested in court.
That would cover disclosing information from email, but it wouldn't cover publishing copies of email. The general opinion from lawyers and law students, when this has been discussed on misc.legal, has been that email would be treated similarly to regular mail. So, copying the entire thing to a mailing list or usenet would probably be a copyright violation. Quoting parts of it as part of an argument would probably be fair use.
Quoted 5 lines
It's almost always considered extremely rude to unilaterally take a private argument public, which should be enough to stop civilized people, regardless of the legal issues.
--Tim Smith
I'm not a lawyer, so don't take this as legal advice, but it
sounds to me like your opinion conflicts with the 1988 US Supreme Cout case Hustler v. Moral Majority, Inc. which was explained to me several years ago when ago, when I asked Yggdrasil's lawyers to look into the question of reposting email without the author's permission for discussion purposes (this was before DMCA, but I'd be surprised if DMCA affected this aspect of fair use).
Poking around google turned up the following brief description
of the case at http://www.isaacsonraymond.com/fair_use_doctrine.html:
| In Hustler Magazine, Inc. v. Moral Majority, Inc.,[29] Jerry | Falwell, a nationally known fundamentalist minister, made unauthorized | copies of a scurrilous parody of himself after it was published in | Hustler magazine. The Hustler parody portrayed Rev. Falwell as | engaging in an insidious sexual exploit and getting drunk before | delivering his sermons. | | Under the aegis of the Moral Majority, Rev. Falwell?s conservative | lobbying group, Falwell sent copies of the Hustler article, together | with a letter soliciting donations to help finance his lawsuit against | Hustler, to 29,000 of the organization?s major contributors. There | was no question that Falwell had copied the entire Hustler article but | for ?eight of the most offensive words,? without any attempt to | transform the original work.[30] Although the Ninth Circuit Court of | Appeals determined that copying the original to solicit funds for | Falwell?s lawsuit was clearly commercial,[31] it still ruled against | Hustler stating that Defendant?s use ?could not have diminished any | potential sales, interfered with the marketability of the parody or | fulfilled the demand for the original work.?[32] The Moral Majority?s | members, the Court observed, would ?probably not be counted among | Hustler?s readers,? and therefore the defendants, while profiting from | use of the copyrighted work, had not adversely affected the | plaintiff?s market for it.[33]
Adam J. Richter __ ______________ 575 Oroville Road [email protected] \ / Milpitas, California 95035 +1 408 309-6081 | g g d r a s i l United States of America
"Free Software For The Rest Of Us."
Quoted 1 line · Adam J. Richter
| Under the aegis of the Moral Majority, Rev. Falwell?s
conservative
Quoted 5 lines
| lobbying group, Falwell sent copies of the Hustler article, together
| with a letter soliciting donations to help finance his lawsuit against
| Hustler, to 29,000 of the organization?s major contributors.
There
Quoted 9 lines
| was no question that Falwell had copied the entire Hustler article but
| for ?eight of the most offensive words,? without any attempt to | transform the original work.[30] Although the Ninth Circuit Court of
| Appeals determined that copying the original to solicit funds for | Falwell?s lawsuit was clearly commercial,[31] it still ruled against
| Hustler stating that Defendant?s use ?could not have diminished
any
Quoted 1 line
| potential sales, interfered with the marketability of the parody
or
Quoted 7 lines
| fulfilled the demand for the original work.?[32] The Moral Majority?s
| members, the Court observed, would ?probably not be counted among | Hustler?s readers,? and therefore the defendants, while profiting from
| use of the copyrighted work, had not adversely affected the | plaintiff?s market for it.[33]
There are really only two conclusions you can draw from this:
1) This only applies to a situation where the primary purpose of the
original publication is for the purposes of selling the item to produce revenue and therefore it's reasonable to judge the copyright violation on the basis of its affect on the sales of the original work, or
2) You can violate copyright for commercial purposes so long as you
don't cost the original publisher anything. In which case, any GPL violation is acceptable, since there's no "market" for a free work.
DS