Alsa mixer for KDE
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Hi Pavel,
I am also searching for good alsa mixer for X and especially for KDE. I'm placing this message in alsa-user and alsa-devel mailing lists too so I'll dream out an ideal mixer first. I hope we find somebody skilled to write such "dream alsa mixer gui".
The ideal mixer should:
- have nice but simple interface (maybe with the possibility of two rows of controls - my Audigy 2 has about 40 controls)
- have hidable controls
- have movable controls
- have one slider for left&right + balance with skip to center
- have possibility to create group of controls with a "Group Master" (if you want to increase volume on 5.1 you have to fiddle with 3 controls now)
- have configurable control names
- use autoupdate (it should reflect changes made by other mixers/applications immediately)
- have mute/unmute ALL function
- have the possibility to define,save and restore multiple settings sets (for example "Night settings" would put all volumes to values I saved yesterday evening, "Full blast" would put volumes to my party-time settings,"TV recording",...)
- have the possibility to dock in panel like KDE kmix does
- have lirc interface (lirc is SW for IR remote controlling)
- be for KDE, gnome and all others
- have everything else what somebody else can dream out
I would say that Creative's mixer for Audigy 2 and Window$ is not far from this ideal in functionality (not in graphical design - that's terribly ugly).
Well, developer guys, you can add this to the user's wishlist.
And now answer for your question Pavel:
I do not use just one mixer but one what I use most is gnome-alsamixer. It has hidable controls at least but no autoupdate. Another I use is alsamixergui - it's 1999 version so probaly you shouldn't except any further development. KDE kmix is usable for simple tasks - this is oss mixer. I use amixer if I need to change settings from a script (for example while handling a multimedia keyboard events).
The alsa official is alsamixer for console but I use it very rarely as I'm almost all the time in KDE.
There are many others on the internet but I haven't found an ideal one. Let me know if you are more successful.
Regards,
Ing. Jozef Sakalos
[email protected]
Quoted 8 lines · you
Hi Jozef!
I have some question. That do you use for volume control? aumix is not working, alsamixer is not usefull. Maybe you know any program to move several controls together (for example: Wave and Wave Surround).
Pavel
-------------------------------------------------------
This sf.net email is sponsored by:ThinkGeek
Welcome to geek heaven.
http://thinkgeek.com/sf
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Hi Chris,
I'm REALLY pleased that kmix is alsa mixer. How should I compile it to enable alsa? (I compiled my KDE 3.1.1 myself - on SuSE 8.0)
Regards,
Ing. Jozef Sakalos
Quoted 90 lines · you
Quoted 5 lines · Ing. Jozef Sakalos
Hi Pavel,
I am also searching for good alsa mixer for X and especially for KDE. I'm placing this message in alsa-user and alsa-devel mailing
I really have to comment on this. Why don't you use KMix?
Quoted 2 lines
probaly you shouldn't except any further development. KDE kmix is usable for simple tasks - this is oss mixer.
KMix is ALSA, when you configure it to inlcude ALSA support. You can also compile in both ALSA- and OSS-Support (Depends on the packer, IIRC SuSE does so). KMix then decides which driver to
use: Uses ALSA if there are ALSA-Mixers available, else uses OSS.Quoted 2 lines
- have nice but simple interface (maybe with the possibility of two
yes
Quoted 1 line
rows of controls - my Audigy 2 has about 40 controls)
You can have two tabs instead. Current version (from CVS) automatically distributes controls on 1-3 tabs (Primary controls, Secondary controls, Switches). Specilized ALSA Switch-Handling is a TODO (e.g. does not need a slider).
Quoted 1 line
- have hidable controls
yes
Quoted 1 line
- have movable controls
no. but a nice idea.
Quoted 1 line
- have one slider for left&right + balance with skip to center
yes
Quoted 2 lines
- have possibility to create group of controls with a "Group Master"
no. But a nice idea.
Quoted 1 line
- have configurable control names
no
Quoted 2 lines
- use autoupdate (it should reflect changes made by other mixers/applications immediately)
yes (dock icon and panel applet need some work).
Quoted 1 line
- have mute/unmute ALL function
(yes) => Just mute the master. 95% of all souncarads have a master.
Quoted 2 lines
- have the possibility to define,save and restore multiple settings
I like this very much. Unfortunately lost this ability in KDE2. :-(
Quoted 1 line
- have the possibility to dock in panel like KDE kmix does
Obviously yes
Quoted 1 line
- have lirc interface (lirc is SW for IR remote controlling)
Not directly, but you can fully "remote control" KMix
Quoted 1 line
- be for KDE, gnome and all others
Yes. KDE applications just run under X11. No problem starting under gnome, or under other Window managers.
Quoted 1 line
- have everything else what somebody else can dream out
For exaple Panel applet, global keyboard shortcuts
Quoted 2 lines
to change settings from a script (for example while handling a multimedia keyboard events).
yes. But for multimedia keyboard events, there is built-in-support. You can either use kmixctrl (limited interface) or dcop (full interface).
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 2 lines
There are many others on the internet but I haven't found an ideal one. Let me know if you are more successful.
Well, obviously for me as author KMix is the optimal thing. Feel free to add wishes to the KMix wishlist (use http://bugs.kde.org
and mark the new "bug" as "wish").Chris
-------------------------------------------------------
This sf.net email is sponsored by:ThinkGeek
Welcome to geek heaven.
http://thinkgeek.com/sf