Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Verified IDE performance issues in kernels newer than 2.4.20

DISCUSSION K. Hampf 3 participants 4 messages Sep 3, 2003 – Sep 4, 2003

lore
Share & tools
lore

K. Hampf

author
#0 lore raw

BRIEF:
I discovered the 2.4.21 and 2.4.22 kernels give me roughly 15% of the troughput compared to 2.4.20. Anyone working on this?

Dear Sirs!

I could not find any info about this issue that indicated you were aware of this issue. So I decided to send you a report. I've confirmed the issue on different i386 chipsets so I think it's a valid issue. Tried to mail the maintaners bug-report e-mail ([email protected]) but failed on delivery, "User unknown".

I'm a bit into tweaking kernels and I've made a discovery explaining getting poor performance in ATA transfers. Both experienced by using apps and with "hdparm -t -T" runs.

I verified this under my VIA KT333 and a SiS 735 (SiS 5513IDE) chipsets. The first on my Debian testing/unstable workstation, the latter on a Debian/stable. It's not debian-kernel specific as I use both "vanilla" stable kernel sources and debian sources, I know that I'm on to something.

I have no time to push the 2.4.20 IDE driver tree into 2.4.22 (tried quickly but the include headers break and it would take some time for me to make it work), I could however, if you take this bugreport seriously and make it meaningful, do some runs on vanilla 2.4.20 and 2.4.22 kernels with hdparm and send all results. All you need is to tell me. I will be able to test it on a newer P4 SATA system too if that's supported when I get to it.

I know this is not a proper nor well formatted bugreport but I could find no info on wether you knew of this performance issue already and are working on it, I'll throw you some extra info just to make you happy:

Both test systems are Athlon architectures (T-bird 1.2GHz and an XP2100+). I've confirmed the issue on different IDE chipsets and on both ATA66, ATA100 and ATA133 drives. I'm experienced with linux and hardware and know I'm not ranting about some "might be" issue. I'm preparing my local LUG to test this out a bit more, hopefully on other architectures than i386 also (SPARC and Alpha I hope).

If this is relevant to your work on the IDE driver (as I can't get in touch with you guys directly) or you might think it's about some PCI issues or other things, do not hesitate to contact me, I can include statistics and do better testruns if you tell me it would be of any value to you and that you are the ones to handle it.

Best Regards,
K. Hampf <[email protected]>

#1 lore raw
Quoted 3 lines · K. Hampf

BRIEF:
I discovered the 2.4.21 and 2.4.22 kernels give me roughly 15% of the troughput compared to 2.4.20. Anyone working on this?

out of the blue, the following info could be very useful ... (for 2.4.20 and 2.4.22 on your systems)

cat /proc/ide/*
hdparm -i /dev/hd?
hdparm /dev/hd?

and try to make it available on a webpage

best,
Herbert

Quoted 49 lines

Dear Sirs!

I could not find any info about this issue that indicated you were aware of this issue. So I decided to send you a report. I've confirmed the issue on different i386 chipsets so I think it's a valid issue. Tried to mail the maintaners bug-report e-mail ([email protected]) but failed on delivery, "User unknown".

I'm a bit into tweaking kernels and I've made a discovery explaining getting poor performance in ATA transfers. Both experienced by using apps and with "hdparm -t -T" runs.

I verified this under my VIA KT333 and a SiS 735 (SiS 5513IDE) chipsets. The first on my Debian testing/unstable workstation, the latter on a Debian/stable. It's not debian-kernel specific as I use both "vanilla" stable kernel sources and debian sources, I know that I'm on to something.

I have no time to push the 2.4.20 IDE driver tree into 2.4.22 (tried quickly but the include headers break and it would take some time for me to make it work), I could however, if you take this bugreport seriously and make it meaningful, do some runs on vanilla 2.4.20 and 2.4.22 kernels with hdparm and send all results. All you need is to tell me. I will be able to test it on a newer P4 SATA system too if that's supported when I get to it.

I know this is not a proper nor well formatted bugreport but I could find no info on wether you knew of this performance issue already and are working on it, I'll throw you some extra info just to make you happy:

Both test systems are Athlon architectures (T-bird 1.2GHz and an XP2100+). I've confirmed the issue on different IDE chipsets and on both ATA66, ATA100 and ATA133 drives. I'm experienced with linux and hardware and know I'm not ranting about some "might be" issue. I'm preparing my local LUG to test this out a bit more, hopefully on other architectures than i386 also (SPARC and Alpha I hope).

If this is relevant to your work on the IDE driver (as I can't get in touch with you guys directly) or you might think it's about some PCI issues or other things, do not hesitate to contact me, I can include statistics and do better testruns if you tell me it would be of any value to you and that you are the ones to handle it.

Best Regards,
K. Hampf <[email protected]>

-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/

#2 lore raw
Quoted 8 lines · Herbert Poetzl
Quoted 4 lines · K. Hampf

BRIEF:
I discovered the 2.4.21 and 2.4.22 kernels give me roughly 15% of the troughput compared to 2.4.20. Anyone working on this?

Quoted 10 lines

out of the blue, the following info could be very useful ... (for 2.4.20 and 2.4.22 on your systems)

cat /proc/ide/*
hdparm -i /dev/hd?
hdparm /dev/hd?

and try to make it available on a webpage

Also try "hdparm -a 2048 <some device>" before running hdparm. Also
the ide section of dmesg woul dbe handy in addition to the above.

[root@goblin e2fsprogs-1.26]# hdparm -t /dev/hdg

/dev/hdg:
Timing buffered disk reads: 70 MB in 3.04 seconds = 23.03 MB/sec
[root@goblin e2fsprogs-1.26]# hdparm -a 2048 /dev/hdg

/dev/hdg:
setting fs readahead to 2048
readahead = 2048 (on)
[root@goblin e2fsprogs-1.26]# hdparm -t /dev/hdg

/dev/hdg:
Timing buffered disk reads: 122 MB in 3.01 seconds = 40.47 MB/sec

Signature · 3 lines
Once you have their hardware. Never give it back.
(The First Rule of Hardware Acquisition)
Sam Flory  <[email protected]>
author
#3 lore raw
In reply to Herbert Poetzl

FALSE ALARM

I am terribly sorry! I was tired last night when I discovered this issue but as you guys (Herbert Poetzl, Samuel Flory) made me realize I do need to make a good report available I realized that the problem was a simple one.

The chipset-specific IDE module didn't load! Even if I probed it it had no effect, the common IDE driver already narrowed down the bandwidth of the IDE bus. I just made a test building the IDE chipset drivers non-modular and it gives full performance again. I do not know exactly what mistake I've made when selecting all drivers to be modular but they block each other, I have to investigate that further, due to it still being an issue but I can work on the newer kernels again.

Thanks for looking at it, I guess I was too tired last night to do a thorough analysis of it all, won't happen again, next time I'll sleep first, then report any errors ;)

Best Regards,
K. Hampf

P.S. If anyone knows exactly what has to be modularized along with the chipset-specific drivers to make them run, please tell ....

Quoted 59 lines · you
Quoted 3 lines · K. Hampf

BRIEF:
I discovered the 2.4.21 and 2.4.22 kernels give me roughly 15% of the troughput compared to 2.4.20. Anyone working on this?

out of the blue, the following info could be very useful ... (for 2.4.20 and 2.4.22 on your systems)

cat /proc/ide/*
hdparm -i /dev/hd?
hdparm /dev/hd?

and try to make it available on a webpage

best,
Herbert

Quoted 42 lines

Dear Sirs!

I could not find any info about this issue that indicated you were aware of this issue. So I decided to send you a report. I've confirmed the issue on different i386 chipsets so I think it's a valid issue. Tried to mail the maintaners bug-report e-mail ([email protected]) but failed on delivery, "User unknown".

I'm a bit into tweaking kernels and I've made a discovery explaining getting poor performance in ATA transfers. Both experienced by using apps and with "hdparm -t -T" runs.

I verified this under my VIA KT333 and a SiS 735 (SiS 5513IDE) chipsets. The first on my Debian testing/unstable workstation, the latter on a Debian/stable. It's not debian-kernel specific as I use both "vanilla" stable kernel sources and debian sources, I know that I'm on to something.

I have no time to push the 2.4.20 IDE driver tree into 2.4.22 (tried quickly but the include headers break and it would take some time for me to make it work), I could however, if you take this bugreport seriously and make it meaningful, do some runs on vanilla 2.4.20 and 2.4.22 kernels with hdparm and send all results. All you need is to tell me. I will be able to test it on a newer P4 SATA system too if that's supported when I get to it.

I know this is not a proper nor well formatted bugreport but I could find no info on wether you knew of this performance issue already and are working on it, I'll throw you some extra info just to make you happy:

Both test systems are Athlon architectures (T-bird 1.2GHz and an XP2100+). I've confirmed the issue on different IDE chipsets and on both ATA66, ATA100 and ATA133 drives. I'm experienced with linux and hardware and know I'm not ranting about some "might be" issue. I'm preparing my local LUG to test this out a bit more, hopefully on other architectures than i386 also (SPARC and Alpha I hope).

If this is relevant to your work on the IDE driver (as I can't get in touch with you guys directly) or you might think it's about some PCI issues or other things, do not hesitate to contact me, I can include statistics and do better testruns if you tell me it would be of any value to you and that you are the ones to handle it.