hot cache line due to note_interrupt()
Subsystems (2)
I dont know the background on note_interrupt() in arch/ia64/kernel/irq.c, but I had to disable the function on our large systems (IA64).
The function updates a counter in the irq_desc_t table. An entry in this table is shared by all cpus that take a specific interrupt #. For most interrupt #'s, this is a problem but it is prohibitive for the timer tick on big systems.
Updating the counter causes a cache line to be bounced between cpus at a rate of at least HZ*active_cpus. (The number of bus transactions is at least 2X higher because the line is first obtained for shared usage, then upgraded to modified. In addition, multiple references are made to the line for each interrupt. On a big system, it is unlikely that a cpu can hold the line for entire time that the interrupt is being serviced).
On a 500p system, the system was VERY slowly making forward progres during boot, but I didnt have the patience to wait for it finish. After I disabled note_interrupt(), I had no problem booting.
Certainly, the problem is much less severe on smaller systems. However, even moderate sized systems may see some degradation due to this hot cache line.
I also verified on a system simulator that the counter in note_interrupt() is the only line that is bounced between cpus at a HZ rate on an idle system.
The IPI & reschedule interrupts have a similar problem but at a lower rate.
(initialially sent to [email protected])
Signature · 4 lines
Thanks Jack Steiner ([email protected]) 651-683-5302 Principal Engineer SGI - Silicon Graphics, Inc.
Hi,
Quoted 6 lines
I also verified on a system simulator that the counter in
note_interrupt()is the only line that is bounced between cpus at a HZ rate on an idle system.The IPI & reschedule interrupts have a similar problem but at a lower rate.
We havent seen this on ppc64 because our timer interrupt doesnt go via the standard interrupt path (its a separate exception). IPIs do however so Id expect these to be a problem for us.
Anton
Quoted 10 lines · Jack Steiner
I dont know the background on
note_interrupt()inarch/ia64/kernel/irq.c, but I had to disable the function on our large systems (IA64).The function updates a counter in the
irq_desc_ttable. An entry in this table is shared by all cpus that take a specific interrupt #. For most interrupt #'s, this is a problem but it is prohibitive for the timer tick on big systems.Updating the counter causes a cache line to be bounced between cpus at a rate of at least HZ*active_cpus. (The number of bus transactions
The answer to this is probably alloc_percpu for the counters. right now this might not possible because irq_desc_t table might be used very early, and alloc_percpu uses slab underneath. alloc_percpu will have to be made to work early enough for this....
Thanks,
Kiran
Quoted 5 lines
The answer to this is probably
alloc_percpufor the counters. right now this might not possible becauseirq_desc_ttable might be used very early, andalloc_percpuuses slab underneath.alloc_percpuwill have to be made to work early enough for this....
Also keep in mind the memory bloat with high NR_IRQS and NR_IRQS.
Anton
Quoted 6 lines · Ravikiran G Thirumalai
Quoted 4 lines · Jack Steiner
I dont know the background on
note_interrupt()inarch/ia64/kernel/irq.c, but I had to disable the function on our large systems (IA64).
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 6 lines
The function updates a counter in the
irq_desc_ttable. An entry in this table is shared by all cpus that take a specific interrupt #. For most interrupt #'s, this is a problem but it is prohibitive for the timer tick on big systems.Updating the counter causes a cache line to be bounced between cpus at a rate of at least HZ*active_cpus. (The number of bus transactions
The answer to this is probably
alloc_percpufor the counters.
Or just make noirqdebug the default.
The note_interrupt() stuff is only useful for diagnosing mysterious lockups (and hasn't proven useful for that, actually). It should be disabled for production use.
Quoted 14 lines · Andrew Morton
Quoted 13 lines · Ravikiran G Thirumalai
Quoted 10 lines · Jack Steiner
I dont know the background on
note_interrupt()inarch/ia64/kernel/irq.c, but I had to disable the function on our large systems (IA64).The function updates a counter in the
irq_desc_ttable. An entry in this table is shared by all cpus that take a specific interrupt #. For most interrupt #'s, this is a problem but it is prohibitive for the timer tick on big systems.Updating the counter causes a cache line to be bounced between cpus at a rate of at least HZ*active_cpus. (The number of bus transactions
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 1 line
The answer to this is probably
alloc_percpufor the counters.Or just make noirqdebug the default.
The
note_interrupt()stuff is only useful for diagnosing mysterious lockups (and hasn't proven useful for that, actually). It should be disabled for production use.
Probably too late for 2.6.0, but here is a patch that disables noirqdebug:
# This is a BitKeeper generated patch for the following project:
# Project Name: Linux kernel tree
# This patch format is intended for GNU patch command version 2.5 or higher. # This patch includes the following deltas:
# ChangeSet 1.1438 -> 1.1439
# arch/i386/kernel/irq.c 1.45 -> 1.46
# arch/mips/kernel/irq.c 1.14 -> 1.15
# arch/ppc64/kernel/irq.c 1.36 -> 1.37
# arch/ia64/kernel/irq.c 1.31 -> 1.32
#
# The following is the BitKeeper ChangeSet Log
# --------------------------------------------
# 03/11/14 [email protected] 1.1439
# Change the default value for "irqdebug" so that it is disabled. # Rename option from "noirqdebug" to "irqdebug".
# --------------------------------------------
#
arch/i386/kernel/irq.c +6 -6
@@ -259,16 +259,16 @@ } } -static int noirqdebug; +static int irqdebug; -static int __init noirqdebug_setup (char *str) +static int __init irqdebug_setup (char *str) { - noirqdebug =1 ; -printk ("IRQ lockup detection disabled\n" ); + irqdebug =1 ; +printk ("IRQ lockup detection enabled\n" );return 1 ; } -__setup ("noirqdebug" , noirqdebug_setup); +__setup ("irqdebug" , irqdebug_setup);/* * If 99,900 of the previous 100,000 interrupts have not been handled then
@@ -484,7 +484,7 @@spin_unlock (&desc->lock); action_ret =handle_IRQ_event (irq, ®s, action);spin_lock (&desc->lock); -if (!noirqdebug) +if (irqdebug)note_interrupt (irq, desc, action_ret);if (likely (!(desc->status &IRQ_PENDING )))break ;
arch/ia64/kernel/irq.c +7 -7
@@ -283,16 +283,16 @@ } } -static int noirqdebug; +static int irqdebug; -static int __init noirqdebug_setup (char *str) +static int __init irqdebug_setup (char *str) { - noirqdebug =1 ; -printk ("IRQ lockup detection disabled\n" ); + irqdebug =1 ; +printk ("IRQ lockup detection enabled\n" );return 1 ; } -__setup ("noirqdebug" , noirqdebug_setup); +__setup ("irqdebug" , irqdebug_setup);/* * If 99,900 of the previous 100,000 interrupts have not been handled then
@@ -457,7 +457,7 @@ desc->handler->ack (irq); action_ret =handle_IRQ_event (irq, regs, desc->action); desc->handler->end (irq); -if (!noirqdebug) +if (irqdebug)note_interrupt (irq, desc, action_ret); }else {spin_lock (&desc->lock);
@@ -504,7 +504,7 @@spin_unlock (&desc->lock); action_ret =handle_IRQ_event (irq, regs, action);spin_lock (&desc->lock); -if (!noirqdebug) +if (irqdebug)note_interrupt (irq, desc, action_ret);if (!(desc->status &IRQ_PENDING ))break ;
arch/mips/kernel/irq.c +6 -6
@@ -191,16 +191,16 @@ } } -static int noirqdebug; +static int irqdebug; -static int __init noirqdebug_setup (char *str) +static int __init irqdebug_setup (char *str) { - noirqdebug =1 ; -printk ("IRQ lockup detection disabled\n" ); + irqdebug =1 ; +printk ("IRQ lockup detection enabled\n" );return 1 ; } -__setup ("noirqdebug" , noirqdebug_setup); +__setup ("irqdebug" , irqdebug_setup);/* * If 99,900 of the previous 100,000 interrupts have not been handled then
@@ -396,7 +396,7 @@spin_unlock (&desc->lock); action_ret =handle_IRQ_event (irq, regs, action);spin_lock (&desc->lock); -if (!noirqdebug) +if (irqdebug)note_interrupt (irq, desc, action_ret);if (likely (!(desc->status &IRQ_PENDING )))break ;
arch/ppc64/kernel/irq.c +6 -6
@@ -416,16 +416,16 @@ } } -static int noirqdebug; +static int irqdebug; -static int __init noirqdebug_setup (char *str) +static int __init irqdebug_setup (char *str) { - noirqdebug =1 ; -printk ("IRQ lockup detection disabled\n" ); + irqdebug =1 ; +printk ("IRQ lockup detection enabled\n" );return 1 ; } -__setup ("noirqdebug" , noirqdebug_setup); +__setup ("irqdebug" , irqdebug_setup);/* * If 99,900 of the previous 100,000 interrupts have not been handled then
@@ -538,7 +538,7 @@spin_unlock (&desc->lock); action_ret =handle_irq_event (irq, regs, action);spin_lock (&desc->lock); -if (!noirqdebug) +if (irqdebug)note_interrupt (irq, desc, action_ret);if (likely (!(desc->status &IRQ_PENDING )))break ;
Signature · 4 lines
Thanks Jack Steiner ([email protected]) 651-683-5302 Principal Engineer SGI - Silicon Graphics, Inc.
Quoted 2 lines · Jack Steiner
Probably too late for 2.6.0
Hard to see how it can break anything; I'll queue it up, thanks.
Quoted 1 line
but here is a patch that disables noirqdebug:
No update to Documentation/kernel-parameters.txt! No cookie for you.
Quoted 9 lines · Andrew Morton
Quoted 2 lines · Jack Steiner
Probably too late for 2.6.0
Hard to see how it can break anything; I'll queue it up, thanks.
Quoted 1 line
but here is a patch that disables noirqdebug:
No update to
Documentation/kernel-parameters.txt! No cookie for you.
Do I get my cookie now :-)
# This is a BitKeeper generated patch for the following project:
# Project Name: Linux kernel tree
# This patch format is intended for GNU patch command version 2.5 or higher. # This patch includes the following deltas:
# ChangeSet 1.1439 -> 1.1440
# Documentation/kernel-parameters.txt 1.31 -> 1.32
#
# The following is the BitKeeper ChangeSet Log
# --------------------------------------------
# 03/11/14 [email protected] 1.1440
# Update documentation for irqdebug.
# --------------------------------------------
#
Documentation/kernel-parameters.txt +3 -3
@@ -427,6 +427,9 @@ ips= [HW,SCSI] Adaptec / IBM ServeRAID controller See header of drivers/scsi/ips.c. + irqdebug [IA-32] Enables the code which attempts to detect and + disable unhandled interrupt sources. + isapnp= [ISAPNP] Format: <RDP>, <reset>, <pci_scan>, <verbosity>
@@ -624,9 +627,6 @@ no-hlt [BUGS=IA-32] Tells the kernel that the hlt instruction doesn't work correctly and not to use it. - - noirqdebug [IA-32] Disables the code which attempts to detect and - disable unhandled interrupt sources. noisapnp [ISAPNP] Disables ISA PnP code.
Signature · 4 lines
Thanks Jack Steiner ([email protected]) 651-683-5302 Principal Engineer SGI - Silicon Graphics, Inc.
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line · Jack Steiner
Jack> Probably too late for 2.6.0, but here is a patch that disables Jack> noirqdebug:
The ia64-portion looks good to me. Andrew, if you queue this patch, please feel free to include the ia64-portion.
Thanks,
--david
Quoted 6 lines · Jack Steiner
Quoted 4 lines
The
note_interrupt()stuff is only useful for diagnosing mysterious lockups (and hasn't proven useful for that, actually). It should be disabled for production use.Probably too late for 2.6.0, but here is a patch that disables noirqdebug:
Why do people hate irqdebug?
Sure, there's some overhead on big machines, but there aren't that many of them, and you can just disable them for those.
The fact is, irqdebug _has_ resulted in a few reports where instead of a silent and total lock-up, the kernel just said "I'll disable this irq" and the machine continued limping along.
Which is a huge improvement, since otherwise especially newcomers really have nothing to even report. Just "it locked up at boot" is not very useful, while a "it said nobody cared about irq5 and now my PCMCIA card doesn't work" is a _huge_ cluebat.
It doesn't catch everything, but it doesn't really cost anything on any normal machines either..
Linus
Quoted 1 line · Linus Torvalds
The fact is, irqdebug _has_ resulted in a few reports where instead of a silent and total lock-up, the kernel just said "I'll disable this irq" and the machine continued limping along.
I strongly agree.
There are two huge reasons I develop and debug drivers solely in 2.6 now: kksymoops and irqdebug. Both have helped a great deal in tracking down problems. Indeed, screaming irqs that lead to lockups are instantly detected in 2.6.
But hey... I'm just a developer. Who can say whether it should be on by default?
Jeff
Quoted 2 lines
Probably too late for 2.6.0, but here is a patch that disables noirqdebug:
Why dont you just disable it during boot somewhere in sgi ia64 specific code? It doesnt seem right to disable this after all the driver effort it took to make it work.
And yes Im a paid up member of the "we build stupidly big machines" club. I'll disable where applicable in ppc64 specific code.
Anton
Quoted 9 lines · Anton Blanchard
Quoted 2 lines
Probably too late for 2.6.0, but here is a patch that disables noirqdebug:
Why dont you just disable it during boot somewhere in sgi ia64 specific code? It doesnt seem right to disable this after all the driver effort it took to make it work.
And yes Im a paid up member of the "we build stupidly big machines" club. I'll disable where applicable in ppc64 specific code.
Since the problem only starts when the cache line bounces between the CPUs, then it might be better to just disable if more than 150 processors are detected?
If it's a layering voilation to disable this during SMP init, then maybe there can be a smp-quirks.c file where exceptions can be put.