More on the intel8x0 resume problems.
As I reported earlier, intel8x0 fails to resume properly on my Dell I8200 with alsa >= 0.9.7
This is due to the fact that snd_intel8x0_ich_chip_init() no longer waits that extra 1/4 second it used to in 0.9.6 and ealier. It seems to believe that all the codecs are ready, but apparently they are not.
I tried to look into this a bit further and found that:
In intel8x0_resume() there are two ac97 codecs actually resumed on my machine (I suppose that these are precisely the primary and secondary ones that snd_intel8x0_ich_chip_init() has waited for already), indexed 0 and 1.
When resuming ac97 no. 0, in snd_ac97_resume() there are quite a few registers that do not get set properly. For example, here's a bit of my debugging messages:
Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 2: c0c 8000 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 6: 801f 8000 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register a: 801e 0 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register c: 801f 8008 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register e: 801f 8008 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 10: 9f1f 8808 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 12: 9f1f 8808 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 14: 9f1f 8808 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 16: 9f1f 8808 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 18: 1010 8808 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 1c: 0 8000 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 1e: 0 8000
The first value is the one read from the register after writing into it, the second is what was written.
On the other hand, if I just add a hard-coded 1/4 second wait before snd_ac97_resume(), emulating the good old days, I only get:
Nov 19 00:00:26 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 2a: 9 209
And the sound resumes fine.
The other ac97, indexed 1, seems to be indifferent to whether I resume it with or without such a delay.
So I believe the problem is that codec no. 0 is not waited for properly, even though it reports to be ready... Could that be?
Please help me out here.
Thanks,
Itay
__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Protect your identity with Yahoo! Mail AddressGuard
http://antispam.yahoo.com/whatsnewfree
-------------------------------------------------------
This SF.net email is sponsored by: SF.net Giveback Program. Does SourceForge.net help you be more productive? Does it help you create better code? SHARE THE LOVE, and help us help YOU! Click Here: http://sourceforge.net/donate/
At Tue, 18 Nov 2003 21:16:44 -0800 (PST),
Quoted 29 lines · Itay Ben-Yaacov
As I reported earlier, intel8x0 fails to resume properly on my Dell I8200 with alsa >= 0.9.7
This is due to the fact that
snd_intel8x0_ich_chip_init()no longer waits that extra 1/4 second it used to in 0.9.6 and ealier. It seems to believe that all the codecs are ready, but apparently they are not.I tried to look into this a bit further and found that:
Inintel8x0_resume()there are two ac97 codecs actually resumed on my machine (I suppose that these are precisely the primary and secondary ones thatsnd_intel8x0_ich_chip_init()has waited for already), indexed 0 and 1.When resuming ac97 no. 0, in
snd_ac97_resume()there are quite a few registers that do not get set properly. For example, here's a bit of my debugging messages:Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 2: c0c 8000 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 6: 801f 8000 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register a: 801e 0 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register c: 801f 8008 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register e: 801f 8008 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 10: 9f1f 8808 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 12: 9f1f 8808 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 14: 9f1f 8808 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 16: 9f1f 8808 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 18: 1010 8808 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 1c: 0 8000 Nov 18 23:58:24 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 1e: 0 8000
Quoted 2 lines
The first value is the one read from the register after writing into it, the second is what was written.
hmm, i guess in reverse, the left is the value written and the right is the value read ?
Quoted 6 lines
On the other hand, if I just add a hard-coded 1/4 second wait before
snd_ac97_resume(), emulating the good old days, I only get:Nov 19 00:00:26 pisica kernel: PEZZ: bad register 2a: 9 209
Quoted 7 lines
And the sound resumes fine.
The other ac97, indexed 1, seems to be indifferent to whether I resume it with or without such a delay.
So I believe the problem is that codec no. 0 is not waited for properly, even though it reports to be ready... Could that be?
yes, it's likely.
could you try the attached patch?
it's to cvs but of course applicable to the new 1.0.0-pre1, too.
also, i'd like to ask you to test 1.0.0-pre1, because we have clean up the handling of multiple codecs of intel8x0 driver, but it's not tested well. please check whether it works for you.
thanks,
Takashi