Promise 20378 + 2.6.0-test10 + libata patch 1
Quoted 1 line
No plans.
Curiious: How come when I disable RAID support in the BIOS and just have it <supposedly> act just like a dumb IDE controller, why aren't the drives aren't recognized that way? The BIOS claims it is plugging them in as plain IDE drives, or is something still different about this controller, even in that mode?
Quoted 1 line
Using standard kernel drivers, Promise RAID _is_ md.
<confused> I understand what md is, but I don't understand how Promise RAID is md. If I set the controller to RAID in the BIOS, and I configure a RAID 1 mirror, for example, how is that md? In this mode, isn't one copy of the data being sent to the controller and the controller "intelligence" figures out that one copy of the data goes to each drive? Where is if it were providing two drives to the OS, the md driver would have to send two copies of the data across the bus, one to each drive?
Perhaps this is a dumb question, but why are these RAID controller companies seemingly making this so difficult? To me it seems like the most logical way to design these controllers would be to make them look like standard IDE controllers to the system and hide the RAID complexities inside the controller intelligence. The most expensive part of these controllers for the manufacturers has to be in providing drivers and support for all the different, primarily MS, OSes. I must be missing something.
_________________________________________________________________
Gift-shop online from the comfort of home at MSN Shopping! No crowds, free parking. http://shopping.msn.com
Quoted 7 lines · Joe Blow
Quoted 1 line
No plans.
Curiious: How come when I disable RAID support in the BIOS and just have it <supposedly> act just like a dumb IDE controller, why aren't the drives aren't recognized that way? The BIOS claims it is plugging them in as plain IDE drives, or is something still different about this controller, even in that mode?
Under Windows, the Promise driver, that you loaded, assumes that they are being used as a RAID controller. If you unload the driver, you can use the two IDE channels as IDE channels under Windows 2000 and Windows XP.
Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Using standard kernel drivers, Promise RAID _is_ md.
<confused> I understand what md is, but I don't understand how Promise RAID is md. If I set the controller to RAID in the BIOS, and I configure a RAID 1 mirror, for example, how is that md? In this mode, isn't one copy of the data being sent to the controller and the controller "intelligence" figures out that one copy of the data goes to each drive? Where is if it were providing two drives to the OS, the md driver would have to send two copies of the data across the bus, one to each drive?
Repeat after me... Hardware raid is smart, wonderful, and expensive. Software raid is cheap, the controller card is dumb, and is what people put on motherboards, and inexpensive controller cards.
There are two IDE controller channels on the Promise RAID controller card, a bios chip, and not much else. They have no processor.
The bios is only used for booting, since the operating system drivers aren't loaded yet. Once booted, the Windows driver pretends it is a hardware Raid, by using software in the driver (I.E. Software Raid). Linux uses the md driver to map access to the of drives, which it makes into a Raid set (I.E. Software Raid).
Quoted 9 lines
Perhaps this is a dumb question, but why are these RAID controller companies seemingly making this so difficult? To me it seems like the most logical way to design these controllers would be to make them look like standard IDE controllers to the system and hide the RAID complexities inside the controller intelligence. The most expensive part of these controllers for the manufacturers has to be in providing drivers and support for all the different, primarily MS, OSes. I must be missing something.
A hardware Raid card is a complete computer, that happens to plug into your PCI bus, and it has a software Raid driver. It frequently costs more than the motherboard it is plugged in to.
Paul