USB Zip drive kills ps2 mouse.
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
| From: walt | To: Linux Kernel <[email protected]> | Subject: [2.6.x] USB Zip drive kills ps2 mouse. | | | Could I ask anyone with a USB Zip drive and a ps2 mouse to try | to confirm this bizarre bug for me? | | To reproduce it should be simple: | | 1) Compile USB support as modular, *not* compiled in. | | 2) The USB Zip drive *must* be plugged in during boot. | This bug won't show if you plug in the drive later. | | 3) Reboot and see if your ps2 mouse works.
Hi,
I'm not seeing a problem with this. I'm using 2.6.4-rc1.
However, you didn't mention what modules were being loaded automatically, so we could have a difference in that area. If you care to specify a module list, I can test it again.
And is your USB Zip drive on a UHCI or OHCI controller? I have both, so I can test it either way.
--
~Randy
Quoted 13 lines · Randy.Dunlap
| From: walt | To: Linux Kernel <[email protected]> | Subject: [2.6.x] USB Zip drive kills ps2 mouse. | | | Could I ask anyone with a USB Zip drive and a ps2 mouse to try | to confirm this bizarre bug for me? | | To reproduce it should be simple: | | 1) Compile USB support as modular, *not* compiled in. | | 2) The USB Zip drive *must* be plugged in during boot. | This bug won't show if you plug in the drive later. | | 3) Reboot and see if your ps2 mouse works.Hi,
Quoted 8 lines
I'm not seeing a problem with this. I'm using 2.6.4-rc1.
However, you didn't mention what modules were being loaded automatically, so we could have a difference in that area. If you care to specify a module list, I can test it again.
And is your USB Zip drive on a UHCI or OHCI controller? I have both, so I can test it either way.
I've narrowed it down to the uhci_hcd module -- all the rest can be compiled in or as modules, doesn't matter.
Just in case I was vague: the Zip drive works great regardless -- it's only the ps2 mouse which is affected by this weird problem. No cursor movement at all if the Zip is plugged in during boot.
ASUS A7V8X mobo, in case it matters:
00:10.0 USB Controller: VIA Technologies, Inc. VT6202 [USB 2.0 controller] (rev 80) 00:10.1 USB Controller: VIA Technologies, Inc. VT6202 [USB 2.0 controller] (rev 80) 00:10.2 USB Controller: VIA Technologies, Inc. VT6202 [USB 2.0 controller] (rev 80) 00:10.3 USB Controller: VIA Technologies, Inc. USB 2.0 (rev 82)
Things that make no difference to this problem: ACPI, PnP, udev versus devfs. I'm also using 2.6.4-rc1. I have not tested for this bug on any 2.6.x prior to a week ago, but I have tried recent 2.4.x kernels and I do not see this bug with them.
Thanks for any suggestions!
Quoted 6 lines
I've narrowed it down to the
uhci_hcdmodule -- all the rest can be compiled in or as modules, doesn't matter.Just in case I was vague: the Zip drive works great regardless -- it's only the ps2 mouse which is affected by this weird problem. No cursor movement at all if the Zip is plugged in during boot.
I don't know if it's related, but whenever I load the uhci_hcd module on my laptop, or whenever I plug in a USB device while that module is loaded (sorry, I forget which and can't test it now) - the floppy disk motor and light are turned on for a couple of seconds!
Now, why would a USB event trigger the floppy disk motor? It doesn't happen with 2.4, and it doesn't happen on my desktop machine which is OHCI+EHCI.
Perhaps the uhci_hcd driver is trampling on some ISA I/O port that it shouldn't be, which is causing both my floppy motor oddity and your mouse problem?
-- Jamie
Quoted 16 lines · Jamie Lokier
Quoted 6 lines
I've narrowed it down to the
uhci_hcdmodule -- all the rest can be compiled in or as modules, doesn't matter.Just in case I was vague: the Zip drive works great regardless -- it's only the ps2 mouse which is affected by this weird problem. No cursor movement at all if the Zip is plugged in during boot.
I don't know if it's related, but whenever I load the
uhci_hcdmodule on my laptop, or whenever I plug in a USB device while that module is loaded (sorry, I forget which and can't test it now) - the floppy disk motor and light are turned on for a couple of seconds!Now, why would a USB event trigger the floppy disk motor? It doesn't happen with 2.4, and it doesn't happen on my desktop machine which is OHCI+EHCI.
Quoted 5 lines
Perhaps the
uhci_hcddriver is trampling on some ISA I/O port that it shouldn't be, which is causing both my floppy motor oddity and your mouse problem?-- Jamie
No, the uhci-hcd driver isn't stepping on any extraneous ISA I/O ports.
Walt's problem was the result of a buggy BIOS, and turning off legacy USB support in the BIOS fixed it. Maybe your problem is similar, though it's hard to imagine how.
I've got 3 computers with UHCI controllers. On none of them does a USB event cause the floppy disk drive to do anything.
Alan Stern