udev versus parallel-port Zip drive
I've been fiddling with Zip-drive support -- both USB and parallel-port.
When I compile everything as modules I find that the parallel-port driver for Zip drives (ppa) does not load automatically. To make the parallel Zip drive work I need to do a 'modprobe ppa' manually, after which everything works as expected.
I can only imagine the complexity involved in figuring out what is attached to the parallel port at boot-time -- there must be thousands of possibilities to sort through.
My question, I suppose, is: what are the chances that a parallel-port device can be automatically detected by udev and the appropriate module loaded? Is this a pipe-dream? Or maybe it should already work and I'm just omitting some important steps?
Any thoughts or suggestions?
Quoted 13 lines · walt
I've been fiddling with Zip-drive support -- both USB and parallel-port.
When I compile everything as modules I find that the parallel-port driver for Zip drives (ppa) does not load automatically. To make the parallel Zip drive work I need to do a 'modprobe ppa' manually, after which everything works as expected.
I can only imagine the complexity involved in figuring out what is attached to the parallel port at boot-time -- there must be thousands of possibilities to sort through.
Quoted 5 lines
My question, I suppose, is: what are the chances that a parallel-port device can be automatically detected by udev and the appropriate module loaded? Is this a pipe-dream? Or maybe it should already work and I'm just omitting some important steps?
udev does no device discovery. Please, please, please, please remember this.
udev has nothing to do with this issue.
Here's a little sign to print out for the next time someone tries to bring this issue up:
********************************** * udev does no device discovery! * **********************************
thanks,
greg k-h
Quoted 11 lines · Greg KH
Quoted 2 lines · walt
the parallel-port driver for Zip drives (ppa) does not load automatically...
Here's a little sign to print out for the next time someone tries to bring this issue up:
********************************** * udev does no device discovery! * **********************************
Okayokayokay! I admit it was a dumb question. Now that you point it out to me with a two-by-four-to-the-forehead I see that udev is a user- space thing, and devices are a kernel-space thing -- so it was a dumb question. Guilty as charged :-(
Innovators are always frustrated with dumb questions from people who Don't Understand The Problem. Users are frustrated with innovators who don't understand the dumb users. C'est la vie! Both groups pay the price for.......whatever it is we pay the price for...
Every dumb question can teach you something about being an innovator. (The proof is left as an exercise for the reader...)
Quoted 2 lines · walt
My question, I suppose, is: what are the chances that a parallel-port device can be automatically detected
0
Quoted 13 lines · walt
I've been fiddling with Zip-drive support -- both USB and parallel-port.
When I compile everything as modules I find that the parallel-port driver for Zip drives (ppa) does not load automatically. To make the parallel Zip drive work I need to do a 'modprobe ppa' manually, after which everything works as expected.
I can only imagine the complexity involved in figuring out what is attached to the parallel port at boot-time -- there must be thousands of possibilities to sort through.
Quoted 6 lines
My question, I suppose, is: what are the chances that a parallel-port device can be automatically detected by udev and the appropriate module loaded? Is this a pipe-dream? Or maybe it should already work and I'm just omitting some important steps?
You can have a look at sys-apps/discover or sys-apps/kudzu for this.
Regards,
Signature · 1 line
Martin Schlemmer