Skip to contentSkip to conversation

_PAGE_PCD bit in DMAable memory

DISCUSSION fc scsi 2 participants 3 messages May 17, 2004

lore
Share & tools
lore

fc scsi

author
#0 lore raw

Hi,

I am trying to get DMAable memory on i386 (kmalloc(GFP_DMA,)) but seems
_PAGE_PCD is not set on the pages that i get back the memory from. Am I
getting the correct results? If yes, then is it not that GFP_DMA should
give me non-cacheable memory (equivalent to setting _PAGE_PCD along
with _PAGE_PWT on i386). Can anyone confirm for me that GFP_DMA will
*always* give me non-cacheable and contiguous memory.

Many thanks in advance.

__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
SBC Yahoo! - Internet access at a great low price.
http://promo.yahoo.com/sbc/

#1 lore raw

fc> Hi, I am trying to get DMAable memory on i386
fc> (kmalloc(GFP_DMA,)) but seems _PAGE_PCD is not set on the fc> pages that i get back the memory from. Am I getting the fc> correct results? If yes, then is it not that GFP_DMA should fc> give me non-cacheable memory (equivalent to setting _PAGE_PCD fc> along with _PAGE_PWT on i386). Can anyone confirm for me that fc> GFP_DMA will *always* give me non-cacheable and contiguous fc> memory.

On i386, the GFP_DMA flag controls _where_ the memory will be allocated, namely in the low 16 MB. This is really a relic of the days of 24-bit ISA DMA.

On i386, the memory does not have to be non-cacheable, since in the PC architecture the bus controller will maintain consistency by snooping the CPU. However, to be portable, your code should use pci_alloc_consistent() to get memory for DMAing. This will do the right thing on all platforms, including making sure that the memory is non-cacheable on architectures where the bus controller does not snoop.

(By the way, kmalloc() will always return contiguous memory, but you should still use pci_alloc_consistent for DMA memory)

- Roland

author
#2 lore raw

Hi,

Thanks for the reply and the information. Actually, the code will have to run on Intel Xscale processor(ARM based). Since I don't have Linux running on the board as of now, I was trying out things on my i386 machine to get non-cacheable memory. That was when I thought that GFP_DMA should give me non-cacheable memory(_PAGE_PCD on i386 should be set for such a memory, and L_PTE_CACHEABLE should be clear on Xscale by this analogy). But, as you have explained _PAGE_PCD need not be set for non-cacheable memory for i386. I am new to Xscale architecture and don't know if pci_alloc_consistent() will give me non-cacheable memory or not. Can anyone who has worked on Xscale confirm this.

Another curiousity for me is, if pci_alloc_consistent() gives non-cacheable memory for Xscale(arm) then will the L_PTE_CACHEABLE bit set in it or not?

Anyway, thanks Roland for the previous answer. It was a great help.

Regards.

Quoted 35 lines · --- Roland Dreier

fc> Hi, I am trying to get DMAable memory on
i386
fc> (kmalloc(GFP_DMA,)) but seems _PAGE_PCD is
not set on the
fc> pages that i get back the memory from. Am I
getting the
fc> correct results? If yes, then is it not that
GFP_DMA should
fc> give me non-cacheable memory (equivalent to
setting _PAGE_PCD
fc> along with _PAGE_PWT on i386). Can anyone
confirm for me that
fc> GFP_DMA will *always* give me non-cacheable
and contiguous
fc> memory.

On i386, the GFP_DMA flag controls _where_ the memory will be
allocated, namely in the low 16 MB. This is really a relic of the
days of 24-bit ISA DMA.

On i386, the memory does not have to be non-cacheable, since in the PC
architecture the bus controller will maintain consistency by snooping
the CPU. However, to be portable, your code should use
pci_alloc_consistent() to get memory for DMAing. This will do the
right thing on all platforms, including making sure that the memory is
non-cacheable on architectures where the bus controller does not snoop.

Quoted 6 lines

(By the way, kmalloc() will always return contiguous memory, but you
should still use pci_alloc_consistent for DMA memory)

- Roland

__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
SBC Yahoo! - Internet access at a great low price.
http://promo.yahoo.com/sbc/