Skip to contentSkip to conversation

possible GPL violation by Free

DISCUSSION Glennie Vignarajah 2 participants 2 messages Oct 11, 2004

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw
Quoted 1 line · Helge Hafting

Perhaps customers can demand to _rent_ the source code too then?

 After few discussions on proad.free.adsl and on linuxfr.org
(http://linuxfr.org/~superzen/15187.html), it seems that Free _lends_ the Freebox (at no charge) while people use their Internet Access. When one stops his Internet Access abonnement, he has sent it back.
 Moreover, Freebox boots (each power cycle) over the network and downloads the OS (which seems to Linux and it's not resident). The bootstrap code used to boot over network is from Broadcom (for V4 model). So even if you can buy it, you just have a box without any OS inside.

Signature · 2 lines
Glennie
"Personne ne survit au fait d'être estimé au-dessus de sa valeur." 
#1 lore raw
Quoted 6 lines

 Moreover, Freebox boots (each power cycle) over the network and downloads the OS (which seems to Linux and it's not resident). The bootstrap code used to boot over network is from Broadcom (for V4 model). So even if you can buy it, you just have a box without any OS inside.

This is clearly a form of software distribution, regardless of who owns or
doesn't own the box the software is being distributed to. The argument then becomes who it is that's entitled to the source code.

So now the question becomes can you "lend" someone GPL'd software without
having to "lend" them the source code. It is pretty clear that this practice is illegal in the United States:

"(b)(1)(A) Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection (a), unless authorized by the owners of copyright in the sound recording or the owner of copyright in a computer program (including any tape, disk, or other medium embodying such program), and in the case of a sound recording in the musical works embodied therein, neither the owner of a particular phonorecord nor any person in possession of a particular copy of a computer program (including any tape, disk, or other medium embodying such program), may, for the purposes of direct or indirect commercial advantage, dispose of, or authorize the disposal of, the possession of that phonorecord or computer program (including any tape, disk, or other medium embodying such program) by rental, lease, or lending. Nothing in the preceding sentence shall apply to the rental, lease, or lending of a phonorecord for nonprofit purposes by a nonprofit library or nonprofit educational institution. The transfer of possession of a lawfully made copy of a computer program by a nonprofit educational institution to another nonprofit educational institution or to faculty, staff, and students does not constitute rental, lease, or lending for direct or indirect commercial purposes under this subsection."

And here's the truly hilarious part -- if not for their download scheme,
they would be exempt from this law! It goes on to list as an exception:

"(i) a computer program which is embodied in a machine or product and which cannot be copied during the ordinary operation or use of the machine or product."

IANAL.

DS