raid1 oops in 2.6.9 (debian package 2.6.9-1-686-smp)
Hi
The complete console log can be found at http://haylott.plus.com/~robbie/md-oops.txt
hde is a failed drive. In this log, hdg (the other drive in the raid1 array) is not present. This oops also occurs when hdg is present. I don't know why it tries to use hde when it has been failed for some time now. This doesn't occur with 2.6.8 (also a debian kernel). I don't have a log of the oops when hdg was present, but I can provide one if necessary.
Please let me know if there is any other information I can provide to help to debug this. For now I have removed hde and everything is working fine.
Best regards
Rob
Quoted 11 lines · Robert Murray
Hi
The complete console log can be found at http://haylott.plus.com/~robbie/md-oops.txt
hde is a failed drive. In this log, hdg (the other drive in the raid1 array) is not present. This oops also occurs when hdg is present. I don't know why it tries to use hde when it has been failed for some time now. This doesn't occur with 2.6.8 (also a debian kernel). I don't have a log of the oops when hdg was present, but I can provide one if necessary.
Quoted 3 lines
Please let me know if there is any other information I can provide to help to debug this. For now I have removed hde and everything is working fine.
On a second note: Could someone please provide an explanation of why the raid10 driver exists? People have created RAID-10 sets for years using the RAID-0 driver on top of several RAID-1 arrays - this works beautifully, it's simple, and it's easy to explain to people.
Why oh why, do we need raid10 ?
(I don't mean to bitch and moan over it - I just assume that there is a good reason for it which was somehow never conveyed, or that I overlooked in my search for this explanation)
And; if raid10 does not provide new functionality that was not possible with raid1 + raid0, why oh why does this get accepted in a stable kernel
series? (ok, 2.6 is not stable, but I assume the intention is to make
it stable eventually, and accepting new functionality does not help this process - all in all I do not understand the raid10 submission at all, but I hope to be enlightened by someone (Neil?))
Also, I'd love to add a mention of raid10 in the HOWTO, but I need to know why raid10 even exists before I can reasonably do that.
Signature · 1 line
/ jakob "baffled Software-RAID HOWTO co-author"
From: Jakob Oestergaard <[email protected]>
Date: Mon, Nov 29, 2004 at 11:07:08AM +0100
Quoted 1 line
Why oh why, do we need raid10 ?
Raid-10 allows things currently not possible with raid-0/raid-1, like spreading 2 pieces of data over 3 pieces of harddisk.
Their was an introductory message on the linux-raid mailinglist, but it's more than one month old so I don't have a local copy.
Quoted 3 lines
And; if raid10 does not provide new functionality that was not possible with raid1 + raid0, why oh why does this get accepted in a stable kernel series?
New drivers that are not enabled by default have always been allowed in stable kernels, since they don't have an impact on stability for the average user.
My $0.02,
Jurriaan
Signature · 3 lines
If something was not wrong things would not be right.
Sergeant Ortega - Zorro
Debian (Unstable) GNU/Linux 2.6.10-rc2-mm3 2x6078 bogomips load 1.44Quoted 6 lines · Jurriaan
From: Jakob Oestergaard <[email protected]>
Date: Mon, Nov 29, 2004 at 11:07:08AM +0100Quoted 1 line
Why oh why, do we need raid10 ?
Raid-10 allows things currently not possible with raid-0/raid-1, like spreading 2 pieces of data over 3 pieces of harddisk.
Sounds weird to me, but hey, that's probably just me :)
Quoted 3 lines
Their was an introductory message on the linux-raid mailinglist, but it's more than one month old so I don't have a local copy.
I must have missed it when I looked for it then - I'll look again.
Thanks!
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines
And; if raid10 does not provide new functionality that was not possible with raid1 + raid0, why oh why does this get accepted in a stable kernel series?
New drivers that are not enabled by default have always been allowed in stable kernels, since they don't have an impact on stability for the average user.
True
Signature · 1 line
/ jakob
Quoted 4 lines · On Sunday November 28, [email protected] wrote:
Hi
The complete console log can be found at
http://haylott.plus.com/~robbie/md-oops.txt
This looks like a known bug that is fixed in current 2.6.10 pre-releases.
Quoted 5 lines
hde is a failed drive. In this log, hdg (the other drive in the raid1 array) is not present. This oops also occurs when hdg is present. I don't know why it tries to use hde when it has been failed for some time now.
It tries to use hde because it sees no reason not to.
When a drive fails, md never writes to it again, so the record of it being part of a raid1 array is still there.
If it is assembled with another drive that "knows" that hde has failed, then it won't accept hde into the array. But the hdg missing, hde is the best bet it has, and it tries it anyway.
NeilBrown