non-free firmware in kernel modules, aggregation and unclear copyright notice.
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): Tx9naC.A.vTD.H5YWCB@murphy
Quoted 16 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 9 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 6 lines
The way you stop someone from distributing part of your work is by arguing that the work they are distributing is a derivative work of your work and they had no right to *make* it in the first
place. See, for example, Mulcahy v. Cheetah Learning.Quoted 5 lines
Er, that's one way, but not *the* way. I could grant you permission to create derivatives of my work, but not to redistribute them. To stop you from distributing them, I'd argue that you had no right to distribute them--you *did* have the right to make it in the first place.
Quoted 4 lines
You could do that be means of a contract, but I don't think you could it do by means of a copyright license. The problem is that there is no right to control the distribution of derivative works for you to withhold from me.
Wrong, sorry. Copyright is a *monopoly* on some activities (copy, distribution of copies, making *and* distribution of derivative works).
HTH,
Massa
Quoted 18 lines · Humberto Massa
Quoted 16 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 14 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 6 lines
The way you stop someone from distributing part of your work is by arguing that the work they are distributing is a derivative work of your work and they had no right to *make* it in the first
place. See, for example, Mulcahy v. Cheetah Learning.Er, that's one way, but not *the* way. I could grant you permission to create derivatives of my work, but not to redistribute them. To stop you from distributing them, I'd argue that you had no right to distribute them--you *did* have the right to make it in the first place.
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 4 lines
You could do that be means of a contract, but I don't think you could it do by means of a copyright license. The problem is that there is no right to control the distribution of derivative works for you to withhold from me.
Wrong, sorry. Copyright is a *monopoly* on some activities (copy, distribution of copies, making *and* distribution of derivative works).
Copyright law only _explicitly_ grants a monopoly on preparation of derivative works. However, it is trivial, and overwhelmingly common, for a copyright owner to grant a license to create a derivative work that is conditional on how the licensee agrees to distribute (or not distribute) the derivative work.
Michael Poole
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 5 lines
You could do that be means of a contract, but I don't think you could it do by means of a copyright license. The problem is that there is no right to control the distribution of derivative works for you to withhold from me.
Wrong, sorry. Copyright is a *monopoly* on some activities (copy, distribution of copies, making *and* distribution of derivative works).
Perhaps you could cite the law that restricts to the copyright holder the
right to restrict the distribution of derivative works. I can cite the laws that restrict all those other things and clearly *don't* mention distribution of derivative works.
[from another post]
Quoted 5 lines
Copyright law only _explicitly_ grants a monopoly on preparation of derivative works. However, it is trivial, and overwhelmingly common, for a copyright owner to grant a license to create a derivative work that is conditional on how the licensee agrees to distribute (or not distribute) the derivative work.
This would, of course, only make sense if you *had* to agree to the license
to *create* the derivative work. If you were able to create the derivative work under first sale or fair use rights, then the restrictions in the contract would not apply to you.
DS
Quoted 10 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 5 lines
Copyright law only _explicitly_ grants a monopoly on preparation of derivative works. However, it is trivial, and overwhelmingly common, for a copyright owner to grant a license to create a derivative work that is conditional on how the licensee agrees to distribute (or not distribute) the derivative work.
This would, of course, only make sense if you *had* to agree to the license
to *create* the derivative work. If you were able to create the derivative work under first sale or fair use rights, then the restrictions in the contract would not apply to you.
This would, of course, only make sense if fair use or first sale rights *allow* the creation of derivative works. I have seen nothing in this thread or in the statutes to suggest that they do.
Do not forget that your copyright interest in a derivative work is limited to the creative elements which you contributed. Simply having a license (or right) to create a derivative work does not permit you to infringe the original work's copyright, which still subsists in the derivative work insofar as the derivative work contains copyrightable elements from the original work.
Even if some court agrees with your hypothesis that the compiled program is a derivative work of the source (which I doubt would happen), and you find some permission outside of the GPL to prepare that derivative work, you still need permission to copy it further.
Michael Poole
Quoted 4 lines · David Schwartz
Perhaps you could cite the law that restricts to the copyright
holder the right to restrict the distribution of derivative works. I can cite the laws that restrict all those other things and clearly *don't* mention distribution of derivative works.
17 USC 103
17 USC 106
Signature · 1 line
Raul