non-free firmware in kernel modules, aggregation and unclear copyright notice.
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Quoted 10 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 5 lines
Copyright law only _explicitly_ grants a monopoly on preparation of derivative works. However, it is trivial, and overwhelmingly common, for a copyright owner to grant a license to create a derivative work that is conditional on how the licensee agrees to distribute (or not distribute) the derivative work.
This would, of course, only make sense if you *had* to agree to the license to *create* the derivative work. If you were able to create the derivative work under first sale or fair use rights, then the restrictions in the contract would not apply to you.
If you buy a W*nd*ws install CD, you can create a derived work, e.g. an image of your installation, under the fair use rights (IANAL). Can you distribute that image freely?
Signature · 4 lines
Friendly fire isn't. Friß, Spammer: [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
Quoted 16 lines
Quoted 6 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 5 lines
Copyright law only _explicitly_ grants a monopoly on preparation of derivative works. However, it is trivial, and overwhelmingly common, for a copyright owner to grant a license to create a derivative work that is conditional on how the licensee agrees to distribute (or not distribute) the derivative work.
Quoted 6 lines
This would, of course, only make sense if you *had* to agree to the license
to *create* the derivative work. If you were able to create the derivative
work under first sale or fair use rights, then the restrictions in the contract would not apply to you.
Quoted 5 lines
If you buy a W*nd*ws install CD, you can create a derived work, e.g. an image
of your installation, under the fair use rights (IANAL). Can you distribute
that image freely?
I would say that if not for the EULA, you could transfer ownership of the
image to someone else. And if you legally acquired two copies of Windows, you could install both of them and transfer them. Otherwise, you could not sell a machine with the Windows OS installed unless you were a Microsoft OEM. Does Microsoft take the position that if you want to sell your PC, you must wipe the OS? Not that I know of.
DS
Quoted 6 lines · David Schwartz
I would say that if not for the EULA, you could transfer ownership
of the image to someone else. And if you legally acquired two copies of Windows, you could install both of them and transfer them. Otherwise, you could not sell a machine with the Windows OS installed unless you were a Microsoft OEM. Does Microsoft take the position that if you want to sell your PC, you must wipe the OS? Not that I know of.
[1] I think you've confused Microsoft's Original Equipment Manufacturer License with Microsoft's End User License Agreement.
[2] The grounds for Microsoft's EULA are much weaker than the grounds for the GPL restrctions on the production of derivative works.
At least with the GPL, you're getting something you didn't already have (rights restricted to the copyright holder -- for example, in the states, under 17 USC 106).
With Microsoft's EULA, it's not clear that you're getting anything in exchange for complying with the copyright -- at least not in the U.S. which is where Microsoft is based. You already have a number of rights (17 USC 107, 17 USC 117), and while the DMCA has put into law that you can't bypass copyright protection (17 USC 1201), it seems to allow bypassing technological defects which would prevent actions allowed under copyright.
It's probably worth noting that legal actions based on Microsoft's EULA are settled out of court -- Microsoft has a history putting a lot of direct and indirect pressure on people charged with violating the agreement and, in the rare case where someone has stood up to the pressure, of cutting their losses and settling out of court.
Signature · 1 line
Raul
Quoted 11 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 7 lines
I would say that if not for the EULA, you could transfer ownership
of the image to someone else. And if you legally acquired two copies of Windows, you could install both of them and transfer them. Otherwise, you could not sell a machine with the Windows OS installed unless you were a Microsoft OEM. Does Microsoft take the position that if you want to sell your PC, you must wipe the OS? Not that I know of.
Quoted 2 lines
[1] I think you've confused Microsoft's Original Equipment Manufacturer License with Microsoft's End User License Agreement.
I wasn't talking about the specific terms of any agreement. I was just
saying that to make this analogous to the GPL situation (which was the point of this example), you would have to ignore any shrink-wrap agreement because the GPL is not a shrink-wrap agreement and the rules for shrink-wrap agreements are totally different from the rules for license.
Quoted 2 lines
[2] The grounds for Microsoft's EULA are much weaker than the grounds for the GPL restrctions on the production of derivative works.
That doesn't matter, the GPL doesn't set the scope of its own authority.
None of what I'm saying has anything to do with the text of the GPL because the GPL can only add new rights. I'm talking strictly about the rights you automatically have if you legally possess the work under fair use and first sale.
Quoted 3 lines
At least with the GPL, you're getting something you didn't already have (rights restricted to the copyright holder -- for example, in the states, under 17 USC 106).
Yes, the GPL can give you rights you wouldn't otherwise have. A EULA can
take away rights you would otherwise have.
Quoted 8 lines
With Microsoft's EULA, it's not clear that you're getting anything in exchange for complying with the copyright -- at least not in the
U.S. which is where Microsoft is based. You already have a number of rights (17 USC 107, 17 USC 117), and while the DMCA has put into law that you can't bypass copyright protection (17 USC 1201), it seems to allow bypassing technological defects which would prevent actions allowed under copyright.
Quoted 5 lines
It's probably worth noting that legal actions based on Microsoft's EULA are settled out of court -- Microsoft has a history putting a lot of direct and indirect pressure on people charged with violating the agreement and, in the rare case where someone has stood up to the pressure, of cutting their losses and settling out of court.
In the few court cases that have directly addresses shrink-wrap and
click-wrap type agreements, I've seen them consistently upheld. However, this is not relevent to the GPL issue at all because the GPL can only give you rights you wouldn't otherwise have, it cannot take away any rights.
If you legally acquire a work free of any shrink-wrap agreement, and this
goes for all GPL'd works, you can use it. This includes any steps necessary for ordinary use, including making derivative works if that's part of the ordinary, expected use. You can also transfer any legally-acquired copy you might have, along with any and all derivative works you made in the process of ordinary use.
DS
Quoted 2 lines · David Schwartz
Yes, the GPL can give you rights you wouldn't otherwise have. A
EULA can take away rights you would otherwise have.
What compels you to agree with an EULA?
Quoted 4 lines
In the few court cases that have directly addresses shrink-wrap and
click-wrap type agreements, I've seen them consistently upheld. However, this is not relevent to the GPL issue at all because the GPL can only give you rights you wouldn't otherwise have, it cannot take away any rights.
The GPL offers you certain rights if you agree to be bound by certain conditions.
You are not compelled to agree to those conditions, but those who do not gain no rights from the GPL.
Signature · 1 line
Raul
Quoted 7 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 2 lines
Yes, the GPL can give you rights you wouldn't otherwise have. A EULA can take away rights you would otherwise have.
What compels you to agree with an EULA?
If you do not agree with the EULA, you cannot and do not acquire lawful
possession of the work.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 5 lines
In the few court cases that have directly addresses shrink-wrap and click-wrap type agreements, I've seen them consistently upheld. However, this is not relevent to the GPL issue at all because the GPL can only give
you rights you wouldn't otherwise have, it cannot take away any rights.The GPL offers you certain rights if you agree to be bound by certain conditions.
Right, and normally the way you become bound by the GPL is if you do
something that you could not acquire the right to do any other way. That's why GPL issues frequently hinge on whether you could not acquire the right any other way. Possible other ways include first sale and fair use.
Quoted 2 lines
You are not compelled to agree to those conditions, but those who do not gain no rights from the GPL.
Right, again, that's why it's important to look at whether they could have
acquired the rights any other way.
DS
This thread should probably get moved off-list soon, it's like beating the dead horse long after its flesh has decayed and its bones disintegrated to dust.
Quoted 8 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 5 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 2 lines
Yes, the GPL can give you rights you wouldn't otherwise have. A EULA can take away rights you would otherwise have.
What compels you to agree with an EULA?
If you do not agree with the EULA, you cannot and do not acquire lawful possession of the work.
Of course, one could always assert the following:
1) I went to a store
2) I found a box
3) I went to the cash register
4) I gave money to the cashier for the box
5) I took the box home
6) I opened the box and took out the contents
Now, to the end user, the above is the same procedure for purchasing a box of cereal or a piece of software, therefore the restrictions are the same. I'm not allowed to distribute the copyrightable materials, which for a cereal box is the images on the box, and for a CD is the digital data stored therein. Other than that, I can take a hammer and smash my CD/cereal, I can make a dozen copies of the CD/box-art and mount them on the wall or burn them, both of which are symbolic speech. I can make backup copies of my cereal box-art/CD too.
At what point of the above did I agree to any license? As far as I know, a license (IE: contract) is not valid for a product unless made at the point-of-sale, before exchanging money. This is especially valid since almost all computer retailers refuse refunds for opened software. When you have to open the box to see the license, that's bad, but when, as I've seen far too many times, you have to break the seal and insert the CD to even _see_ the license, it cannot be valid.
The only real point of most of the EULAs is to protect the owners copyright, which is implicitly protected in any case.
Cheers,
Kyle Moffett
-----BEGIN GEEK CODE BLOCK-----
Version: 3.12
GCM/CS/IT/U d- s++: a18 C++++>$ UB/L/X/*++++(+)>$ P+++(++++)>$ L++++(+++) E W++(+) N+++(++) o? K? w--- O? M++ V? PS+() PE+(-) Y+ PGP+++ t+(+++) 5 X R? tv-(--) b++++(++) DI+ D+ G e->++++$ h!*()>++$ r !y?(-) ------END GEEK CODE BLOCK------
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
What compels you to agree with an EULA?
Quoted 2 lines · David Schwartz
If you do not agree with the EULA, you cannot and do not acquire
lawful possession of the work.
What about cases where you pay for the software before you're allowed to see the EULA?
Signature · 1 line
Raul
Quoted 8 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 5 lines
If you buy a W*nd*ws install CD, you can create a derived work, e.g. an image
of your installation, under the fair use rights (IANAL). Can you distribute
that image freely?I would say that if not for the EULA, you could transfer ownership of the
image to someone else.
The EULA is irrelevant in germany and in many parts of the USA.
Quoted 4 lines
And if you legally acquired two copies of Windows,
you could install both of them and transfer them. Otherwise, you could not sell a machine with the Windows OS installed unless you were a Microsoft OEM.
Then it would be stupid to become a OEM. Just buy one CD and install it on each computer you sell, combined with a pre-installed ghost.
Quoted 2 lines
Does Microsoft take the position that if you want to sell your PC, you must wipe the OS? Not that I know of.
They say it's forbidden do pass even the boot loader you put on disks, they just won't sue you for just the boot loader.
Signature · 4 lines
Funny quotes: 36. You never really learn to swear until you learn to drive. Friß, Spammer: [email protected] [email protected]
Quoted 9 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 6 lines
If you buy a W*nd*ws install CD, you can create a derived work, e.g. an image
of your installation, under the fair use rights (IANAL). Can you distribute
that image freely?
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines
I would say that if not for the EULA, you could transfer
ownership of the
image to someone else.The EULA is irrelevant in germany and in many parts of the USA.
Really? I was under the impression EULA's were routinely upheld in the USA.
If you have any references for that, I'd love to hear them.
Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 5 lines
And if you legally acquired two copies of Windows,
you could install both of them and transfer them. Otherwise, you could not
sell a machine with the Windows OS installed unless you were a Microsoft OEM.Then it would be stupid to become a OEM. Just buy one CD and install it on
each computer you sell, combined with a pre-installed ghost.
You can only transfer each legally acquired copy once. The nice thing about
GPL'd works is you can easily legally acquire as many copies as you want. But for works that are sold for a price, you have to legally acquire one copy for each one you transfer. *You* cannot increase the number of copies of the work, only a lawful distributor of the work can.
If you don't want to be bound by the GPL and you want to give ten friends
copies of a Linux install disk, you could download ten copies of that disk from an FTP site, transfer them each to a floppy and destroy all other copies. You could then give those copies away under first sale rights. However, technically, if you gave out eleven copies and only legally acquired nine, you are exceeding your rights under first sale.
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Does Microsoft take the position that if you want to sell your PC, you must wipe the OS? Not that I know of.
They say it's forbidden do pass even the boot loader you put on disks, they just won't sue you for just the boot loader.
Right, but in these cases the number of copies of the work is increased by
the person. In the case of most GPL'd work, you can find any number of web sites that will do this for you. They have to comply with the GPL but you don't. (You don't have to agree to the GPL to lawfully acquire as many copies of the work as you want. Each copy can be lawfully transferred to another under first sale rights.)
If you acquire a copy of a GPL'd work that is sold for a price, and you
only buy one copy, you cannot make and distribute additional copies without complying with the GPL. Each lawfully-acquired copy can be transferred, however.
DS
Quoted 4 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 1 line
The EULA is irrelevant in germany and in many parts of the USA.
Really? I was under the impression EULA's were routinely upheld in the USA.
If you have any references for that, I'd love to hear them.
http://www.freibrunlaw.com/articles/articl22.htm
Signature · 4 lines
Top 100 things you don't want the sysadmin to say: 90. Wow....that seemed _fast_..... Friß, Spammer: [email protected] [email protected]
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines
The EULA is irrelevant in germany and in many parts of the USA.
Really? I was under the impression EULA's were routinely
upheld in the USA.
If you have any references for that, I'd love to hear them.
This wasn't a copyright case. The court only refused to uphold the
agreement because there was no oppurtunity to review the agreement before purchase. So it certainly wouldn't apply to a click-through type agreement.
This is also one ruling by a district court, and the ruling is in the
process of being appealed. Anyone relying on this and ignoring a EULA would be foolish indeed. There are several other shrink-wrap cases where courts have enforced the agreements. See, for example, Hill v. Gateway 2000 and Mortgage Plus v. DocMagic.
It is reasonable to describe this area as somewhat uncertain.
DS
Quoted 3 lines · David Schwartz
This wasn't a copyright case. The court only refused to uphold the
agreement because there was no oppurtunity to review the agreement before purchase. So it certainly wouldn't apply to a click-through type agreement.
http://www.answers.com/topic/first-sale-doctrine cites several cases, and has a very nice writeup on the current status of this issue.
In essence, you're claiming that the difference between Davidson & Associates v. Internet Gateway Inc (2004) and other cases such as Softman v. Adobe (2001) and Novell, Inc. v. CPU Distrib., Inc. (2000) is that the presence of a click-through is the determining factor. Of course, it could just as easily be something else (for example, admitting in court agreement with the license).
Does this thread have anything to do with the linux kernel at this point?
Signature · 1 line
Raul
Quoted 6 lines · Raul Miller
In essence, you're claiming that the difference between Davidson & Associates v. Internet Gateway Inc (2004) and other cases such as Softman v. Adobe (2001) and Novell, Inc. v. CPU Distrib., Inc. (2000) is that the presence of a click-through is the determining factor. Of course, it could just as easily be something else (for example, admitting in court agreement with the license).
Failure to have a click-through license means that there is no acceptance, which is a fundamental part of contract law. No acceptance, no contract, no exceptions. So yes, the difference in many of the click through license cases is whether the contract was something you couldn't avoid accepting.
There is talk these days among tech contract drafters to develop a more universal method for electronic acceptance... probably something that will be written into the Uniform Commercial Code in the next few decades (behold, the speed of legal evolution!).
-Sean
Signature · 12 lines
Sean Kellogg 2nd Year - University of Washington School of Law GPSS Senator - Student Bar Association Editor-at-Large - National ACS Blog [http://www.acsblog.org] c: 206.498.8207 e: [email protected] w: http://probonogeek.blogspot.com So, let go ...Jump in ...Oh well, what you waiting for? ...it's all right ...'Cause there's beauty in the breakdown
Quoted 3 lines · Sean Kellogg
Failure to have a click-through license means that there is no acceptance, which is a fundamental part of contract law. No acceptance, no contract, no exceptions.
False.
For example, you can indicate acceptance of the GPL by exercising the rights it grants.
Furthermore, the converse is also false: it's quite possible to install software on your machine without clicking on the click-through license. For example, someone else might install it for you. [You expect my dad to figure out how to install anything?]
Signature · 1 line
Raul
Quoted 11 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 1 line
The EULA is irrelevant in germany and in many parts of the USA.
Really? I was under the impression EULA's were routinely
upheld in the USA.
If you have any references for that, I'd love to hear them.This wasn't a copyright case. The court only refused to uphold the
agreement because there was no oppurtunity to review the agreement before purchase. So it certainly wouldn't apply to a click-through type agreement.
So you can review click-through-licenses before buying the product?
Signature · 4 lines
Funny quotes:
32. "I am" is reportedly the shortest sentence in the English language.
Could it be that "I do" is the longest sentence?
Friß, Spammer: [email protected] [email protected]