freebox possible GPL violation
Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 1 line
Why does it need to reboot when there is a new firmware ?
To use it, exactly like when you reboot your pc to change kernels.
Yes but in this case you have just rebooted. It is like when you reboot to change your kernel, the new kernel notice it is newer and reboot...
If it has an external firmware in the adsl chips for downloading the linux kernel, why after you download the new linux firmware, you need to reboot ?
I forgot to say that in case of a new firmware, you can see the upload (and flash ?) of the new firmware with ____,----- symbol on led. See step 6 of [1].
So why in case a new firmware you need to wait more time (about 10 second) that the case where there not new firmware ?
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines
How they manage to download the firmware (need led driver, ppp, http, adsl driver, atm stack, ...)
How do you think some random network card with do netbooting works ? (got a led driver, ipv4 simplified "stack", dhcp & tftp capabilities)
Just like your pc has a BIOS to search for booting devices
Adsl is far more complex than ethernet...
Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 1 line
Please suggest other mailling lists.
the one you CC at first @lists.gpl-violations.org and only this one ...
Ok, let's continue on this mailling list.
Register is needed to post, but I think it is worth to continue, to clarify how works the freebox and some wrong assuptions.
Pierre
Quoted 4 lines · Pierre Michon
Quoted 2 lines
Just like your pc has a BIOS to search for booting devices
Adsl is far more complex than ethernet...
Not complex enough so that a network boot protocol can't fit on a BIOS chip, believe me.
Quoted 3 lines
Ok, let's continue on this mailling list.
Register is needed to post, but I think it is worth to continue, to clarify how works the freebox and some wrong assuptions.
The only wrong assumptions that I see here are yours.
I don't understand why you cannot accept that the Freebox is part of the Free network infrastructure and that you are not using directly the OS but only the service that they provide.
You have to understand that this is just like if the nodes to which your mobile phone is connecting were running Linux. Just because your mobile phone is your, you cannot ask for the code of what is running on the node.
'Got it, now ?
Regards
Signature · 4 lines
Emmanuel Fleury A good compromise leaves everyone mad. -- Calvin & Hobbes (Bill Waterson)